Have your own question?

Click here to submit your question

Q: Hey Chico. Where was Coach Tom Bradley's version of "Blitzburgh" two weekends ago in Chestnut Hill? In the past, I've been critical of his game-planning in this very forum, but credit where it is due -- his blitz schemes were well-timed, came from a variety of positions and were generally very effective (granted, they were playing UCF). Is this a trend we can expect to see going into the Big Ten season, or will we soon back to putting out the red carpet so our opponents' offenses can walk right through our typical zone scheme?

One last thing -- Michael Robinson appears to be turning into a potentially elite wide receiver. With Anthony Morelli continuing to get game snaps so early in his career, is Robinson playing himself out of the chance to ultimately see full-time duty under center? Thanks Chico, keep up the great work!

Advertise with us

Mark of Methuen, Mass.

HARLAN: With the defense, I agree -- it was nice to see. There was a noticeable difference between Tom Bradley's strategy against BC and UCF. As I understand, players were thrilled with the changes. When a team blitzes and jams and forces pressure, it sends the message that coaches have confidence in their players. It establishes an aggressive mind set, and almost all football players feed off such a message. When the defense looked passive against Boston College, it resulted in some missed tackles and big plays. With a more intense strategy a week later, the defense had one of its best showings in the last four years. I would be surprised and disappointed if coaches didn't at least try to keep a good thing going. Wisconsin's offense is about as dangerous as a 9-to-5 job in a cubicle. So in short, there's no reason for Penn State to play passive defense. With star tailback Anthony Davis still sidelined because of an eye injury, the Lions would be smart to jump all over this team. I know if the players have their way, that's exactly what will happen.

As for Robinson, I think Robinson has indeed become a wideout first and foremost. If Mills was injured this season, Robinson would still likely relieve him under center. But next season, I see Robinson staying at wideout and Morelli growing into the team's new quarterback. Look at it by pure numbers. If, in 2005, Morelli plays QB and Robinson stays at WR, that automatically fills two needs for the Lions instead of one. And Morelli will be aided by having a reliable target like Robinson to throw to. Most important, perhaps, Morelli should be a better QB option by next season than Robinson. You ask if Robinson is "playing himself out" of the chance to play QB. I think it's more a matter of Morelli playing himself into the chance.

Q: Michael Robinson is routinely dubbed as the Penn State player with the most NFL-caliber talent, but it's hard to say what position he is best suited for at the next level. I remember when the Steelers drafted a kid that was used almost exactly the same in college and now he's their best offensive weapon, a Pro-Bowler, and the best blocking wide receiver in the league. Do you think Michael Robinson is better suited as an NFL quarterback or as the next Hines Ward?

Rob York of Alexandria, Va.

Advertise with us

HARLAN: Robinson was asked this week what he thinks about his position for the NFL. His answer? Whatever a team wants from him. At this point, it's almost impossible to define Robinson's position. Some NFL teams actually see him as a defensive back. But I definitely see the similarities between Robinson and Ward. At Georgia, Ward basically did the same thing Robinson is doing now. Maybe an NFL team will draw this comparison, too. But I think the longer Robinson stays at wideout, the more his position at the next level will become defined. Say he's played receiver for two consecutive seasons by 2006 NFL Draft. He'll be drafted as a received without consideration. But if Robinson must switch positions again during his last 1 ? years at Penn State, things could be muddled again.

Q: I have been an avid reader of your mailbag and I'm glad to see you're entertaining offbeat questions. So I ask you this: Joe Paterno seems to be quite a character. Some could say he should have his own sitcom. Playing off this theme, which show or role do you think he could thrive in? My guesses are either a crotchety old senator on "The West Wing," Caleb Nichol on "The O.C." or Ray Romano's dad on "Everybody Loves Raymond." Your thoughts?

Nick Donatelli of Boston

HARLAN: My only acting advice to Paterno would be this: if ESPN calls about a role in a made-for-TV movie, hang up the phone immediately.

Q: Why is it that every time Austin Scott gets in the doghouse, fans blame Paterno? I think Tony Hunt is an excellent running back, and shares at least Scott's potential. Your thoughts?

