DAYTON, Ohio — Pitt’s 60-59 win Tuesday night over Mississippi State in the NCAA tournament was the best moment for the program in Jeff Capel’s five-year tenure. The Panthers stood tall against an SEC team whose defensive metrics were among some of the best teams in the country and played at an unfamiliar pace that came down to clutch performances in the final 10 seconds.

But the win was bigger than just Jamarius Burton’s mid-range jumper that put Pitt up with 9.8 seconds left in the game, or Guillermo Diaz Graham’s block of a Tolu Smith layup with 2.7 seconds left. It was a culmination of what Capel’s been coaching his team to achieve all season and the hard work of players who were out to earn the program’s first NCAA tournament win since 2014.

Good

Capel has challenged Pitt’s defense for over a month — without much of an on-court response from his Panthers. He even pointed out Sunday, after the Panthers learned they would play Mississippi State, that Pitt hadn’t played well defensively since its Feb. 14 win over Boston College.

Advertise with us

But Tuesday night, all that changed. And it happened while Pitt called upon freshman forward Guillermo Diaz Graham to make his second start of the season after the team had to bench sophomore center Fede Federiko due to a knee injury. Pitt held the Bulldogs to 38.9% shooting and won the turnover battle, 7-14.

Diaz Graham faced Smith, Mississippi State’s 6-foot-11 top scorer and rebounder who earned first team All-SEC honors this season. But in that challenge, Diaz Graham stood tall, as did all of Pitt’s players in an inspired defensive effort.

“They were tonight who they've been all season long,” Capel said after the game. “Tough, resilient, unbelievably together. For Guillermo, as a freshman, to start in the NCAA tournament, play 37 minutes against an all-conference player that's a graduate, and to stand up to him and to fight throughout and then to make that block at the end. ... For us to be able to do that and to be able to grind out a game like this, I'm really proud of everyone.”

But it wasn’t just Diaz Graham who stepped up on defense. Pitt’s players adjusted their defensive game plan to bring double-teams and defensive help against Smith and the other Mississippi State forwards, who are bigger than Pitt’s frountcourt.

“It was [the] scouting report,” Burton said. “Coach [Capel] did a great job putting us in positions, knowing where they were going to be feeding the ball off of their plays, and [being ready to execute]. And for us, we just wanted to be there for our brother. We understood the type of battle he was going to be in, all-conference type of guy, that he was going to be going against, so we just wanted to have his back out there.”

Advertise with us

The effort left Diaz Graham exasperated after the game. He finished with just three points but added five rebounds, an assist and two blocks. Smith finished the game with 13 points, the lowest scoring total for him over a span of eight games, dating back to a Feb. 11 game against Arkansas.

“Man, I'm exhausted,” Diaz Graham said after the game. “That was a hell of a fight. He's a really good player, and he was trying to attack me every time. Of course he's bigger than me. Just fighting. He's bigger than me, but I'm going to fight more than you ... We knew they were going to come at me. I just had my team behind me to help me because I was at a disadvantage.”

What’s truly impressive isn’t just that the Panthers got an inspired effort from a freshman forward, but that they came together in short order and executed a layered plan. Mississippi State tried on-ball and off-ball screens, backdoor cuts, and fed the ball into their forwards all night. But Pitt had a counterpunch for each plan, even when the Panthers’ personnel was at a size disadvantage.

Bad (for Mississippi State)

Pitt’s offensive plans changed entirely between the first and second halves. The Panthers had a 35-34 lead at halftime because their 8 of 13 made 3-pointers in the first half balanced out the Bulldogs’ 16-2 points advantage in the paint. Pitt knew that it didn’t have the size to contend and win with inside offense against Mississippi State, so it played to its strengths and shot from the outside, where the Bulldogs’ size mattered less.

Advertise with us

And then, that strategy disappeared. Mississippi State made a priority to take away the 3-point line and force Pitt to score on the inside. The Panthers weren’t fazed and adjusted accordingly.

“They kind of stayed with shooters a little more,” Nelly Cummings said. “Every team is going to make adjustments at halftime, so I think we had to make the same type of adjustments and realize what type of game we were in and take what the defense was giving us.”

“We've got some lethal shooters on our team,” Burton added. “I remember at that point in time, when Blake [Hinson] was setting screens, they didn't want to switch, they wanted to stay with him. And sometimes we exploit that mismatch with him at the 4 [position] setting those screens, because you've either got to stop the ball or stop him. They did a good job taking him away, but he made a big one down the stretch for us, and we just continued to take what the defense gave us.”

Pitt went from making eight 3-pointers in the first half to just one in the second half, and that was Hinson’s shot from the March Madness logo in the middle of the court to give the Panthers a 58-52 lead with 3:08 left in the game. It shot 47.4% on 2-pointers in the second half.

That means the Bulldogs achieved their goal to drag Pitt into the style of game that favored the SEC team’s strengths, and the Panthers still walked out unscathed.

Advertise with us

Ugly

Make no mistake, this was an ugly game. Both teams shot less than 40% from the field, and more than half of Mississippi State’s offense came from points in the paint. That would’ve fit the skill set of last year’s Panthers who didn’t have a consistent offensive presence and needed to win with defense and rebounding.

But this year’s Panthers are different. Their 313 made 3-pointers on the season were second-most in the ACC. They prefer a fast-paced offensive game that allows their shooters to set the tone and extend leads at a quick pace. But that adjustment to play a style of ball in crunch time that hadn’t suited the Panthers all season long was a deciding factor in the win.

“I just think it's a group of fighters, Capel said of his team. “It's a group that really believes in themselves, really believes in each other. We've said the strength of our team is the team. We've said that from the beginning. Tonight was another example of that. Guys stepped up and made big plays throughout. Some of those finishes that Nelly made, Blake taking that what-the-heck 3, but that's who he is. I've got to live with that. I'm yelling at him when he shoots it and he looks at me like, ‘Whatever.’”

“I'm just unbelievably proud,” Capel continued. “To be on this journey with them, I don't want it to end.”

Christopher Carter: ccarter@post-gazette.com and on Twitter @CarterCritiques