Have your own question?
Click here to submit your question
Q: Don't you think it is time to pull the plug on Zack Mills? Time and time again, he turns the ball over on critical downs in close ball games. This is not supposed to happen with quarterbacks that have played as long as he has. It is obvious he doesn't have what it takes to lead the Lions to a good season. Time to build for the future. If you are not going to redshirt Morelli, play him! Since he is the quarterback of the future and the I've heard though the grapevine that 2006 is the year the Lions make a run for the Big Ten title and national top-10 ranking, let him get the experience now.
George Hendrickson of Pittsburgh
HARLAN: I'm a Mills man, George, and I'm ready to defend him like Maximus defended Rome. I say where there's a Mills, there's a way. His arm strength is poor and his decision making suffers some lapses. But those are his only shortcomings. Trust me, you'd see a whole new host of problems if Morelli started taking the snaps. Mills gives the team excellent leadership and a stable presence. He has also shown, during his four years, the capability to have excellent games, at least from time to time. It's far too early to give up on the 2004 season, and shoving Mills aside and replacing him with Morelli would be akin to waving a white flag. That would be unjust to the dozens of seniors on this team -- the players who need this season to be great, not next year or 2006. Without question, Mills can still be an excellent player on this year's team. He's played just two games this season. In all but one half, he's played as well as possible. This is not the kind of player you pull and stick on the sideline. No doubt Morelli has a bright future, but that future ought to wait.
Q: Mr. Harlan, I disagree with your prediction of 5-6 or 6-5 for this year's Penn State squad. Penn State has one of the most talented backfields in the country, a much-improved defensive line that was thrown to the wolves last year with heavy losses to the NFL, promising young linebackers, and a solid secondary. Not to mention Galen Hall is in Happy Valley calling the offense. I have always been a JoePa supporter; however anything less than seven wins with the talent on this years team would signify that the game has passed him by.
John Gallagher of Forty Fort, Pa.
HARLAN: I agree with your assessment about this team's talent. I think it's plentiful. But many of the people I talk to think PSU is a year away. In fact, Penn State has had considerable talent the last four years -- three of which have been decidedly sub-par. Talent alone doesn't do it. As you mention, this is an important season for Joe Paterno. The season opener signaled the potential of this team. Blame will be hung on the coaching staff if that talent, then, fails to flourish. As for my original predictions, I think a 6-5 season will be a considerable stride for this team, and something that will lead to even higher expectations in 2005.
Q: OK, Chico. A question that has been bugging me for a while now: I read a wire story a few days ago with a headline that said, "Paterno, Penn State find themselves at a crossroads." Now, would this be the Bone Thugs 'N Harmony version of "Crossroads," or perhaps Bon Jovi's classic 1994 album, "Crossroads." Maybe it's the Tracy Chapman song "Crossroads," and then again it could be the television program "CMT Crossroads," where people of reputable musical tastes lend their talent to the hacks of country music. Personally, I think it's Bone. But that's just me.
Penn State 31, Central Florida 10
Ira Rothstein of East Meadow, N.Y.
HARLAN: Intriguing, Ira. Again, you deliver a query with unparalleled peculiarity. Though your question, on the surface, contains nothing but blatant nonsense, I'll try to deduce insight from the mess, much as one might search for meaning in a Rorschach inkblot. First, let's compare the various "Crossroads" in question here. Chapman, in her song, sings, "I'm standing at the crossroads of hell." I think it's a bit extreme to invoke such a statement for a football team. (Well, unless Penn State loses to Central Florida.) Bon Jovi's aforementioned album is not even a true crossroads -- so long as we're analyzing syntax (and for the record, that's exactly what we're doing), the proper name of the album is, in fact, "Cross Road." Plus, it was an exceptional album, and right now, the Lions are anything but exceptional. Strike Two. This leaves up with the Bone Thugs. Here, I find some wondrous similarities between the song and the team. The song opens with this verse: "Tell me what ya gonna do / when there ain't nowhere to run." The answer, as PSU running back Tony Hunt could tell you, is run for 2.9 yards per carry. Quickly as possible, Penn State must escape this "Crossroads," hopefully finding a more satisfying musical refuge in the process. By my opinion, they'd be wise to start with CMT.
Q: Hey Chico. Unfortunately, I was at the game in Chestnut Hill on Saturday and came away with a few observations, the abbreviated (and censored) versions of which are as follows: this squad lacks the organization that used to be a staple of even average Paterno coached teams (players constantly breaking the huddle looking around at the guy next to them to see where they're supposed to be); the O-Line can't "zone block" either; the defensive line is still too small for a D-I schedule (if BC can blow you off the ball, you've got problems); and finally, I don't think it's a coincidence that the downward spiral that has become Penn State football began with the departure of Jerry Sandusky (our defensive schemes are so transparent, even I could see what was coming from the cheap seats). Am I wrong? I sincerely want to be wrong about these (and other) things, so please Chico, tell me I'm wrong!
Mark of Methuen, Mass.