Advertise with us

Tom Joseph of Cranberry

HARLAN: Scott is a bit slower than Hunt, but other than that, I think they're comparable players. Right now, Hunt sees more playing time because he's shown himself to be more reliable. I know, at the onset of the season, there was some sentiment that Scott would inevitably overtake Hunt for the starting job. After three games, this notion is rightfully starting to dissipate. Big Ten play will provide a greater challenge for both, but right now, Hunt is the better option. Scott, though, is still worthy of getting at least a half-dozen carries per game.

Q: It certainly was tough watching Penn State's offense operate against Central Florida. A couple of comments, then some questions. It looks as though Joe has a couple of good runners in Tony Hunt and Austin Scott. He ought to make sure they get plenty of carries and stay away from running back by committee. It hasn't worked well in the past. Second, Zack Mills has got to take better care of the ball. If Penn State can get back to Paterno turnover-free football, the defense looks better (granted, lesser competition) and the offense shows promise. Let Galen Hall call all the plays, keep feeding the two young running backs to open up the defense and Mills should have more time to throw. Granted, we have a killer schedule coming up. But I honestly believe if PSU can eliminate the turnovers, the Lions can beat Wisconsin and most anyone in the Big Ten. This team could surprise some people but only if it gets the turnovers down to one a game and plays smart.

If you were Paterno, how would you handle Hunt, Scott, Robinson and Mills?

Jeff Smith of Temple Terrance, Fla.

Advertise with us

HARLAN: Nice hypothetical. If I were Paterno, Jeff, the first thing I'd do is retire. But to the point of your question, this is what I'd do: Robinson would be strictly a receiver, who'd be involved in the occasional trick play that gets me on SportsCenter. Mills would have a long leash. I think he's the team's best option at quarterback by a long distance. Morelli isn't ready yet, regardless of his arm strength and potential. And playing Robinson at quarterback takes inherently removes one of the team's top receivers, so this, in essence, stops one problem while opening another. As for Hunt and Scott, they'd go on as is. Hunt has proven himself through three games to have the edge right now. But a two-man competition in the backfield, I say, can only be beneficial.

Q: Chico, my boy, the mailbag just keep getting better and better. And what would one be without a contribution from your No. 1 fan, Ira R., who celebrated his birthday this week by having dinner with life-sized cardboard cutouts of Blair Thomas, Shane Conlan and other legends of Penn State yonder. Anyway, I'm distraught with JoePa's decision to sit down Austin Scott for a game. So he missed a practice? You can't tell me, Chico, that you haven't skipped out on work to attend one of your country concerts. You mean that you never cut a class in college?

All I'm saying is, Joe's got to cut Austin some slack, no? Whatever his troubles were -- oversleeping, homework, no clean underwear -- they're certainly no reason to bench your best player.

Ira Rothstein of East Meadow, N.Y.

HARLAN: Whoever said "dog is man's best friend" certainly never had the pleasure to keep company among cardboard cutouts. But let me be serious here, Ira. I don't think Austin Scott is, as you say, Penn State's best player. Scott's problem is, he's the team's best college student. As I recall from my college years, college students slack off and live, for the most part, free of serious repercussion, and that's become Scott's forte. (For instance, I know one buddy several years back who took a road trip to Morgantown, W.Va., got arrested for underage drinking and then returned to Syracuse with nothing but a fine to pay and a great story to tell.) Anyway, most college students live with such carefree enjoyment. But football players are different, and this is what Scott must understand. He not only represents a team and a university -- he is also accountable to dozens of teammates who need his dedication. When Scott skips meetings, it is indeed a serious offense. Playing him immediately thereafter sends the wrong message to those who do give their full dedication to the team. One or two mistakes is forgivable. After all, everybody has the occasional alarm clock malfunction or country concert that takes them away from more pressing obligations. But something tells me Scott's missed meeting was part of a bigger problem coaches saw with the sophomore. From this point forward, I'm sure Paterno wants to rely on Scott. No doubt, he'll keep careful tabs on what Scott is up to. If Scott were only an inanimate cardboard cutout, this would be so much easier.

Advertise with us

Q: I would like to know with all the talent in the backfield, why can't we switch to a wishbone type offense? We have the perfect quarterbacks, running backs and fullbacks for this type of offense. Our wide receivers are not going to get us anywhere and I feel our tight ends are big enough to do the blocking and slide out for short passes.

Warren Quinn of Pottsville, Pa.

