This week marks another milestone in the long history of player empowerment in college athletics, with U.S. District Judge Claudia Wilken set to hear objections to the proposed settlement of House v. NCAA. Her stamp of approval on dramatic terms — billions in back pay to former college athletes, revenue sharing agreements and new NIL rules — will radically alter one of America’s favorite pastimes and largest entertainment industries.
Few, if any, know what consequences await when the dust is settled on five years of litigation. Everyone from athletes to coaches, fans and administrators — including Pitt’s athletic director Allen Greene — is trying to piece a whole picture together.
Six months ago, Greene took his post as the leader of Pitt’s athletic department and became tasked with guiding it through a portal: from one age of college sports to another.
“This is the City of Champions, and there’s an expectation from our community that we live up to that moniker,” Greene said in an exclusive interview with the Post-Gazette. “In order to do so, we’ll need to invest with precision.”
There are 14 objectors, ranging from star gymnast and influencer Livvy Dunne to the Department of Justice, slated to file complaints about the proposed settlement on Monday. Nothing is set in stone yet, but Pitt has been able to prepare for certain terms. One of those is the $20.5 million cap that every school opting into the settlement will be bound to when sharing revenue with their athletes.
It’s a massive cost for any school to take on — and that’s just for the 2025-26 academic year. The cap is expected to increase, potentially reaching $30 million over the next decade, according to some estimates.
Read More
A strategic hire
While looking for a new athletic director, Pitt saw the House Settlement and its future costs approaching and needed someone who could raise funds.
Greene most recently worked as senior deputy athletics director at Tennessee, senior deputy athletics director for external relations and business development at the University of Mississippi and director of athletics at Auburn, meaning he had extensive experience not only in the SEC but in getting prominent, power-conference programs ready for a new era of college sports dominated by the almighty dollar.
“Athletic departments are going to deliver — we're going to deliver a different experience because we have to,” said Greene, who also cited Pitt’s need to enhance philanthropic effort and generate more revenue through ticket sales.
“We have to evolve, and that comes in many different shapes and sizes. This is not the athletics department of three years ago or four years ago, let alone of 20 years ago.”
For a school like Pitt, with an athletic department that reported more than $138 million in total revenue but didn’t turn a profit during the fiscal year 2023-24, satisfying the terms of the House Settlement will take a holistic effort. Greene is counting on funding from several areas — including the university itself — to account for the extra cost of paying athletes through revenue sharing.

“It's important to understand Pitt athletics’ relevance in the university context and in the community context,” Greene said. “It's important for our institution, and it's important for our community to have successful athletics.”
Every participating school will be allowed to use its own discretion when distributing those funds once they are in hand. A handful of them have shared their plans for revenue distribution, and among institutions with Football Bowl Subdivision (FBS) programs, a pattern has emerged — football takes the lion’s share of the money, men’s basketball takes a smaller share, and everyone else falls into a significantly smaller basket.
“While football and men’s basketball will receive a significant portion of the revenue share allocation in this proposed new model, we have an obligation to position each of our programs for competitive success,” Greene said.
However, the revenue-sharing money is coupled with a further obligation to recruit and retain talent with NIL money. This isn’t a new phenomenon, but it is now intertwined with the fundraising and budget allocation schools have to do to satisfy the terms of the House Settlement, and it has only become a more drastic need for coaches who want to compete.
Following Greene’s introductory press conference last October, Pitt men’s basketball head coach Jeff Capel said he needed one thing from his new athletic director: “NIL. I need money.”
It was a blunt assessment of his team’s needs at the time and the direction of college sports, but not inaccurate.
If recruiting is the lifeblood of a program, then money is the heart, pumping in enough talent to keep everything moving. Whereas the recruiting battles of previous eras were fought with facilities, today’s are fought with NIL war chests.
“Resources have always been a differentiator. For the past 20 years, the race for elite facilities has dominated spending, all in the name of recruiting,” Greene said. “In the current landscape, talent acquisition has become heavily transactional through NIL and the looming reality of revenue sharing.
“What coach Capel, and all our coaches for that matter, want is for their programs to be positioned for success.”
What about Victory Heights?
A new building is being raised within view of Greene’s office at Petersen Events Center. Victory Heights is a massive athletics capital project that will house an arena, gyms and offices for volleyball, gymnastics, wrestling and more. It was conceived and started by his predecessor, Heather Lyke, and is scheduled to open this fall.
Lyke said Pitt had raised $12 million towards the project as of April 2023 — out of a $240 million goal. Nearly two years later, Greene said Victory Heights is a worthy investment, and internal discussions about how to balance the cost of construction and terms of the House Settlement are still ongoing.
For now, Greene’s plans to keep Pitt athletics in the black do not involve cutting athletic programs. However, the financial strains of the House Settlement will be shared by the athletic department and its fans.
NIL used to be solely the obligation of the fan and alumni base, who are the only ones permitted to pay into NIL collectives. The House Settlement changes that slightly and permits institutions to participate in NIL payments, too, but those who want to stretch their money as far as possible will still count on outside contributions.
“While at the core of what we do centers around shaping young lives through sport, there are increasing characteristics of our industry that resemble big business,” Greene said. “As costs rise, from scholarships and team travel to revenue share, our industry is urgently seeking ways to maximize existing revenue streams and unlock new opportunities to bridge the financial gap.”
Greene knows Pitt is fighting an uphill battle.
The wealthiest in college sports will be able to address the terms of the House Settlement more easily, but that doesn’t make competing for ACC or national championships — even in football and men’s basketball — impossible.
And if it were, Greene wouldn’t be here. He’s embracing the challenge of making Pitt competitive in a college sports landscape unlike anything anyone has seen before.
“I would say our path to success is a little bit different. There are programs out there that have more financial resources to throw at it,” he said.
“We don't have those financial resources that the SEC and the Big Ten do, but that doesn't mean that we can't find success.”





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.