Welcome to the Pitt mailbag, where Post-Gazette reporters Noah Hiles and Christopher Carter answer all of your questions about the Panthers. If you have a question, tweet them at @_NoahHiles and @CarterCritiques or email them at nhiles@post-gazette.com and ccarter@post-gazette.com. Noah and Chris will answer your questions in full length each Tuesday on YouTube. You can read the condensed version of the discussion below.
Justin: I think the easiest layup is this hypothetical: What happens if Christian Veilleux had started all season? He didn't do anything amazing, but he was competent, made some plays and kept the ball out of harm's way.
Hiles: I think Pitt has at least one more win than it does now. Veilleux’s level of play Saturday would’ve been more than enough for the Panthers to beat West Virginia. I’d say it’s a toss-up against both Cincinnati and Virginia Tech. I feel like there were too many other problems in those games for us to just assume he gets both wins, although he probably gets a win in at least one of them. And I think it’s safe to say he doesn’t lead Pitt to a win over North Carolina. So with all that being said, I think Pitt would probably be 4-2.
Carter: I think at worst Pitt is 3-3 and at best is 4-2, which is of course better than what it is now at 2-4. Veilleux wins them the game against WVU. I think Virginia Tech could’ve also gone differently had Veilleux played because I think he would’ve provided more consistency.
George: Do you guys think [coach Pat] Narduzzi waited too long to make a change at quarterback? Why do you think he waited until the bye week to bench Phil?
Hiles: In a black and white world, I see Narduzzi’s logic. He gave his starting quarterback, a guy whom he handpicked out of the transfer portal, a guy who knew the offense, a month to prove himself. He waited until the bye because that is the best time to make a change at the game’s most important position. But the reality is Jurkovec didn’t deserve a month to prove himself. His play in back-to-back weeks against Cincinnati and West Virginia should’ve been enough to make a change. I think, by that point, we all could see Jurkovec wasn’t going to finish the year as the starter.
Read More
Carter: Narduzzi is a loyal coach. He’s gonna stand by his guys and stick with them as long as he can. Sometimes, that works out well. Sometimes, it doesn’t, which is the case with Phil. I also think he should’ve been benched after the West Virginia loss. At that point in the season, you still have the ability to turn things back over to Phil if Christian doesn’t play well. But instead, they played him until it reached a point where he couldn’t play any longer.
Joe: If Veilleux follows this game with an even better performance and Pitt throttles Wake Forest, which I fully expect, do you think Pitt can win out?
Hiles: OK, let’s not get ahead of ourselves. Pitt had a nice win over Louisville, but no, I don’t think it can win out. I’m not sure there are more than five teams in the country that could beat Notre Dame and Florida State in back-to-back weeks. Games like Wake Forest, Syracuse and Boston College look winnable, but I think this team would be lucky if it defeated Duke, Florida State or Notre Dame. A 6-6 season is perhaps within reach, but I think anything more would be a bit unrealistic to expect as of now. And if I’m wrong and Pitt does win out, it would be one of, if not the most impressive things Narduzzi has achieved in his coaching career, right up there next to the ACC title.
Carter: I’m not sure we can simply assume Pitt is going to match its quality of play from last Saturday just because it had a good game. Consistency has been a huge struggle for this team in all areas. I need to see it perform well back-to-back weeks before I even remotely entertain the idea of it finishing with a winning record. I think this team can reach a bowl, and if it does, that would be a great feat considering its 1-4 start. But I don’t see a world where this team wins its last seven games, with four of those wins coming against ranked opponents.
David: We’re officially halfway through the season. Which position group do you feel has made the most improvement since Week 1?
Hiles: I’d say the linebackers. SirVocea Dennis was such an important player on this team last season. I knew his absence would be felt. However, I’ve been impressed by what younger players such as Braylan Lovelace and Kyle Louis have shown. I also think older guys such as Solomon DeShields and Shayne Simon have been better and better as the season went on.
Carter: I’ll go with the group in front of the linebackers, the defensive line. The pressure has been getting better and better each week. The group as a whole looked great against Louisville. Young players such as Samuel Okunlola have made major improvements. I think Pitt fans have a reason to be excited about the young talent at both defensive line and linebacker.
Brad: Is the Panther the most deadly mascot in the ACC? I'll hang up and listen.
Hiles: We discussed how ROC the Panther would do in a battle against each of the opposing mascots on Pitt’s schedule once during a spring practice, but I never looked at the entire ACC. My top pick would probably go to Miami, as I don’t see anyone beating a Hurricane. Florida State’s Seminole and NC State’s Wolfpack would also be hard to beat. I’m not sure what powers a Blue Devil has and I honestly don’t know if I want to find out. But I think the Panther could hang around in a fight against just about anyone else. As far as the weakest mascot, I think we can all agree that title belongs to the Syracuse Orange.
Carter: If we’re going off actual mascots, Miami’s mascot is a bird, so I think ROC could take him. I’ll just say this: I saw all of these mascots throw down during a dance-off during halftime last March at the ACC tournament, and ROC the Panther was the one who came out on top. So I don’t know who is the most deadly, but I do know who is the best dancer.
Thank you all for following along! Be sure to send questions on Twitter to @_NoahHiles and @CarterCritiques or email them at nhiles@post-gazette.com and ccarter@post-gazette.com. And subscribe to our FREE daily all-sports newsletter, PG Sports Feed.



Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.