Have your own question?

Click here to submit your question

Q: Living now in Colorado, I don't get as much Penn State information as I'd like, although the Internet has helped. I'd like an objective opinion of the Lions' prospects for this year. I've seen SI's ranking of Penn State at 50th. I'd like to think they could bounce back better than that.

Bob Swartz of Beaver

Advertise with us

HARLAN: You're throwin' around the big question, Bob. What to expect for the season? You know how fans tend to go down the schedule when it first comes out and pencil in a little "W" or "L" next to each game? Well, I did the same thing. My guess: 5-6 or 6-5. An average Big Ten team, in other words. The Lions better win at least two of their first three games, because the stretch thereafter -- games against Wisconsin, Minnesota, Purdue, Iowa and Ohio State -- is simply brutal. Even if the Lions start 3-0, the month of October is so difficult, it could quickly derail their season. The end of the schedule is, again, more forgiving, with games against Northwestern, Indiana and Michigan State. If the losses start piling up the middle of the season, the biggest question becomes this: Can PSU pull back together for the stretch run and win the games it ought to? Easier said than done for a team that fell apart in 2003. The best way to keep the team together during the middle of the season is by defeating one or two of the Big Ten powerhouses. (Purdue, in Happy Valley, is certainly a winnable game; so is the trip to Minnesota), thereby avoiding a four- or five-game losing streak. This could be a streaky season for Penn State. But I think SI is largely accurate -- ranked nationally, Penn State is OK, nothing better.

Q: I have questions about the Nittany Lions' run defense. Winning football games start by stopping the run and I feel that has been the biggest struggle over the last four years. I have my doubts on the physical style of Tom Bradley's defenses. How do you believe they'll change, if at all, to be a more physical team and stop opponents running games?

Neil Fico of Pawley's Island, S. C.

HARLAN: This was the question of the week -- several folks expressed concerns about defensive line play. Penn State certainly identified run-stopping as one of the areas it must improve for 2004, Neil. But I honestly don't think the failures of recent seasons have much to do with a lacking "physical style." I think it has more to do with stability. By my count, nine different players started on the defensive line last season. Almost automatically, that will cause some problems. I believe the Lions will be stronger on the line this year. Of course, that won't be tough -- a year ago, for instance, they let up roughly 2,500 rushing yards all season. If they can go from an "D" to a "B," Penn State's defense will have a strong foundation.

Q: I've noticed in your writing that you're a big fan of country music. As morally reprehensible as that is, I'll let it pass and instead pose this question: When was the last time Joe Paterno bought new eyeglasses? I think Ben Stein time-warped them from his Ferris Bueller cameo so he could give JoePa a present for his 143rd birthday.

Advertise with us

Ira Rothstein of East Meadow, N.Y.

HARLAN: Thanks for the touch of humor, Ira. No doubt, Joe Paterno would be amused. (But for the record, I was not amused by your dig at country music. You better hope my boy Tim McGraw is not a reader of this Q & A.)

Q: Hey Chico. I've really enjoyed your Penn State and Pirates articles. I think PSU should have some success running the football this year. They have a line that's played together for a year now, and three talented tailbacks. Austin Scott and Tony Hunt showed flashes last year, but supposedly, Rodney Kinlaw has been very impressive. Do you expect any of these guys to get the bulk of carries, or do you think they'll split it up?

Chris of Bellevue

HARLAN: Though it's always fun to watch a feature back -- after all, that's how you get the truest sense of a back's ability -- I don't believe the Lions will have one this year. I'm simply basing this on precedent. In recent years, unless Penn State has had one can't-miss talent (like Larry Johnson in 2002) the backfield has been a mix of comers and goers. Even Johnson didn't get the running back spot to himself until his last season. So far this summer, Paterno has given the impression of optimism about his running backs -- especially Scott and Hunt. However, he's found plenty of time to be critical, too. In other words, he sees reasons every one of them should play; he also can find reasons every one of them isn't quite reading. At a press conference several weeks ago, for instance, Paterno spent a few minutes explaining why he didn't believe Scott was entirely ready to carry the load: He needs to get a better feel for the blocking schemes, he needs better ability to break off long runs, etc. Granted, Scott and Hunt are both sophomores, so there's plenty of time for improvement. But I think the two of them will split the carries to start the season. Kinlaw is a factor, too -- at just 5-foot-9, he has a shiftier style than the other two. But he's coming back from an ACL injury from last year, and it generally seems to take running backs more than a year until they totally recover. Still, he'll get a sliver of the carries as well. I'd expect that to go on for much of the season.

