Pitt’s disappointing 2023 football season continues to find new ways to show how far the Panthers have fallen from their 20 wins in the past two seasons.

The Panthers were bullied by Syracuse on Saturday afternoon at Yankee Stadium in a 28-13 loss. The Orange had lost five straight, and the Panthers now represent their only ACC victory of the season. The loss drops the Panthers to 2-8, the most losses in a season during Pat Narduzzi’s tenure as head coach and the most since Pitt’s 2-9 finish in 1998.

But just as bad as the Panthers’ record after Saturday is the effort that led to them being dominated by a Syracuse rushing attack that ranked in the middle of the ACC. That rekindled concerns about the trajectory of Pitt’s defense and questions as to whether the traditional Pitt identity under Narduzzi can be attainable again anytime soon.

Before we get to that, we’ll address one of the few positives in Saturday’s game:

Advertise with us

What worked: Pitt’s receivers looked good, and it makes the Panthers’ lack of consistent quarterback play that much more disappointing. On the few times they were given catchable balls that didn’t hang them out dry for big hits, Pitt’s receivers made plays.

As Pitt trailed 7-3 with 5:04 left in the second quarter, Christian Veilleux fired a pass over the middle to Bub Means, who caught it and raced for 65 yards to get Pitt into the red zone. Just a few plays later, Konata Mumpfield ran a spot route that perfectly fit in the soft spot of Syracuse’s zone defense to create a good passing window for Veilleux. The result was a catch and run that scored a 10-yard touchdown.

Mumpfield caught four passes for 29 yards and a touchdown, while Means caught two passes for 71 yards and Daejon Reynolds caught three passes for 44 yards. The flashes of their potential bring further questions about what Pitt’s offense has left on the table this season as the Panthers rank dead last in the ACC in scoring and total offense.

Veilleux had a rough day for Pitt, completing 13 of 22 passes for 161 yards and a touchdown but also threw an interception and fumbled twice on failed exchanges during option runs. Pitt would eventually replace him with Nate Yarnell at quarterback, but it didn’t boost the offense enough to score any more points.

If you think that’s where the worst part of the game resides for Pitt, you’d be wrong. We have to talk about the defense.

Advertise with us

What didn’t work: Pitt’s run defense delivered one of the worst performances of the Narduzzi era, not just because Syracuse ran for 382 yards but also because the Orange also only threw for 17 yards and started a quarterback coming off injury in Garrett Shrader, who threw two passes, completing only one for a 5-yard touchdown.

In fact, the leading passer for Syracuse was tight end Dan Villari, who completed 3 of 5 passes for 12 yards. In most games during the Narduzzi era, if a team was one-dimensional against Pitt the way Syracuse was, the Panthers would toughen up against the run and control the line of scrimmage. If Pitt lost the game, it would be because the offense was abysmal and had several turnovers, combined with other factors like the occasional big pass play given up on a trick play or play action.

Pitt’s offense committed turnovers, but Syracuse’s offense never made a big play through the air. It was a game in the trenches, the way Pitt usually wants its contests to go, and the Panthers were whipped by a better Syracuse team. Villari was also Syracuse’s leading rusher with 154 yards on 17 carries, along with a touchdown. He was joined by running back LeQuint Allen, who gained 102 yards on 28 carries, as well as quarterback Shrader who ran for 96 yards and a touchdown on 14 carries.

What’s worse for Pitt is all appearances indicate this game plan Syracuse concocted looked to be brand-new and something they hadn’t practiced a lot. Villari had just two carries for 3 yards coming into Saturday but took snaps out of the wildcat and ran the triple option that forced Pitt’s defense to read their keys up front.

“Obviously, they didn’t plan on passing,” Narduzzi said after the game. “I’m not sure if Shrader could throw it. He hadn’t played for the last couple of weeks, and I didn’t even know he was going to go today. I had no idea who the starting quarterback was — you try to work for [Carlos] Del Rio-Wilson and everybody else. They did a lot of different stuff that we had not practiced. We tried to adjust as we went.”

Advertise with us

That didn’t happen, as the Panthers looked undisciplined in their gap integrity and allowed clear rushing lanes throughout the contest. Narduzzi acknowledged on the ACC broadcast that Syracuse was using plays they hadn’t shown on tape in previous games this season, but it was just the simplicity of the triple-option offense that required fundamental play up front from the Panthers.

Pitt knew Syracuse would run the ball at them and still got bullied off the ball. It rekindles the analysis after the Panthers’ embarrassing 38-21 loss to Virginia Tech back on Oct. 1. Narduzzi’s team has lost its way. Normally when Pitt looked outplayed, it was because a team attacked through the air and the Panthers didn’t have answers as they focused on stopping the run and rushing the quarterback. But this is now multiple times this season the Panthers haven’t had answers to stop the run and allowed a game to fall out of reach because of it.

Saturday’s game was also historic in a bad way, as the 382 rushing yards by Syracuse were the most allowed by a Pitt defense under Narduzzi since the Panthers’ 35-17 loss to Georgia Tech on Sept. 23, 2017, when the Yellow Jackets ran for 436 yards and five touchdowns on 67 carries. Saturday was also the first contest of the season in which Pitt allowed over 300 rushing yards and just the second for over 200 rushing yards (Cincinnati).

What’s next: Pitt’s next game is against a 6-4 Boston College team at Acrisure Stadium on Thursday night. The Eagles just lost 48-22 to Virginia Tech on Saturday but have been the ACC’s top rushing offense with an average of 212.2 rushing yards per game going into Saturday.

That should be alarming for Pitt’s defense that only has four days before facing such an opponent. But even more important than just the Panthers’ final two games of the season is the trajectory of the program. Pitt’s players looked defeated in the second half, and it’s far from the first time that’s happened this season.

Advertise with us

Narduzzi said during his Thursday press conference that he felt Pitt’s defense had shown progress and after limiting Florida State to just 24 points while the Seminoles were the fifth-best scoring offense in the country, he had merit to say so. But such a showing from Pitt against Syracuse, just two weeks removed from a 58-7 drubbing at the hands of Notre Dame, shows the team hasn’t been making progress but instead is moving in a circle of struggles that have held them back all season.

This disaster of a season after such high expectations could lead to changes on the team’s coaching staff. That probably won’t be a top-to-bottom cleaning of the house, but it’s hard to imagine not making significant changes after such a dreadful season and Pitt having been stripped of its identity as a program again this year.

Christopher Carter: ccarter@post-gazette.com and on Twitter @CarterCritiques