HARLAN: Congratulations, Mark. You have managed to summarize your feelings about Penn State in a 135-word sentence -- clearly, you use semicolons with more aplomb than PSU uses zone blocking. But to the point, I think your quick-hit summary is in step with many fans' concerns. I received a lot of questions this week about the offensive and defensive lines, as fans said they were either 1.) too slow, 2.) too small, 3.) too undisciplined or 4.) poorly coached. I'm not willing to pinpoint one factor, specifically. And to be fair, we shouldn't be categorizing either the D-line or the O-line as a failure just yet. The O-line was excellent against Akron; sub-par against BC. But the defensive line, for all its been maligned this week, actually held its own versus the Eagles. BC ran 40 times for 154 yards. That averages out to 3.2 yards per carry. Normally, that's a run-stopping effort you'd associate with victory. The one concern to come from last week's game was this: PSU's defense did not look aggressive. Their defensive backs played constantly in soft coverage. The team generated only one sack. And too often, Penn State couldn't make a big play when it needed just that. Perhaps this is traceable to coaching; perhaps it's more a result of lacking talent. Or, perhaps, PSU just had one bad game. We'll know more soon.
Q: Hey, Chico, fabulous coverage so far this season. I'm writing because I've become so fed up with the incompetence with Syracuse's football team, I'm looking for a new favorite. Syracuse is very, very bad, OK? Do you think Penn State might be the way to go? By the way, the last time this happened, I was fed up with pop music and settled on country as my new favorite. Let's just say that was the right choice.
James Thurber of Syracuse, N.Y.
HARLAN: You've come to the right place, James. As a Syracuse grad myself, I have a vague understanding of your predicament. But be appreciative. In truth, with the Syracuse football program now entering what I would term its "postmortem stage," the Orange have actually provided you quite a luxury: You can go anywhere to pick your next team. Penn State doesn't seem like a wise choice. If I have any grasp on the vitriol the Syracuse locals currently direct at Paul Pasqualoni, perhaps this fact will deter you from the joining blue & white: PSU is the school that spawned Coach P. So let's go elsewhere for a new team. The SEC provides the best stadiums and the best road trips, but you're probably too far, geographically, to establish much of a bond with any school there. UConn has an up-and-coming football team -- and a chic new stadium to go along with it -- but the SU-UConn basketball rivalry might offset your feelings for the Huskies' football team. So I have just the solution. The team I'm suggesting went 15-1 last year. They're an hour drive from your hometown. They almost won a national championship last year. They have some of the most loyal fans on the Earth. (I know one, and he actually covered the team.) What team am I talking about? The fightin' excitin' Colgate Red Raiders. This team just keeps winning and winning; and, as Alan Jackson says, "too much of a good thing is a good thing." Hope you find this suggestion helpful.
Q: When is Mr. Paterno going to retire?
Jerry Matsick of Jacksonville, Fla.
HARLAN: Straight from the horse's mouth, he'll coach "probably four or five more years." Oh wait -- he said that in 1973.
Q: Is it me or does JoePa always have one senior on his team that he doesn't know where to play? Tyler Valsocki switched from defensive line to offensive line to tight end and back now. Jason Robinson is doing the same thing, and I believe Gio Vendemia is next in line. No other schools make these many changes, especially with players in their last year. What is your take on this?
Mike Jones of Youngstown, Ohio
HARLAN: In truth, Mike, I have no problem with it. Paterno's logic with some of these position changes follows thusly: We need depth at a certain position? We must move somebody to fill that position? If I move a young player, I am jeopardizing that player's long-term status at his natural position? If I move a veteran who is already a spare part, I am not jeopardizing anything long-term and I am solving the short-term problem. With a guy like Robinson, Paterno isn't doing him a disservice by switching his position -- after all, it's not like Robinson will be auditioning for an NFL roster spot this fall. But by switching him from the D-line to tight end, where Penn State needs a third man for goal line plays, Paterno is certainly helping the team. So long as he finds a player willing to make the switch -- and indeed, Robinson seemed amenable -- I think the strategy of moving veteran players can be wise.
Q: Chico, I, like many fans, had a number of areas of doubt concerning the Blue & White this coming year. One area of concern for me was the O-line. Like most areas of the team, I felt the talent was there, but it was not developed and I was unsure as to the ability of the staff to develop it. After the disappointment of the BC game, I was still impressed with the line's ability to pass protect. It seemed as if Mills had plenty of time to read and react to the BC defense. My question is what happened in regard to their run blocking? They seemed to be getting pushed into the backfield on running plays (unlike the Akron game). Is this just a factor of playing against better competition, or is there another reason that could explain their proficiency at pass protection and inability to establish a running game?
Thanks for the excellent coverage...I appreciate it.
Gene Ritter of Atlanta, Ga.
