Q: What's going to change next year for Penn State? It's not really a strong group of underclassmen. They're losing the battle on local recruits as well as having lost their leverage nationally. How is this team going to compete in the Big Ten without making some major changes?
Terry Hammer from Huntington Beach, Calif.
FITTIPALDO: I agree that much has to change, but I disagree about the underclassmen and recruiting. There is a strong core of underclassmen returning. It's not a great group, but it's solid. Either Zack Mills or Michael Robinson will play quarterback, the tailback situation will be more stable and the offensive line should be stronger with guys like Tyler Reed and Levi Brown having a year under their belts. The only question is whether they will have enough playmakers at receiver. The defense returns its linemen and ends and has several strong young linebackers who are ready to make an impact. The secondary should be OK, too. Penn State, as of right now, has a top five recruiting class in the nation with its impressive list of verbal commitments. Yes, they lost Chad Henne, but they got a lot of good players from Western Pennsylvania. I think the coaches need to do a better job of putting the players in position to make plays. And the players have to pick themselves up by the bootstraps and put an end to the losing attitude that has pervaded the program. I don't think they'll contend for the Big Ten next season, but I think they can get back to. 500 in the league. That's not all bad after a 1-7 season.
Q: I have a comment more than a question. The Michigan State game was a disaster. And the decisions Joe Made early in the season were part of the reason. The No. 1 receiver, a former defensive back, was left back and no one was there to pick up his slack. Zack Mills struggles, then they put their starting tailback in at quarterback. Joe needs to make a decision at quarterback. Have a starter and a backup. This will not work next year.
Gene from Chicago
FITTIPALDO: I agree wholeheartedly, Gene. The uncertainty at quarterback this season led to the team having absolutely no leadership on offense. Neither Mills or Robinson ever felt confident enough to take charge of the offense because they were constantly looking over their shoulder. If Mills beats Robinson out again, put him at receiver, where help is needed. Whatever happens with the competition, there needs to be a clear-cut No. 1 next season. About leaving Maurice Humphrey back, Joe never said the reason, but since Humphrey landed in Centre County Prison a few days later, I would say that Paterno probably made the right call.
Q: Tom McHugh was swiftly dismissed from the team for allegedly slapping a woman. We don't have all the details, but Maurice Humphrey's incident appears to be more severe. The contributions to the team are clearly different, so should we expect another dismissal, or should we expect some inconsistency in the punishment?
Jeff from Oklahoma City, Okla.
FITTIPALDO: I think if Humphrey was going to be dismissed from the team it would have happened already. This might be one of those situations where Joe waits to see the outcome of the legal proceedings before making a determination. I think we have to give Joe the benefit of the doubt. He didn't make a rash judgment with Anwar Phillips, and Phillips was acquitted of sexual assault and allowed to play this season. And remember, Humphrey allegedly broke a male's jaw. The female involved in the incident didn't need medical treatment. There have been plenty of guys who have gotten into fights at Penn State and were allowed to remain on the team after some kind of probationary period.
Q: Ray, given the downward progression of the team over the past several years, do you think it's time to clean house and start over with a new staff? Sadly, it seems that Joe's grand design has run its course. Penn State now is one of the worst programs in the country, period. It's right there with the very worst in the Big Ten. It's sad to see the program collapse the way it has. This staff has set the program back for years to come. I've had it. I say start over and clean house.
Jerry Moore from North Potomac, Md.
FITTIPALDO: If Penn State doesn't turn it around next season, I think the upper administration at Penn State should look outside the program. If they turn it around, I think it's more likely that Fran Ganter will take over. As for next season, it's the final year of Joe's contract. I don't see him making major changes in his staff. Some coaches, like Ron Vanderlinden, might get a head coaching position and move on and it may be time for Dick Anderson to retire. He hasn't done a very good job with the offensive line in recent years. But other than one or two guys, I don't think it would make much sense for Joe to do anything severe going into what is likely his final season.
