Next up in the Post-Gazette’s football preview series is a look at the biggest questions facing Pitt as it kicks off a pivotal 2025 season. From an overhauled offensive line to a revamped wide receiver room and the return of quarterback Eli Holstein, the Panthers enter camp with plenty of intrigue—and even more to prove.

These are the top questions the Post-Gazette is watching as Pat Narduzzi’s squad hits the field.

Eli Holstein expectations?

After taking over as Pitt’s starter in 2024, Eli Holstein enters the 2025 season as the presumed QB1, but not without questions.

Holstein showed flashes of his four-star pedigree last season, completing 62% of his passes (180 of 291) for 2,228 yards and 17 touchdowns. He was also Pitt’s second-leading rusher with 328 yards and three TDs on 81 carries.

Advertise with us

But the redshirt sophomore also showed signs of inexperience: inconsistent decision-making, accuracy lapses and uneven performances in big moments. Part of that had to do with injuries disrupting his season and, in turn, limiting his development and Pitt’s offensive rhythm. Staying healthy is key if he’s going to take a step forward in 2025.

Now, with a full offseason to heal and build chemistry in Kade Bell’s system, the expectation is a more settled and confident version of Holstein.

Holstein doesn’t need to be a Heisman candidate, but he does need to be the steady hand that can keep Pitt competitive in the ACC. That means fewer turnovers, more command at the line and stronger finishes in close games. He needs to get his interception numbers down after having seven last season, too.

A full, healthy season with all-around improvements could earn Holstein All-ACC recognition and solidify him as a long-term answer at the position.

Pitt hasn’t had consistency at the quarterback spot since Kenny Pickett was the starter from 2018-2021. Holstein, entering year two under center, could become the first Pitt QB since Pickett to start in consecutive seasons.

Advertise with us

He’ll have pressure from other quarterbacks, though, and Narduzzi has shown he’s not afraid to pull a quarterback if he’s struggling. Continuity isn’t everything — especially in this current college sports landscape — and there’s a reason Pitt won the ACC football championship in 2021 with Pickett as its starter.

Newcomer impact?

While Holstein remains the expected starter at quarterback, don’t forget about Cole Gonzales. The Western Carolina transfer reunites with offensive coordinator Kade Bell and already has a deep understanding of the offense. If injuries hinder Holstein again, or if consistency becomes a question, Gonzales gives Pitt a ready-made backup.

As Pitt opens training camp, all eyes will also be on the offensive line — and for good reason.

The Panthers surrendered 41 sacks in 2024 and struggled to establish a consistent ground game, making the offensive line overhaul a necessity.

Three newcomers — Kendall Stanley (Charlotte), Jeff Persi (Michigan), and Keith Gouveia (Richmond) — are expected to play major roles. Stanley has made an early case for a starting job with his athleticism and toughness. Persi offers Big Ten pedigree and versatility. Gouveia’s technical polish and interior skills could help solidify the middle of the unit.

Advertise with us

On the other side of the ball, Jaedon Moore, a transfer edge rusher from Oregon, is quietly positioning himself as a potential difference-maker.

Pitt’s defensive ends are young and largely unproven, with Moore bringing Pac-12 experience and a long, athletic frame that fits well in Randy Bates’ aggressive scheme. If he flashes in camp, he could earn a significant role as a rotational pass rusher or even crack the starting rotation.

Biggest position battles?

One of the biggest position battles of training camp will take place at left tackle, and the Panthers are fortunate enough to have two strong options, both of whom are transfers.

The aforementioned Persi and Stanley split first-team reps during spring drills, but they were both getting their feet wet. The winner will be decided in August and be tasked with protecting the blindside of Holstein from day one.

Braylan Lovelace should be the favorite to land as the Panthers’ starting middle linebacker, but he faced a serious challenge from sophomore Jeremiah Marcelin in spring camp. Lovelace has the experience, but Marcelin is a physical specimen, so they should each find playing time regardless of who wins the starting job.

Advertise with us

At cornerback, Pitt is looking to replace their top man from a year ago: Ryland Gandy, who transferred to Indiana. Returning veterans Rashad Battle and Tamon Lynum are likely favorites to start, but how redshirt junior Shadarian Harrison and Penn West California transfer Rashan Murray build on strong springs could change that.

The Panthers also hope to go deeper at wide receiver than they did a year ago. Kenny Johnson, Raphael Williams and C.J. Lee make up a clear top three, but transfers Blue Hicks and Deuce Spann — plus true freshman Tony Kinsler — will compete with Zion Fowler-El for the plentiful snaps Bell wants to share among the WR corps.

Will the offense be better?

The dramatic decline of Pitt’s offense was the most obvious reason for last season’s second-half collapse.

Bell’s explosive, up-tempo system stagnated as injuries mounted, the quality of competition increased, and a model for how to contain the Panthers materialized. Simply put, the offense must be more consistent and perform better against top-quality opponents.

In its first six games of the season, during which it averaged 4.67 offensive touchdowns per game, Pitt played just one defense (Cal) that ended the year ranked among the top 40 nationally in stop rate (the percentage of a defense's drives that end in punts, turnovers or a turnover on downs), scoring defense or Pro Football Focus (PFF) grade.

Advertise with us

The Panthers have the benefit of continuity going into 2025, however, as Holstein, Johnson, Williams and others — including star RB Desmond Reid — surround an offensive line that has been supported via the transfer portal.

But there’s an onus on Bell to ensure his team has all the schematic tools necessary to score against any opponent.

Does the House settlement impact Pitt?

The short answer is yes, especially regarding revenue sharing and roster strategy. But many of the changes will be made behind closed doors, so fans won’t necessarily notice a radically different game-day atmosphere or on-field product right away.

Instead, the shifts will be felt primarily in how the program manages its finances, distributes funds to players and handles recruiting and roster compliance.

One of the most significant changes is Pitt’s ability to directly share a substantial portion of revenue with players — estimated to be around $15 million for the 2025 season. This new revenue-sharing model is designed to better compensate athletes, particularly those in high-profile positions.

Advertise with us

This is a win for the players, but the money has to come from somewhere, and that means Pitt likely faces tough budget decisions. The athletic department is already operating with a large deficit, so fans may eventually see small things such as ticket price increases and additional fees as the program figures out how to offset these new costs.

On the roster front, the settlement replaces strict scholarship limits with total roster size caps.

To stay within the new limits, the Panthers will also need to manage player counts carefully, potentially reducing walk-ons or transfers.

Narduzzi has already touched on his approach and how the program is taking great care with the subject. He didn’t want to cut someone come August after they were promised a spot early, so the grandfathering-in rule plays a considerable role here.