Have your own question?

Click here to submit your question

Q: Early in the year I consoled myself by telling everyone that this will be a National Champion contender in two years. And for everyone groaning about Joe let's face it, he's not going to quit in the middle of a team in progress. If he can't put together a .500 season next year and an eight win season in 2005, then I think he'll actually consider retirement. What do you think Ray? I'm more concerned with what is going to happen when he does decide it's time. Does he make the announcement prior to a season and jeopardize potential recruit(s) (you know, that one good recruit we get every year)? Or does he wait until after signing day and cause chaos in the off-season? Do you honestly think they'll bring someone from the outside and break the current status quo? Who's in the pot of potentials outside Penn State? You think we could ever draw one of those Stoops away from Oklahoma? Whatever they do, I hope it is someone from outside the current administration, change is needed in big way. I'd imagine this stuff is a couple years down the road though...open for debate. So, what changes can we realistically expect for next year? A special teams coach, a new strength and conditioning coach, a defensive tackle that doesn't get driven into the secondary, a peace offering to the Big Ten officials pleading mercy, what? Please tell me, all I see when I close my eyes are dropped balls, inept assistant coaches and a CEO unwilling to rock the boat in the slightest way in his final years!

Arthur of Arlington, Va.

Advertise with us

FITTIPALDO: Unless something changes in the next two weeks, Paterno will be back next season. He desperately wants to say 'I told you so' to the people who are doubting his coaching abilities now. That those people are many and multiplying by the day only drives Paterno more. I don't know if a national championship is in the offing anytime soon, but this team could be .500 or better next season. I know it's difficult to see any positives now, but look at the teams that graduate quarterbacks after this season. Craig Krenzel leaves Ohio State, John Navarre leaves Michigan, Jeff Smoker leaves Michigan State. A lot of teams will be rebuilding next season. I'm not saying Penn State is going to contend, but the Lions will be in the upper half of the conference. We can speculate all we want about who the next head coach will be, but until Joe says he is going to hang it up, I see no reason to waste time wondering. Joe might coach until he's 83, who knows?

Q:

Hey Ray, I know that the coaches probably feel like they need to get Michael Robinson some touches. After all, he is one of the more athletic players on this team. But is it effective to use him out of the backfield? Are the coaches worried about trying to find a place on this team for Michael for next year and do you have a sense what the plan will be for him. After all, next year is all we really have to look forward to. Where was Austin Scott? Has he been injured. One note from the game this past weekend I attended and much respect to the devoted Penn State fans and alums who still come out and support our team. These kids are trying and we should not loose sight of that. By the way to me that is a reflection of good coaching.

Dan VanDyke of Chicago

FITTIPALDO: I think the point to all of this is that the coaches don't really know what they're doing with Robinson. First, he is a slash player, then strictly a quarterback. When he performs well at quarterback, Paterno says he will remain at quarterback and compete for the starting position. When Zack Mills plays well, Robinson goes to the bench and doesn't see the field. The he comes back as a slash player. That doesn't sound like any kind of a plan to me. I know the coaches want to get the most out of this guy's talent. But he is not a running back. He has no field vision or a knack for breaking tackles. About the only way he was useful against Northwestern was on swing passes. Why they would mess with the offense after the Ohio State is beyond me. That game was probably their best all season and they went and changed things. There has been speculation that they're trying to appease Robinson some because he is not playing quarterback. As for Scott, my understanding is that he is completely healthy. Paterno said he is not all that happy with the play of his young tailbacks. But in a 2-8 season, I think there is even more reason to play them. Let them get their feet wet now, so they'll be ready for the future.

Advertise with us

Q:

Call me crazy but, don't you think it's difficult to win when your best quarterback is playing running back and your best running back is on the bench? Loyalty is one thing, but you have to get the most talented players on the field and start developing them for next season.

Drew Robertson of Falls Church, Va.

FITTIPALDO: I agree and disagree with you, Drew. I think Penn State has its best running back on the bench. The explanation for benching Scott was unacceptable to me. He is clearly the best option at running back. Michael Robinson might be as fast and can make things happen in the open field, but he has nowhere near the field vision and hole-hitting ability of Scott. Like a lot of Penn State followers, I go back and forth between Robinson and Zack Mills at quarterback. They have been so up-and-down this year that's it's hard to evaluate them. Robinson looked good against Wisconsin, then he stunk up the joint against Purdue and Iowa. Mills looked great against Ohio State and then he didn't play particularly well against Northwestern. By going with Mills, I think they made the right decision in that they finally made a decision.

Q:

Advertise with us

Exactly how unhappy is Michael Robinson with his ever-changing role in the offense? Might he transfer out? (I have this fear that he will end up at Miami.) If you were him, would you? More generally, what effect does transferring have on a player's eligibility?

Josh Plaut of Brooklyn, N.Y.

FITTIPALDO: I don't know what is going through Robinson's mind, but I think it's a little late for him to be transferring. If he was going to do that, he should have done it before this year. He has NFL-caliber athletic ability, so sitting out a year and going into an unfamiliar situation doesn't make much sense. But that doesn't mean it couldn't happen. Robinson had his opportunity to unseat Mills this season and failed to do it. I don't think he's happy about his role, but I think he is a stand-up guy and is genuine when he says he will do anything to help the team win.

Q: What?!! Middle linebacker Gino Capone will sit out the Indiana game and senior Andy Ryland will take Capone's place. Didn't Paul Posluszny play well and won't he be the anchor of the linebackers corps for the next three years? No knock against Andy, but what am I missing besides the obvious senior reference which follows Ryland's name on the roster. Why not reward Posluszny for his effort and give the guy the start?