HARLAN: Switching offenses requires far more than a whimsical decision based on a quick talent evaluation. Just because Penn State currently has a slew of running backs and a dearth of big-play wide receivers doesn't mean the team should scrap its traditional offense for something like the wishbone. That would require huge overhauls and adjustments. Galen Hall would have to essentially rewrite the playbook. Players would have to relearn the offensive system. And more long-term, young players -- especially wide receives -- who signed on to Penn State expecting one day to become vital parts of the passing offense would have legitimate reason to feel angry. A balanced offense is still the best fit for this Penn State team, and looking at the trend if college football, the wishbone is an archaic offense that's fun to watch on TV but hardly an upgrade over something more conventional.

Q: Why is Charles Rush being replaced by Scott Davis during games for an extended period of time?

James Castillo of Franklin Square, N.Y.

Advertise with us

HARLAN: Easy answer, James. Paterno feels that Rush and Davis are relatively equal players. This information came to me at Tuesday's press conference, when Paterno was asked about the guard position and provided one of the few informative answers of the afternoon. Rush is still slightly ahead, but the difference is marginal. That's why you see the two players rotate in and out. Rush is a junior; Scott is a senior, so this certainly isn't a situation where Penn State is grooming a younger player for a larger role down the line. Playing time, as I see it, is strictly being doled out based on performance. And that's the best way to do it. I'd expect Rush and Davis to keep splitting time until one definitively pulls ahead.

Q: I don't know why Paterno has Zack Mills holding for extra points. Chris Ganter did a good job for the last couple of years and he needs a little mop-up duty. Why not give Mills a rest?

Mark Wilson of Charleston, W.Va.

HARLAN: I've actually held for extra points before (OK, it was pick-up Thanksgiving Day football. . . and OK, my brother way the kicker) so I feel very qualified to answer this question. The simple fact is this, Mark, when a human being holds a football, he is not exhausting even an ounce of energy. It's just like holding a pencil or a cell phone. Holders actually sit still on the field, so I don't know how you can suggest Mills' position as the holder somehow prevents his resting. Right now, Mills is holding for extra points because coaches feel he's better at it than Ganter. The day Mills becomes too fatigued to spend time as the holder, that's when you better start worryin'.

Q: Penn State consistently has better recruiting classes than every Big Ten school expect Michigan and Ohio State, and they are recruit better than all of the current Big East schools. If it's not coaching, what is the cause of the lack of performance? West Virginia, for example, never out-recruits PSU, yet they are currently ranked in the top ten. Boston College has embarrassed PSU the last two years with players that were not as highly recruited. PSU players are also very slow to develop into top college players, which is not the case at the elite schools where top recruits develop very quickly. The entire PSU football system appears to be in disarray, which includes player development, game strategy, player confidence, etc. Maybe it is the coaching!

Advertise with us

Bob of Sharon

HARLAN: First, let me say this, Bob. I have a hard time saying Penn State definitely out-recruits every team in the Big Ten aside from Michigan and Ohio State. They recruit better in Pennsylvania than the rest of the conference, as they well should, but I contend they haven't done a good job attracting recruits from states west of Pennsylvania -- the heart of Big Ten territory. I think Penn State still does an above-average job recruiting, but much of that comes from reputation. For the longest time, they allowed the PSU tradition to work automatically. It would bring recruits to PSU without requiring coaches to show much more than passive interest. Now that the winning and the tradition has thinned somewhat, Penn State is in a recruiting adjustment period. Yes, I agree that Penn State does -- and should -- out-recruit schools like Pitt and West Virginia, but PSU's recruiting is hardly the envy of the Big Ten. That said, you still must wonder why Penn State can't regularly beat the schools it out-recruits. Indeed, I think coaching is a large part of it. But there's also something to be said for the schools that attract a smaller number of top-tier recruits, then have the luxury of developing them immediately. When a can't-miss prospect lands at an average Big East school, he'll probably play right away. He'll be the focal point. He'll be somebody to build a program around. Put a few of these at one school, and they might actually have a better chance to develop. At a school like Penn State, top recruits seemingly blend in, and in a weird way, their excellence seems to dissipate. I look at a player like Austin Scott. Just a few years ago, he headlined Penn State's recruiting class. Now, he's a backup. I think at schools more desperate for blue-chippers, his talent wouldn't be so quickly cast aside -- it would be treated with more care, because, quite simply, it's more of a rarity. Just one theory, though.

This story was originally published with images that are no longer available.