Pitt football’s initial haul of 12 incoming transfers hasn’t turned many heads so far this offseason.
By industry measurements, the Panthers’ 2025 transfer class ranks anywhere between No. 13 (On3) and No. 15 (247Sports) among ACC schools. These sites have yet to log all of their commitments — On3, 247Sports and Rivals each claim the Panthers have landed just eight transfers, but the program announced 11 additions on Jan. 8, when the spring semester at Pitt began, and former Louisville wideout Cataurus Hicks officially joined the program little more than a week later.
But even when the recruiting sites do catch up to the Panthers’ newest additions, don’t expect much of a bump in terms of national standing. Safety Kavir Bains, defensive end Blaine Spires and offensive lineman Keith Gouveia, the trio of Pitt signees not yet factored into the recruiting services’ team rankings, were all considered either unrated or three-star transfer prospects. So while they could become impact players on the field, these players won’t raise the ceiling on Pitt’s recruiting rankings.
Barring a spring surprise, Pitt’s latest crop of transfer additions is guaranteed to be overlooked on a conference and national scale, but that might not be something worth losing sleep over as they go through winter workouts in anticipation for the start of spring ball.
One reason the Panthers have lagged behind the rest of their league in terms of transfer recruiting is volume. Pitt is one of four ACC teams — alongside Clemson, Syracuse and Duke — with transfer classes totaling in the single digits. None are ranked higher than No. 13 by 247Sports. Nationally, there are just four teams ranked in the top 50 of 247Sports’ transfer class rankings — Oregon, Alabama, Georgia and Ohio State — with fewer than 10 commitments.
The size of the class matters when recruiting experts account for both high school and transfer classes, which is why a team like UCLA — which has 21 transfer commitments, all of whom are rated as three-star prospects — can climb to No. 21 in 247Sports’ rankings.
Read More
But chalking their low ranking entirely up to the size of the class would be disingenuous. It’s one factor, but at the end of the day, the Panthers are one of seven ACC schools to not have signed a transfer rated better than a three-star prospect by 247Sports. Some of their signees, like Spires and former Charlotte offensive tackle Kendall Stanley, are more highly touted transfer prospects than they were as high school seniors but still only rose to three-star status.
With that said, there’s no reason why good players can’t emerge from this unheralded group. Pitt took in 14 transfers during the last cycle, the most of the Narduzzi era, and of those 14 transfers, three landed on the All-ACC football team, seven earned starting jobs and 10 saw extensive playing time as members of the offensive or defensive two-deep.
Desmond Reid, Eli Holstein, Lyndon Cooper, Nate Matlack and Nick James, four of the Panthers’ better players on either side of the ball this past season, all earned three-star ratings once entering the transfer portal and held them through their commitments to Pitt. It should serve as reason for optimism that Stanley, defensive end Jaeden Moore or the trio of seldom-used wide receivers the Panthers recruited can thrive once given an opportunity to play.
As has been the case with its high school recruiting, great recruiting pedigrees don’t always translate into productive careers on the field. Pitt is the kind of program that will always need to find diamonds in the rough and develop them. This year will be no different. Because this program doesn’t have the advantages of historic prestige or unlimited sums of NIL money, the coaches winning on the margins will determine whether Pitt can take a step forward or not.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.