HARLAN: I did not anticipate the line to struggle like it did against BC. One possible explanation is this: BC's defense really hit Penn State with a curveball last Saturday. All week leading up to the game, the Lions practiced against the blitz. They expected BC to blitz often -- both against the run and pass, as it did a year earlier in the PSU loss at Beaver Stadium. Well, instead, Boston College went an entirely different route, playing more of a sit-back-and-wait defense. In other words, everything PSU practiced for became almost irrelevant. I'd imagine this contributed to the blocking struggles last week. I still think the offensive line is talented, and I'd expect to see an improvement against UCF.
Q: Chico, I noticed that the humble burg of State College has its own creamery right on the Penn State campus. As I am one to indulge in conical icy delights, I find it interesting that Joe Paterno -- the bespectacled old ballcoach -- has his own flavor, Peachy Paterno. Are there any other legendary Penn State footballers worthy of such a distinction? What would it take for the creamery to honor them in frozen form? And -- who knows? -- perhaps they'll soon recognize your penmanship and create a flavor called Choco-Choco Chico. Keep up the whiz-bang work.
W.F. Whence of Quillstown, Mass.
HARLAN: Brilliant, W.F. Purely brilliant. Hopefully folks at The Creamery get a hold of this, because I have some more suggestions for possible flavors. Among them? BranDon SnowCone (in honor of our favorite injured linebacker), Caramorelli and Cream, (in honor of QB Anthony Morelli), Vanilla (in honor of Penn State's play-calling), Peanut Butler and Chocolate (in honor of DB Deon Butler) and Gould Medal Ribbon (in honor of K Robbie Gould). As for Choco-Choco Chico, c'mon -- that's about as likely as Nelly and Tim McGraw collaborating on an R&B record. Oh wait? You mean that already happened? I give up.
Q: Despite last weeks loss to BC, I thought the offense showed much more than last year's team, in pass protection, catching the football, etc. As for the defense? My question is, Is Tom Bradley under any real heat as defensive coordinator this year? This team still gives up way too many yards on first down and way too many long third down conversions. I got to think if Fran Ganter was allowed to get a front office type job, could Bradley be in line for a similar reassignment if this trend continues for another season? His recruiting value is strong, but his on field coaching isn't getting results.
Jerri Bullock of Beaver Falls
HARLAN: As you mention, Bradley has prime value as a recruiter. I think that makes his position on the coaching staff fairly secure. That said, when Paterno leaves or retires -- especially if PSU hires an outsider as head coach -- all job stability disappears. A new coach would be liable to bring in a whole raft of new assistants. But so long as Paterno remains PSU's head coach, I think Bradley is heat-free. Remember, let's put off the doomsday scenarios for the defense at least for another few weeks. So far, the defense has surrendered just 31 points -- not even 16 per game. They've been exceptional at stopping the big play, both on passes and runs. Even against BC, when the team let up three touchdowns, one of the BC scoring drives was bolstered by a pair of roughing-the-punter penalties. Another scoring drive was only 26 yards; it came right after a PSU turnover. Though the defense's performance was far from excellent, it wasn't exactly condemnable either.
Q: This is more of a comment than question. Your summation of the BC game reflects my sentiments exactly. This team is no different than last year's. The Akron game was purely a mirage. BC will be no more than a mediocre team in a weak conference and Penn State made them look much better than they really are. Paterno's refusal to develop a modern strength program is evident as an experienced D line got shoved up and down the field against an inexperienced BC O-line. It was sickening to watch. State's O line couldn't block anybody. This all falls on a coaching staff that refuses to mirror successful programs. A 3-8 or 4-7 year would be a success at this point. This team would be no better than a .500 team in the MAC.
Mick Fulton of Universal City, Texas
HARLAN: Harsh, Mick. Very harsh. In all seriousness, I think it's safe to say this team would be far better than .500 in the MAC. If you think otherwise, you've clearly never watched the Buffalo Bulls.
Q: How long have you been with the P-G and how long have you covered PSU football? It's nice to have a new viewpoint and, while I understand this forum can be positive or a reality check for us PSU fans, I think it can get a little old when Walt Harris is answering the questions.
Lee Pauley of Columbus, Ohio
HARLAN: As a prideful wordsmith, Lee, I am insulted. Walt Harris? Answering these questions? The old Pitt ballcoach couldn't match my sesquipedalian vocabulary if he hired Merriam Webster as his new offensive coordinator. But to answer your question, I've been working at the Post-Gazette since May. I've been covering Penn State football since the team started practicing in the summer. Thanks for your interest.
Q: Would you agree with the following assertion: Pennsylvania can best be characterized as Alabama bookended by Pittsburgh and Philly. If so, would you please answer my Penn State question. Is State College Station more similar to Auburn or Tuscaloosa? Why?
Wright T. of Kansas City, Mo.
HARLAN: Well, Mr. T. -- it is OK if I call you that, right? -- I vehemently disagree with your assertion. As any good employee of the state tourism office would tell you, Pennsylvania is a bountiful reservoir of nature, greenery and beauty. Your analogy is way off. Allow me to propose another one: In the sea of verdant mid-state wilderness, State College is an island of excitement -- let's call it Aruba with a football stadium.
This story was originally published with images that are no longer available.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.