Have your own question?
Click here to submit your question
Q: Do you think size on the defensive line will be an issue? (No players weigh at or above 300 pounds.) I hear countless reports from the staff about how quickness and technique can make up for a lack of size. But once they get worn down might all that be negated?
Richard of Southampton, N. Y.
HARLAN: A few thoughts, Richard. First, I don't believe lack of size -- and yes, Penn State does have a small defensive line -- correlates much with stamina and getting worn down. Some of the NFL's biggest players (those like Ted Washington, for instance) have difficulty staying on the field for 50-odd plays simply because they're so big. A lean and quick D-line can be quite effective, so indeed, quickness and technique, can help make up for lack of size. So can depth. As I see it, the Lions enter this season with a fairly interchangeable mix of linemen. This is both advantageous (they are deep at the position) and worrisome (nobody has really stood out enough to command keeping him on the field at all times). At times last season, it certainly looked as if the team's defensive line wore down. I attribute most of this to its inability to stop the run. In the always-reliable NCAA rankings, Penn State finished 104th out of 117 Division I teams in stopping the run. The Lions surrendered, on average, 209 yards per game. Therefore, they took a pounding simply by staying on the field so long. No defensive line can stay fresh when it's been on the field for two-thirds of the game. If the defensive line can improve its run-stopping, I think you'll see a unit where endurance never really becomes a problem.
Q: Your coverage has been delightful, though, if you'll allow me, I'd like to take on the task of delving into weekly minutiae. Such as the names of players. Being the biggest Penn State fan in America next to Sonny Mazzolini of Solon, Ohio, I've poured through each and every one of the biographies on PSU's Web site. A couple of them piqued my interest. First, in honor of BranDon Snow, I request you change your name to ChiCo Harlan for at least one story. It would be a truly watershed moment. Second, and here is the Q part of Q & A: How do you pronounce the middle name of Amani Purcell? It's spelled Ta'agamanusina, and, to be honest, I've spent 17 hours trying to figure it out -- the exact amount of time, according to the PSU Web site -- that it takes Amani to fly from State College to Pago Pago, American Samoa. Thanks.
Ira Rothstein of East Meadow, N. Y.
HARLAN: Unfortunately, Ira, the page in the Penn State media guide dedicated to player name pronunciations -- pg. 66, if you're curious -- ignores offering any help in regard to Amani Purcell's sesquipedalian middle name. Perhaps you can travel the 7,004 miles back to Pago Pago and ask his family. Then, surely, you will overtake Sonny Mazzolini as Penn State's most ardent fan.
Q: Hey Chico, Welcome to the forum? I've been enjoying your additions to the P-G, and it's nice to have a new brain to pick this year with all things PSU. That said, I'll get right to my questions -- Is Galen Hall calling all of the offensive plays this season, or will he, like Ganter in recent years, be sharing those duties with Jay Paterno? Also, with the offensive line getting out of the gates fast (albeit against Akron) this season, has the coaching staff settled on a week-in-week-out starting five, barring any injuries? Thanks Chico? keep up the good work!
Mark of Methuen, Mass.
HARLAN: First, the O-line. Coaches have indeed settled on a permanent starting five -- Levi Brown at left tackle, Charles Rush at left guard, E.Z. Smith at center, Tyler Reed at right guard and Andrew Richardson at left tackle. The unit looked excellent against Akron, so barring injuries, those five will continue to play alongside one another. I'd guess the O-line becomes a strength not just this season, but next season, too. (All five are slated to return.) Next, the play-calling, which, based on one game, looks far smoother than it ever did last year. The curious thing is, not much has changed. Last year, fans and media members figured the lack of offensive continuity stemmed from a system that forced Fran Ganter to call the running plays and Jay Paterno to call the passing plays. This year, Hall calls plays on first- and second- down. Paterno calls the third-down passing plays. So indeed, there's still something of a power-sharing system. It's just working better.
Q: How does Penn State plan its recruiting efforts? Said differently, in this age of specialization, how can the Lions end up with so few linebackers, proven tight ends, or experienced wideouts?
Bill of Bala Cynwyd, Pa.
HARLAN: High schoolers choose other schools. Recruiting efforts fail. Players arrive at State College and never pan out. Players quit the team. Players switch positions. There are so many variables, Bill, that account for a current team's depth (or lack thereof), it's almost impossible to pinpoint the exact shortcomings. At wideout, for instance, Maurice Humphrey, who PSU coaches were likely planning a future around 1 ? years ago, is no longer with the team. I don't think the team's current weaknesses at certain positions can be traced to a lack of planning at the recruiting level. Every year, coaches determine the positions they need to address, but even this is mostly speculative, because the help from incoming freshmen is never immediate. With recruiting, you are planning two and three years down the road. When such a gap in time between planning and results, it's never an exact science.
