UNIVERSITY PARK, Pa. — Not there yet. Still not elite. Still not even close, really.

Penn State came up small in another big game on Saturday.

Of course, it did.

James Franklin’s teams almost always do.

Advertise with us

In another failed referendum on Franklin as a big-game coach, Penn State was beaten handily here by Michigan 24-15 before 110,856, the second-largest crowd in Beaver Stadium history. That made Franklin 3-17 against top-10 teams. He is 3-7 against Michigan and 1-9 against Ohio State, which beat Penn State 20-12 on Oct. 21 in Columbus.

“We’ve lost to the No. 1 and the No. 3 team in the country,” a forlorn Franklin said after this latest defeat. “That’s not good enough. We’ve got to find ways to win those games.”

It’s certainly not good enough for those Penn State fans who unloaded with boos on Franklin as he walked to the tunnel that led to the Penn State locker room after the game. It didn’t seem to matter to those fans that Franklin is headed perhaps to his fifth 11-win season in his 10 seasons at Penn State. They were thinking only about the harsh truth: Franklin can’t win the significant games against the two best Big Ten opponents.

It was just five years ago, after a tough 27-26 home loss to Ohio State, that Franklin delivered his infamous rant about Penn State’s standing in the college football world:

“The reality is we’ve gone from an average football team to a good football team to a great football team. But we’re not an elite team yet.”

Advertise with us

Penn State is 2-9 against Michigan and Ohio State since then with six consecutive losses.

The loss at Ohio State in October was bad, but this defeat was worse. Michigan won easily without its coach, Jim Harbaugh, who was suspended by the Big Ten on Friday night for his role in the alleged sign-stealing scandal at Michigan. It won easily on a day when it didn’t even have to throw a pass — not a single one — in the second half.

You think the Steelers offense has been bad this season? Pitt’s offense? Penn State’s offense is right there with them in terms of being mostly rancid.

Penn State quarterback Drew Allar, a five-star recruit in his first season as the starter, was 10 for 22 for 70 yards against Michigan. He also lost a key fumble and took an intentional grounding penalty. The Penn State offense managed just 238 yards of offense.

Allar was 18 for 42 for 191 yards in the 20-12 loss at Ohio State. Penn State finished with 240 yards of offense in that game.

Advertise with us

“Just not good enough overall,” Allar said. “Obviously, not the outcome we wanted. I’ve just got to be better.”

Penn State was trailing 14-9 when Allar fumbled at the Penn State 49 on the first possession of the third quarter. Michigan turned that into a field goal and what felt like an insurmountable 17-9 lead eight minutes later.

“A significant play in the game,” Franklin called it.

“That’s when the game changed to me, personally,” Allar said. “We were moving the ball. I just can’t put the ball on the ground.”

It’s easy to blame Allar for the defeat, but that would be leaving Franklin off the hook. Franklin had another rotten game.

Advertise with us

After Penn State scored to cut Michigan’s lead to 14-9 late in the second quarter, Franklin went for a two-point conversion that failed. That left him and the Penn State team to have to chase points later in the game.

Franklin wasted a timeout late in the third quarter before finally deciding to punt on 4th-and-2 from the Penn State 46. That was a timeout he could have used later in the game.

Franklin had Penn State go for it on a 4th-and-6 play from the Penn State 30 with 4:25 left in the game despite still having two timeouts left and Penn State being down by one score. Allar’s pass was incomplete. Michigan running back Blake Corum scored on a 30-yard run on the next play to stretch Michigan’s lead to 24-9.

Franklin then had Penn State go for another 2-point conversion after it scored a touchdown to pull within 24-15 with 1:59 left. It made no sense to not kick the extra point there and make it a one-score game.

“We felt like points were going to be at a premium,” Franklin said.

Advertise with us

It probably wouldn’t have mattered, anyway.

Michigan clearly was the better team and came in motivated to win for Harbaugh.

“Everything that’s going on right now just brings us closer together,” Corum said after rushing for 145 yards and two touchdowns.

Offensive coordinator Sherrone Moore served as Michigan’s interim head coach and broke down in tears as he delivered an emotional message that turned X-rated during a postgame, on-field interview that was seen nationally on FOX.

“I want to thank coach Harbaugh. [Bleeping] love you, man. Love the [bleep] out of you, man. This is for you.”

Advertise with us

It was for all of Michigan, actually, and came at the expense of Franklin and Penn State.

Again.

Of course, again.

Ron Cook: rcook@post-gazette.com and Twitter @RonCookPG. Ron Cook can be heard on the “Cook and Joe” show weekdays from 10 a.m. to 2 p.m. on 93.7 The Fan