Heather Lyke has tried three times to hire Hall of Fame softball coach Jenny Allard.

The most recent time came after Lyke announced Jodi Hermanek would no longer lead the Panthers back in May.

“When I started the search, two thoughts came to mind,” Lyke said. “I would say it was either ‘three strikes and you're out’ or ‘the third time's the charm.’ Lucky for us, we did not strike out and the third time's the charm.”

The timing was finally right for Allard after 28 seasons at Harvard.

Advertise with us

The goal was three decades with the Crimson. There, she was the Ivy League's longest-tenured and winningest softball coach. She boasted a 688-518-3 overall record, including 342-130-1 in league play.

But she started to become worried she wouldn’t be able to keep up the level of success at Harvard given everything she had on her plate and how quickly she was turning over young assistants.

That didn’t mean Allard was ready to give up coaching, but she didn’t really know what was next.

That is until she got a text from her former teammate at Michigan, Lyke.

“I thought, ‘Maybe at Pitt I could have a longer tenure because I would have more support, more help,” Allard said. “I don't have that level at Harvard. I've loved what I've done at Harvard, and it's been a great fit for me. ‘How can I stay in coaching longer?’ Because softball is a grind.”

Advertise with us

Coming to Pitt, there would be more resources, simply because of the nature of being in a Power Five program. The facilities are better. There is more staff to lean on. She doesn’t have to catch bullpens or throw at batting practice.

Simply stated, there was just more. It also helped that the athletic director had a passion for the sport.

That and Allard’s son, now 20, doesn’t need the stability of staying in one place anymore. Everything lined up, so she said yes.

Then the work began.

“My first priority was to meet the team,” Allard said. “I had to get in front of the team. So getting on calls with them, understanding who they are and how they were. We didn't even talk about, ‘Oh, what position do you play?’”

Advertise with us

She joked that she didn’t know graduate student Kat Rodriguez was mainly an infielder until she introduced the returning player to her family.

After her initial meeting with the team, she singled out the seniors and had a meeting with just them. Allard asked them to get with their teammates and put together information that’s important to them for the transition.

Twenty-four hours later, she was given a huge packet of information.

“They wanted to elevate,” Allard said. “They wanted to be pushed. They want to develop. They want to be really successful. They want to have a great strategy. They want to continue their strong culture of support of each other and having coaches that really can push them and develop them.”

Staffing was the second priority. There were three vacant assistant coaching positions and a director of operations role to fill.

Advertise with us

Allard brought over Lacy Schurr, who worked with her at Harvard, as the associate head coach. Together, they’re now looking to find others to build a winning staff.

The final priority was recruiting, both out of high school and through the transfer portal — something she didn’t really have to touch at Harvard.

Her first two weeks on the job were spent on the road reconnecting with incoming players and attending recruiting events. She was formally hired on June 19, but her introductory press conference wasn’t until Wednesday due to how busy she was.

“I've been here since Thursday night,” Allard said. “I've gone from the hotel to this building. I've gone to the airport a lot to pick up assistant coaches flying in and candidates and recruits. I went to yoga once. Oh, and last night, we went to dinner with my siblings.”

She’s got plenty of time until softball season starts in the spring but is trying to do her best to set the team up properly.

Advertise with us

Allard is confident the team will be able to find success simply because of a question she asked in her initial interview.

“What's the team GPA?” Allard asked. “They told me that GPA and I was like, ‘OK, all right. We're gonna win because they were. They were [winning] in the classroom and they were out of the classroom.’ If they're doing that level of achievement in the classroom, they're gonna put that level of effort on the field.”

Abby Schnable: aschnable@post-gazette.com and Twitter @AbbySchnable