Advertise with us

Q: New season, old question -- what to do with Michael Robinson? All I hear and read is that the coaches "have to find a way to get him on the field." Am I the only one out there asking why? The guy is not a secret weapon any longer. Teams know all about him and will be prepared to stop him. Fans can debate that he is a better QB than Zack Mills (I don't think so, but you can debate it at least) but I don't think that using Robinson in all sorts of random positions at random times during the game is effective for the team or, especially, the players that he is replacing. Is it only coincidence that the best game PSU played last year (against Ohio State) had zero involvement from Robinson? I'd like to hear your thoughts. And by the way, I don't count Indiana as our best game. That's like Division II football.

Tripp Merchant of Pittsburgh

HARLAN: Interesting question, Tripp. Indeed, Robinson is no longer a secret weapon, but I believe he should be on the field at all times. Bottom line: he's PSU's most talented player on offense. Maybe not the most refined, but certainly the most athletic. You suggest that teams will stop him because they know about him. I tend to think otherwise. If defenses could stop offenses -- or individual players, for that matter -- simply by knowing about them, watching film would put an end to the talents of Michael Vick and Randy Moss. Granted, I'm not comparing Robinson to either of those players (I should terminate my own contract day I do), but Robinson can certainly be effective no matter how much defenses key on him. So far, I don't think Robinson has been treated fairly. Coaches have yet to define a role for him, which could, during the season, hamper him more than any defense. Of course Robinson is valuable as a backup quarterback, but Robinson can be mightily helpful this season as a wideout for the Lions, if they elect to use him there. He doesn't have to be Slash, Part II; but he does have to be on the field. As for the Ohio State game, where Robinson had zero involvement, I think it's dangerous to make assumptions about his value based on one game.

Q: What will the Penn State offense look like with Galen Hall as the coordinator?

Joe Kaldon, Jr. of Hopewell

Advertise with us

HARLAN: Tough to say, Joe. So far, Penn State hasn't given fans -- or media members -- much of a clue about changes in the offense. Zack Mills said the Lions will rely more on play-action passing. Other than that, it's just a pile of guesses. One person close to the program, though, told me not to expect much change with the offense. So long as Joe Paterno is there, he'll have the ultimate veto power on anything too drastic for his liking.

Q: The Lions' pass offense, rush offense, rush defense, and special teams were dreadful last year. I expect them to better in these areas this year but only because there is a ton of room for improvement. Which of these areas is still the biggest concern for this year's team?

Rob York of Alexandria, Va.

HARLAN: It's special teams. Sometimes it seems coaches love reminding people that, Yes, special teams is one-third of the game, as if most people make a habit of overlooking it. But it's hard to overlook how problematic special teams was last year. This includes kicking, returning and return coverage. The Lions basically had problems in every department. Robbie Gould was disappointing last year, making just 9 of 16 kicks. He actually regressed from his sophomore year, when he converted 17 of 22. Still, Gould was just one man in a pile of problems. In several key Big Ten games, Penn State let the game swing on critical special teams breakdowns: the Lions allowed punt returns for a touchdown against Wisconsin and Purdue in back-to-back weeks. During the preseason camp, the Lions spent more time working on special teams than even most players expected. Sometimes the first step in correcting a problem is realizing that the problem exists. So at least Penn State is taking step No. 1.

Q: Does the lack of quality depth at linebacker worry you as much as it worries me? After J.R. Zwierzynski and Dan Conner, we are looking at freshmen and walk-ons.

Advertise with us

Mike Jones of Youngstown, Ohio

HARLAN: I think it's a concern, Mike, but certainly not among the Lions' greatest ones. Depth is a luxury, and few teams have it. A sorrowful plague of injuries would have to come about for depth at linebacker to truly become a problem, especially now that Derek Wake is practicing once again at the position. If Connor is as good as most believe, one can probably assume he's already a strong back-up. Zwierzynski didn't play much last season, but he did earn some time on special teams. Depth at other positions is more important. At defensive back, for example, you'll have six on the field in passing situations. But the Lions' base defense uses three linebackers, and they'll rarely use more. When they do, I think Connor will be the first to see playing time -- and I think that playing time will increase as the season progresses.

This story was originally published with images that are no longer available.