Pitt men’s basketball coach Jeff Capel came out of the 2021-22 season knowing he needed to up his game in the transfer portal.
The Panthers went 11-21 overall and 6-14 in ACC play. They’d only retain five players come the fall.
It was only the second year in which the transfer portal had really become more relevant. Transfers no longer had to sit out a year in between programs. One-time transfers were now immediately eligible to play in the upcoming season.
Capel made sure to surround himself with people who had more of a background. He hired Kyle Cieplicki to serve as chief of staff and Jake Presutti transitioned to assistant athletic director of scouting.
Capel wanted to be more prepared once the portal opened after the completion of the 2021-22 season.
“I told our staff ... from now until I think I gave a date of July 1, we need to have a lot of wins,” Capel said. “That's going to be recruiting. It's going to be retention and recruiting.”
Read More
It’s the new era of college sports.
That season, 1,649 basketball players entered into the transfer portal, a small decrease from 2021 in which 1,687 went into the portal the previous year, according to the NCAA. 84% of those players were on scholarship.
Without the portal, Pitt or Penn State may have not made it into the NCAA tournament in 2023. Both teams were teams full of students who used to play for another university.
“Before the season was over, we had compiled a database of guys that could potentially go into the portal,” Capel said. “Once the season was over, we had an idea. Once the names started going in, we had contact right away where we could start that process.”
Capel had a lot of scholarship spots to fill, yet they didn’t reach out to a large number of players, only ones that met the needs of the team.
Then-Penn State coach Micah Shrewsberry was in a similar boat. He had returning players in Myles Dread, Jalen Pickett and Seth Lundy. He wanted to find players who fit the scheme he was building.
The problem with today’s transfer portal world comes hand in hand with NIL and the extra year of eligibility due to COVID-19, college basketball analyst Jeff Goodman said.
“Kids can just store the name of the portal, even if they're not sure they're done,” Goodman said, “even if they’re not planning on leaving. With college basketball, it’s like, ‘I'm gonna throw my name in the portal and just see who contacted me anyway.’ ”
Part of that is to gauge interest. Could they go somewhere else with their last year of eligibility and get more playing time? Could they go somewhere else and get more money?
The former is true for former Pitt player Greg Elliott. He played his first four seasons at Marquette averaging 5.6 points, 2.1 rebounds and 1.2 assists per game.
“I just felt like it was time for just a fresh start,” Elliott said. “I knew I had one more year and I just wanted to go somewhere where I could just be a difference.”
Elliott started in all 36 games for the Panthers and averaged 11.1 points, 4.0 rebounds and 1.1 assists.
Pitt’s entire starting lineup was full of players who transferred in: Jamarius Burton, Blake Hinson, Nelly Cummings, Fede Federiko and Elliott. Even ACC Sixth Man of the Year Nike Sibande didn’t start with the Panthers.
Penn State was in a similar position. Pickett transferred in when Shrewsberry took the job in 2021. Andrew Funk and Camren Wynter were pickups before this past season.
“Most coaches would rather have a less talented, more experienced player,” Goodman said. “You'd rather have an older dude, preferably one who has been in the program. You'd rather have a multiyear transfer if you can get one rather than maybe a one-year grad guy who's coming in having to learn the system right away. It still takes time.”
Pitt had an older starting lineup than some NBA teams, joining Penn State as one of the oldest teams in the nation.
The 2023 NCAA tournament had the oldest and most experienced teams in recorded history. The 64-team field had players with an average of 2.29 years of playing experience, a significant increase from 1.98 years in 2022 and 1.87 years in 2021.
A lot of that has to do with the extra year of eligibility. Between Pitt and Penn State, there were six graduate students in the starting lineups.
All but one came from a mid-major program.
“They've become essentially a feeder system,” Goodman said. “Everyone’s trying to take the best mid-major players.”
Capel said during the season he wanted to try to target guys that came from winning backgrounds. Cummings had played in back-to-back NCAA tournaments out of the Patriot League.
Out of the 23 players who earned Player of the Year honors from typical one-bid leagues this past season, 10 have transferred. At least six of those have landed at high major programs.
Pickett was named the 2019-20 MAAC Player of the Year while playing at Siena. He was Penn State’s best player this past season, averaging 17.7 points and 7.4 rebounds en route to earning All-American honors.
“It was great,” Pickett said during the season. “Coming from a mid-major to a Power Five conference and the coaches having faith in you that you can help win and play a certain way is definitely encouraging.”
It’s a benefit for these players who may have gotten overlooked in the past. And it’s only helping the high majors, too.
The mid-majors are getting the short end of the stick simply because they can’t compete resources-wise and monetarily with a power conference program.
Duquesne’s leading scorer in 2021-22, Primo Spears, entered the transfer portal after the completion of the season. He played at Georgetown for a season but recently committed to Florida State, joining the many mid-major players to play for a power conference.
“The positive is these kids are able to move around and have the flexibility to do what they want,” Goodman said. “It's in favor of the players, certainly.”
The transfer portal closed last Thursday, but there’s still constant movement. With Penn State’s Mike Rhoades taking over at the helm and Pitt losing four of its top five leading scorers, both looked to the portal once again to fill some holes.
Only time will tell if it worked for them. But one thing is certain: The transfer portal isn’t going away.
Abby Schnable: aschnable@post-gazette.com and Twitter @AbbySchnable






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.