Q: Mr. Harlan, I'm a big fan of your mailbag, but remain baffled by the constant questions about country music. Let's talk about something relevant. Like Penn State football. If you were a betting man, who would you say will win more games this season in the glorious state of Pennsylvania? The Pittsburgh Steelers? Or the Penn State Nittany Lions? I'm going with Joe Pa. Penn State wins six games. Steelers win four. Any thoughts? And keep that country music where it belongs -- in trailer parks.
Greg B. of Seattle, Wash.
HARLAN: Penn State wins six. Steelers win nine. Both are left wishing they had half the year Toby Keith did.
Q: Preseason predictions are so?predictable. It seems that the experts on television and in the newspapers just look at last year and knock it up or down a notch and that's how you get guesses like yours (5-6 for Penn State). After the Akron game, seeing a senior quarterback with his mojo back, a healthy offensive line and crispness and enthusiasm all the way around, do you want to reconsider your prediction for the '04 campaign? Yeah, I know, it was Akron, but PSU looked like a wet kitten against Temple last year and my 6-year-old daughter would be a capable back-up center for Temple. Your thoughts?
Curt Leonard of Tallahassee, Fla.
HARLAN: If your 6-year-old can back-up for Temple, maybe she ought to consider a transfer to Syracuse. Then, she can probably start. (As for changing my prediction, I'll say 6-5. Remember, this team's true colors won't be revealed until October. Then we'll know a lot more.
Q: I was wondering about whether we should be starting Tony Hunt or Austin Scott. Couldn't we start both? I would imagine that would create quite a headache for opposing defensive coordinators since both can be dangerous and you can't key in on one runner. Is this a realistic scenario, or is it one for a fantasy league?
Joe of Forest, Va.
HARLAN:,/B> Well, it's fun to think about, Joe, but it's purely a fantasy scenario. With Hunt and Scott both in the backfield, that would leave no spot for fullback Paul Jefferson, who is the true cog for the running game. Jefferson is a devastating, bullish blocker -- somebody who can intimidate his own teammates during practice. Check out some of the blocks he made on Saturday. Without him, neither Scott nor Hunt would have reached 100 yards. Even if Penn State had a lesser fullback -- somebody easier to yank from the lineup -- Hunt and Scott wouldn't make for much of a backfield, mostly because their styles are pretty similar. Indeed, opponents wouldn't be able to key in on one runner, but the defense's strategy wouldn't change much depending on the ball carrier. Hunt and Scott have similar styles; thus, they present similar challenges. Those challenges won't multiply if both are playing at the same time. Until one truly emerges, I think they're best splitting time as is.
Q: What's the latest on linebacking corps? How about J.R. Zwierzynski? If I recall correctly, he was a Gatorade Player of the Year in Illinois a couple years ago, but seeing him out there last week didn't show me that he's a difference maker. Overall, while Shaw looked fast last week, and Paul Posluszny was around the action all the time, I'm still concerned that we're a little too small. Wake is a big guy, and played well last week, but he's not someone who has the motor working all game long. Poz is fine, but Shaw is a bit smaller, and while Connor looked pretty good, he looks a little thin, too. They'll be going up against bigger guys this week and in weeks to come from here on out. Thanks.
Eric Berkman of Richmond, Va.
HARLAN: You're right, Eric -- Penn State's linebackers are a bit undersized. Wake, the biggest, is 241, which works perfectly. But the other starters, Show and Posluszny, both weigh roughly 230. Penn State takes an odd (or at least unique) approach with its weightlifting program. Instead of immediately shoving new players under the heaviest weights, PSU trainers have created programs designed to create endurance, often with an excruciating number of repetitions. This means players take longer to bulk up. So when you're starting two sophomores like Posluszny and Shaw at linebacker, they're almost certain to look a bit svelte. That said, I don't think it's a big problem. Some would even argue that 230 is an ideal weight for a linebacker. Once players exceed 250, speed -- not size -- becomes a question. And I'd argue that speed is more valuable than bulk, especially at the college level. As for Zwierzynski, I haven't been able to take a close look at him yet, both I don't get the feeling coaches think he'll be an impact player. He just makes for a quality back-up. And lastly, Connor? Now here's a guy who's undoubtedly small for a college linebacker. (He's listed at 218). But give him time. Remember, he was in high school one year ago. He'll be a special player.
This story was originally published with images that are no longer available.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.