Pitt’s recruiting class won’t blow away national analysts on paper, but there’s still something to be said with how Pat Narduzzi assembles new recruits for his program.

Rivals.com ranked the Panthers as having the 46th-best 2023 recruiting class Wednesday afternoon as national signing day was coming to a close, but the program’s class dropped back to 50th. But Narduzzi isn’t concerned about that.

“We were about 85% effective in bringing the guys [we wanted] in,” Narduzzi said Wednesday. “That’s a pretty good high-school rate. I’m still that type of guy who wants to build our roster out of high-school players. A lot of people are dipping into the portal, maybe too much.”

Pitt’s haul of high-school recruits included only a single four-star recruit in defensive tackle Isaiah Neal out of Baltimore. Compared to that of Penn State, whose class was ranked 13th in the country by Rivals with 14 different four-star recruits, there’s a different pedigree.

Advertise with us

But that’s also been how Narduzzi has assembled his rosters that have been the most successful for Pitt. His best players over the past three seasons are an example of Pitt developing three-star recruits to be star players.

Patrick Jones II, Rashad Weaver, Jordan Addison and Kenny Pickett were all consensus All-Americans as three-star recruits from their respective classes, and Calijah Kancey was a three-star recruit who became Pitt’s 15th unanimous All-American.

That also doesn’t include other key contributors like the slew of first team All-ACC players that carried the Panthers to an 8-4 regular season in 2022. SirVocea Dennis was a first team All-ACC linebacker for Pitt this year and was a two-star recruit in Pitt’s 2019 class. Wide receiver Jared Wayne and running back Israel Abanikanda both made first team All-ACC this year and were three-star recruits for their respective classes.

Narduzzi’s program thrives off players’ development behind already established starters. Even four-star recruits like redshirt freshman Elliot Donald, a Central Catholic graduate who’s the nephew of Aaron Donald, haven’t played much because of the depth Pitt has had on its roster.

That being said, a closer look at some of the standouts from Pitt’s class still shows a lot of potential for the Panthers to continue the development of key contributors to strong future teams for the Panthers.

Advertise with us

First to break out: Isaiah Neal | DT | 6-foot-3, 270 pounds | Baltimore | 4 stars

Neal possesses leadership qualities that attracted Pitt’s attention right away, especially when he announced his commitment in 2021.

“He goes by the nickname of ‘Ghost,’ ” Narduzzi said of Neal. “He’s another one of those guys — maybe he’s not big enough for [other programs], but we think he’s a diamond in the rough. I’ll be shocked if this guy isn’t a captain by his senior year. He’s got leadership qualities kids don’t have nowadays. I’ll never forget when he committed in the Champions Club at [then] Heinz Field. He grabbed the mic, told everyone what he was doing, and it was impressive. He’ll be here mid-year.”

Pitt has up-and-comers at defensive tackle like Donald and freshman Sean FitzSimmons of Central Valley High School. Neal could be the next in line with them to continue the dominant run the Panthers have had with their defensive line under coach Charlie Partridge.

Most versatile: Montravius Lloyd | RB | 6-foot, 205 pounds | St. Petersburg, Fla. | 3 stars

Advertise with us

One of the biggest plays for Pitt in 2022 was Abanikanda’s touchdown reception that tied West Virginia late in the Panthers’ season-opening win. But after that, no other touchdowns were thrown to running backs.

Lloyd is a talented running back who flipped between skill positions in high school and expressed his willingness to continue that versatility in Pitt’s offense.

“Montravius is a super football player,” Narduzzi said. “He’s a guy who can do it all. He played tailback as a junior and played receiver this past season. He’s an unselfish [player] and told us, ‘Coach, I’ll do whatever it takes.’ He’s a slash guy and he’s exciting, fun to watch.”

If Lloyd can help Pitt’s running back room as a receiving back, it could open up the Panthers to have more formations with two running backs that flex Lloyd out into the slot as an extra receiver and force mismatches for opponents.

Sleeper pick: Jordan Bass | LB | 6-foot-3, 198 pounds | Hampton, Va. | 3 stars

Advertise with us

Bass is a bigger linebacker who showed the ability to play all linebacker positions in high school. That quality was a big reason why Dennis became a major contributor for the Panthers.  If Bass can learn quickly, he could replenish a linebacker room that will be losing its leader for the past two seasons.

“Led his team to a state championship,” Narduzzi said of Bass. “Coach [Ryan] Manalac watched him, and he was the best player on the field by far. He’s athletic, tough, smart and gigantic. He can play all three [linebacker] positions. In all my 33 years of coaching, it was the first time a family asked us to help put up the Christmas tree. That’s something I’ll never forget.”

Surprise addition: Ryan Carretta | OL | 6-foot-5, 318 pounds | Columbus, Ohio | 3 stars

Pitt had to beat out several other major Power Five conference programs to land Carretta. Tennessee, Michigan State, West Virginia, Kentucky, Louisville and even Michigan, who’s preparing for the College Football Playoff, all offered Carretta after Pitt gave its initial offer.

But despite that, Carretta chose the Panthers after his official visit in June and followed through by signing Wednesday. Narduzzi revealed one of his position coaches played a role in Pitt’s edge over the competition.

Advertise with us

“Big interior offensive lineman,” Narduzzi said of Carretta. “He’s smart and everything we want. We had to beat a few Big Ten teams on this guy. Our linebacker coach Ryan Manalac is from that area and coached [Carretta’s] brother [Connor Carretta] at Bucknell. We have a good prior relationship with that family.”

One that got away: WR Daidren Zipperer | 6-foot-1, 170 pounds | Lakeland, Fla. | 3 stars

Zipperer committed to Pitt on Sept. 24 but decommitted from the program on Oct. 24, weeks after an official visit to Utah, where the receiver would eventually land. But Narduzzi insinuated there might have been name, image and likeness funding that pulled Zipperer away.

“We lost one to Utah that was a good receiver,” Narduzzi said. “I think [NIL] had something to do with it. You sometimes don’t know what to believe. Even when someone gets money, there’s a lot of lying going on. I’ve talked with enough agents who’ve given me feedback that what they’re being told is not true when [the student-athletes arrive to their programs]. Then, they’re kind of disappointed, and then, they wind up in the portal, call us back and say they want to come to Pitt. Sometimes it’s us; sometimes it’s academics; and sometimes it’s tampering.”

Christopher Carter: ccarter@post-gazette.com and on Twitter @CarterCritiques