Welcome to the Pitt mailbag, where the Post-Gazette reporters Noah Hiles and Chris Carter answer all of your questions about the Panthers. If you have a question, tweet them at @_Noahhiles and @Cartercritiques or email them at nhiles@post-gazette.com and ccarter@post-gazette.com. Noah and Chris will answer your questions in full length each Tuesday on YouTube. You can read the condensed version of the discussion below.
Dan: Pitt’s 2023 non-conference schedule must be one of the toughest in the country. What do you think their record will be after those 4 games?
Hiles: First off, I don’t think Pitt has one of the toughest non-conference schedules in the country. It’s definitely stronger than ones they’ve had in years past, but at the end of the day, it’s probably one ranked opponent in four games. As far as those four games go, I’ll say Pitt goes 2-2. Wofford is the only easy win. Cincinnati might be a tough challenge early on. West Virginia will be a crazy atmosphere. And Notre Dame is Notre Dame. Winning three of those four will be huge, but Pitt tends to find its footing much later in the season, so I will say it goes .500 in non-conference.
Carter: I’ll go with 3-1. I think Pitt being home against Cincinnati helps, and I just believe the Panthers are a better team right now than West Virginia, although that game won’t be easy. The only one they lose will be on the road at Notre Dame, which is of course a really difficult place to win for just about any team. If they can go 4-0 in non-conference, I think it will be a great sign for how the rest of the season will go.
Nate: What’s Phil Jurkovec’s floor and ceiling? Could we see him replicate what Penix did after transferring from Indiana to Washington? Or is that asking too much?
Hiles: I think Phil will be a solid quarterback, but he’s not going to be Michael Penix Jr. He threw the ball over 500 times last season. He tallied over 4,500 passing yards. I wouldn’t be shocked if he ends up being a Hissman finalist and a first-round pick next year. Phil is talented, but he doesn’t play in an offense that will allow him to put up those types of numbers. Phil’s floor is similar to what we saw last year from Kedon Slovis. His ceiling is similar to what we saw his best year at Boston College, which, if he does that with Pitt’s defense and rushing attack, could result in a 10-win season for the Panthers. It could also result in him being an early Day 3 draft pick.
Read More
Carter: Phil won’t be able to replicate Penix’s yards or touchdown passes, but he could replicate the efficiency. Penix threw 31 touchdowns and eight interceptions last year. Phil’s ceiling could be something like 24 touchdowns and five interceptions, which would be huge for this team. I think Phil has the physical tools to be a decent NFL prospect. A good season gets him drafted. He won’t be an All-American, but he has the potential to be a serious upgrade from what Pitt had at quarterback last year.
Derek: Is there reason to be more optimistic for football or basketball next season?
Hiles: Football. Experience matters and the football team has more key upperclassmen than the basketball team right now. I think football’s defense and rushing attack will be just as good as it was last year. If Pitt had a better quarterback last fall, it probably would’ve won 10 games. I think Pitt has a better quarterback this season, one that definitely understands the offense better. Basketball has a ton of talent, but those young guards worry me. Their ceiling could be higher, but the floor is definitely lower. Basketball is still figuring things out a bit. How can they build off last year’s success? Pitt football is a bit further along as a program right now, which allows me to believe it's more capable of having a big season.
Carter: I’ll go with basketball. I really like the young talent. If one of those guards can become a superstar, and you pair that with Blake Hinson, Fede Federiko and the twins, I think you could really have something special. I agree that their floor is lower than football’s. I just feel like the basketball team has more guys on its roster that could end up being true star-quality talents, which allow a program to achieve more than expected.
Tony: ACC travel question: Best campus, food spot and sports venue? If I can squeeze one more in, what’s the most underrated place for Pitt fans to make a road trip to?
Hiles: The best campus in the ACC is by far North Carolina — It’s just beautiful, but at the same time, not too fancy where you feel like you’re amongst a bunch of snobs. For food, you really can’t go wrong with any barbecue spot on Tobacco road. Brian Batko recommended Q Shack in Durham and it was incredible, but there are other places in the area that are equally good. For sports venues, Cameron Indoor Stadium is truly one of a kind. The media sit courtside, about two feet in front of the student section. You feel like you’re in the game. The noise, the intensity, the history of the building and the program, it’s all really unique. Finally, an underrated city for a road trip is Louisville. Both the football and basketball venues are awesome. The city has a ton of great food and drink places — especially if you enjoy whiskey. And if you’re a sports nerd like me, there are a lot of cool places to visit like the Louisville Slugger factory, the Muhammad Ali museum and Churchill Downs.
Carter: I haven’t done as much traveling as Noah, but I think I’ve been to some cool spots. My favorite campus I’ve checked out is Virginia Tech, I really enjoyed the trip down there this past basketball season. For the food, well, I always eat well when I’m in Miami. For the venue, I’ll go with Doak Campbell Stadium at Florida State. As far as underrated places to visit go, I’d say Charlotte. I had a great time when I covered Pitt football in the ACC championship. It’s not a college town, but it’s an underrated destination.
Mike: Carter Warren, Izzy Abanikanda and Deslin Alexandre all going to the Jets made me wonder who is the best former Panther to ever play in New York? Darrelle Revis or Curtis Martin?
Hiles: I think this one is easy. Martin had a great career, but I’m not sure if there are three better cornerbacks to have ever played football than Revis. The guy dominated the game in an era where the rules started to really favor passing. Again, Martin was an all-time great. Maybe it’s because I grew up watching Revis more than Martin, but I’m picking the guy from Aliquippa.
Carter: As an Allderdice man it pains me to say this, but I have to go with Revis as well. He’s a first-ballot Hall of Famer. He completely took away an entire half of a football field. Martin was special, but there were a lot of running backs that were also really, really good during his time. There weren’t a lot, if any, cornerbacks that were better than Revis for the bulk of his career.
Thank you all for following along! Be sure to send questions on twitter to @_Noahhiles and @Cartercritiques or email them at nhiles@post-gazette.com and ccarter@post-gazette.com. And subscribe to our FREE daily all-sports newsletter, PG Sports Feed.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.