Justin Johovich of McCandless

Advertise with us

Fittipaldo: Posluszny plays outside linebacker. He is splitting time with senior Deryck Toles. Posluszny has not played the middle position yet and it's probably a little much to ask a freshman to run the defense, which is what the middle linebacker does. He is responsible for getting the signals from the sidelines and relaying the call to the rest of the players. I'm not ruling Posluszny out of playing middle backer forever, but I think he's a pretty good fit at the outside position. Who will play in the middle next season is reason for concern. Capone and Ryland graduate and Tim Johnson probably won't cut it. Maybe one of the highly-touted freshmen (Dan Connor or Dante Brown from McKeesport) can seize an opportunity and make a difference. I think it's been apparent that they need a difference maker at linebacker.

Q:

Can you tell me why Calvin Lowry continues to return kickoffs and punts. He is too slow, does not follow his blocks and is good for at least two special teams mistakes every week. He constantly catches the ball inside the 10-yard line or lets the ball bounce in front of him and roll 20 yards. You have so many good athletes to return kicks -- Maurice Humphrey, Tony Johnson, Austin Scott, Michael Robinson, Terrance Phillips, Tony Hunt, Yaacov Yisrael, Rich Gardner, Alan Zemaitis and Donnie Johnson. At 2-8 try something?

Frank from Pittsburgh

FITTIPALDO: Great observation, Frank. Lowry's special teams play is a constant topic of conversation in the press box. Against Northwestern he made two crucial mistakes that led to poor field position. He fielded a punt at the 5 instead of letting it bounce into the end zone for a touchback. That play cost the Lions 15 yards in field position. He also was called for a personal foul for interfering with the punt returner on punt coverage. That's another 15 yards. In previous games, he has fumbled and those plays have resulted in touchdowns for the other team. Paterno has been asked why Lowry continues to get opportunities, and he says he likes what Lowry brings to the game. He said people were all over him a few years back when Bobby Engram struggled in the punt return game. He stuck with Engram and he became a good punt returner who is still making a living in the NFL. I think he believes Lowry can turn it around, too. But I'm like you, Frank. I think Lowry is a liability back there.

Advertise with us

Q:

What did Penn State do in the game against Ohio State which allowed them to be successful, and why didn't it work against Northwestern?

Alex Levandoski of Scottdale

FITTIPALDO: Against Ohio State, the Lions caught the ball and made some field goals. They did neither against Northwestern. If they had, they would have been up 20-0 at halftime and would have won the game. That's simplifying it. (certainly there's more wrong with the team than that). But those two things jumped out at me in the Northwestern game.

Q:

Advertise with us

I am a Penn State fan transplanted to Texas when I was a kid. But I am still a Lions follower. But I have also adopted the Longhorns. Which leads me to this question. Texas and Penn State seem to have a very similar situation at quarterback. Both have very mobile quarterbacks in Michael Robinson and Vince Young at Texas. Texas has been much more successful though getting the most out of their quarterback using an inside read where the quarterback lines up in the shotgun with a single back and reads the defensive end and either runs the ball or hands off to the running back depending on how the defensive end is playing. This has met with much success and I think would serve Penn State to take notice. Do you feel this could help open some running lanes up for Penn State as it has done for Texas?

Ensign Eli Rudick of Pensacola, Fla.

FITTIPALDO: You're talking about two different offenses, Eli, so it's hard to make a comment on the situation. And to be honest, I have not seen Texas enough this year to compare what they do with the Lions. I can comment on the use of the shotgun, however. Penn State does not use it a lot because they have such a good fullback in Sean McHugh and like to keep him in the game. That and the receivers have not played well enough to warrant three- or four-wide sets.

Q:

Historically sub-par Penn State teams have gotten better as the year went on. Does the smallish size of this years senior class have anything to do with this teams non improvement, as the season has progressed?

Advertise with us

Tammy McIntyre from State College

FITTIPALDO: The problem with this year's senior class, Tammy, is that it is small and on top of that some of the leaders in the class aren't very good players. So it's hard for guys who aren't playing or guys who aren't playing well to be vocal in a season like this. There are some seniors Penn State will miss next season, but for the most part, the Lions return all of their important players.

Q:

Why did the coaches give up so quickly on Ricky Upton this year? Granted, the freshmen were exciting to watch against lesser defenses, but as miserable as Penn State's line has been, it seems they would've been better with a stronger, more experienced, if less flashy starting tailback, as Upton is. I don't think he's fumbled or dropped a pass all year when he has played (no mean feat on this offense), and he has always run hard to get the extra yard, and has a good per-carry average. As hard as he worked to position himself for playing time this season, I think Ricky got robbed, and Penn State has been the worse for it. To make matters worse, both Austin Scott and Tony Hunt have burned their freshmen seasons. Scott I could understand, but Hunt has not been critical to the offense. Seems it would've been better to redshirt Hunt, use Scott in certain situations, but rely on Upton for most of the load.

John Penner from Los Angles, Calif.

Advertise with us

FITTIPALDO: Upton is an OK back, but an OK back in this offense can't do the job. Scott is better than OK, and he can't do the job. The only way Upton could have played for Penn State was if the Lions had a good offensive line. Scott has the ability to make people miss and the ability to break off a big run. Upton does not possess either ability. He is a hard-nosed runner, but hard-nosed runners with that line are not useful. I agree with your point about Hunt, though. Why not use Upton as the backup and save Hunt for another season?

This story was originally published with images that are no longer available.