Q: Do you have idea as to when Penn State can produce another national championship team? Or will it take Joe's retirement or other drastic changes before that happens again?
James Patrick Thompson of South Daytona, Fla.
FITTIPALDO: I think Joe complained about the officiating so much last season because down deep he knew that was his last best chance to win a national title. That team had so much talent, but came up short in their big games. I don't think a national championship is in the offing anytime soon. Penn State would be ecstatic just to contend for the conference championship again. When Joe does retire, Penn State will be a very desirable job. They have great facilities and a great recruiting base and a great tradition. If a motivated young coach gets the job, Penn State could be a contender again in fairly short order. But if I was a fan, I'd be happy with 7-4 or 6-5 next season.
Q: Thank goodness the season is over. It was painful to watch from day one. What can we expect next year? Joe has been saying 'we're young' for the last three or four years now. The 9-4 season was not a return to prominence as some in the media have said. Yes, they have been competitive, but that is of little consolation after a loss. After watching the Michigan State game, it looks as if there is no foundation to build around next season. Can the fans expect a winning season next year? Is all this talk of a Big Ten championship a bad joke? Ohio State and Michigan seem to reload, while Penn State seems to have slipped to a second-tier program.
Chris from DuBois
FITTIPALDO: I, like many other people who follow Penn State, was discouraged after watching the Michigan State game. That was the first time this season they did not compete. If you look at Purdue, Iowa and Ohio State, those programs are in the top 20 and Penn State was in the game until the fourth quarter in each of those games. But I don't think you can let one game ruin an outlook. A lot of people like Penn State's younger talent and it's not unheard of for a team to climb the ladder from the cellar to contend the following season. Illinois in 2001 and Northwestern in 2000 won Big Ten championships after winning two and one game, respectively the season before. I don't think Penn State will do it because I don't like the way they're doing certain things, but I don't expect them to be 1-7 again next year, either.
Q: Why does everyone keep getting on Joe Paterno's case? I mean, he has one really bad year and everyone turns on him. Last year Penn State was 9-4 and no one was complaining then. I think Penn State will have a good team next year and maybe even contend for the Rose Bowl. If they have a good year next year will these ridiculous comments stop?
Alex Levandoski of Scottdale
FITTIPALDO: Well, three of the past four seasons have been pretty bad by Penn State standards. The Lions are 22-26 over the past four seasons. I think people have the right to expect more. I've said it a thousand times over the past few years, Penn State's down years should be 6-5 or 7-4, not the 3-9 and 5-7s that have occurred recently.
Q: What do you make of the fact that on more than one occasion Joe Paterno has been asked if Penn State would consider leaving the Big Ten for the Big East and on each occasion failed to give a denial and really left the door wide open? And Tim Curley hasn't responded to these questions. Do you think Penn State is considering leaving the Big Ten?
Richard Englehart of Newburyport, Mass.
FITTIPALDO: I don't know what to make of Paterno's comments about the Big Ten and Big East. I think if Penn State really wanted to make the move, it would have made it along with Louisville and Cincinnati and South Florida. Syracuse football coach Paul Pasqualoni and Rutgers coach Greg Schiano approached Paterno to gauge Penn State's interest in coming to the Big East, but apparently that was as far as it got. I never heard Penn State's name during the recent raid of Conference USA. There's two schools of thought on this: Joe might be trying to make a point to Big Ten officials that he is unhappy about several things in the league, like the officiating and the fact that Penn State still doesn't have an eastern traveling partner in the league after 11 seasons. (Joe is in favor of expansion and wants Syracuse, Pitt or Rutgers to join the Big Ten). Or Penn State figures that it can pretty much join the Big East anytime it chooses and is waiting for some point in the future to do so. Or it is quite possible that Joe is just having some fun with all of us.
This is the last Q&A until next summer. Thanks for participating. We'll do it again next year.
This story was originally published with images that are no longer available.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.