In a six-minute news conference Saturday, coach Pat Narduzzi said the word “tape” eight times. As in, the seventh-year Pitt coach had to “check the tape” or “look at the tape” to see how on earth Pitt lost to Western Michigan.
Defensively, it was pretty obvious what happened. The Broncos hit slant route after slant route with little resistance. Western Michigan’s run-pass option offense carved up Narduzzi’s scheme and thwarted defensive coordinator Randy Bates’ play-calling from start to finish.
“It starts with the coaches,” Narduzzi said after the 44-41 loss, the worst of his tenure and Pitt’s first home defeat to a non-Power Five program since Paul Chryst’s team fell to Akron in 2014. “We got outcoached today. And we’ve got to do a better job.”
Narduzzi also gave Western Michigan quarterback Kaleb Eleby his due. The 2020 All-Mid American Conference selection completed 23 of 35 passes for 336 yards and three touchdowns, oozed confidence, and was willing to stand in the pocket and deliver despite getting hit.
And make no mistake, Eleby got drilled. Narduzzi said he wished his defense blitzed more, but Bates wasn’t shy about applying pressure — and it didn’t really work. Eleby was sacked only three times, and more often than not, he found wide receivers Skyy Moore and Corey Crooms out of the slot over the middle for easy first downs.
Eleby completed four of his first five slant throws. Pitt blitzed on three of the four connections. Eleby found Crooms and Moore for 13, 11, 15 and 11 yards, all four passes moving the chains. A safety, either Brandon Hill or Erick Hallett, was isolated on the receivers and made the tackles after Crooms or Moore caught it underneath.
Read More
Western Michigan continued to pick on Pitt en route to a surprising 27-27 halftime deadlock. When the Panthers went to the locker room, they had to change something to stymie the RPO slant. Middle linebacker SirVocea Dennis said the defense did make adjustments, but respectfully declined to share exactly what those adjustments were.
But when Western Michigan went 4 of 5 for 102 yards and a touchdown on second-half slant route throws, it looked like much of the same from Pitt’s defense — committing linebackers at or behind the line of scrimmage and leaving its defensive backs one-on-one.
Norwin product Jack Salopek, filling in for Eleby at quarterback on the Broncos’ opening drive, hit Moore for 10 yards. Three Pitt linebackers sunk to the line of scrimmage to guard against the run option, freeing up space behind them for Moore, the former Shady Side Academy receiver.
On Western Michigan’s next drive, Pitt’s John Petrishen blitzed off the edge, two more linebackers caved to the line of scrimmage, and Eleby hit Croom — who glided in for a 54-yard score after Hallett and Hill collided attempting to tackle him.
On a third-and-12 in the third quarter, Bates sent five players after Eleby and dropped defensive end Habakkuk Baldonado into coverage. Eleby hit Crooms for 25 yards.
And on a critical third-and-7 — when Pitt needed a stop, down three points with less than three minutes to go in regulation — the Panthers sent five. Eleby got popped, but connected with Crooms over the middle for 13 yards, all but sealing the upset.
Western Michigan’s only second-half incompletion on a slant route really shouldn’t have been. Pitt cornerback Damarri Mathis clearly held his receiver, but the referee missed it. Officiating was bad on both sides, for what it’s worth. But the Panthers appeared helpless against one of the simplest routes in the book.
“They were able to find the holes, which is something we have to clean up in practice,” Dennis said. “They did a good job picking us apart.”
Fourth-down decision
Western Michigan running back Sean Tyler put the nail in the coffin on a 34-yard gain with two minutes to go. But it felt like all was lost for Pitt four drives earlier.
Down 41-34 with 10 minutes left, Narduzzi went for it on fourth-and-6 from Western Michigan’s 48-yard line. Right guard Keldrick Wilson got blown up on the play, and Kenny Pickett was swarmed on a 14-yard sack. Western Michigan started in Pitt territory and was in field-goal range in a matter of moments — ultimately taking a two-score lead on a 29-yard kick.
Now, Narduzzi went for it on fourth down earlier in the drive. Pitt converted a fourth-and-1 around midfield. But just because it worked once doesn’t mean it should have happened again. Instead of pinning the Broncos deep with plenty of time left, Narduzzi gambled ... and lost.
Quick hits
• Owen Drexel’s second high snap led to a costly turnover. Pickett managed to catch the ball and tried handing it off to running back Rodney Hammond, but he couldn’t secure it. Western Michigan recovered and scored two plays later.
“Next time, I just have to follow him into the hole and eat it and take the minus-two yards,” Pickett said. “Live to play another down.”
• Drexel was replaced at center by Jake Kradel, and Wilson filled in at right guard. Narduzzi didn’t say if Drexel being replaced was injury or performance-related, simply saying, “Owen was out.”
• If not for Western Michigan’s self-inflicted wounds, the loss might’ve been worse. The Broncos had 11 penalties for 117 yards. Pitt, meanwhile, had eight penalties for 82 yards — the 20th time Narduzzi’s teams have had eight or more penalties in a game going back to 2018.
• Vincent Davis was once again Pitt’s preferred ball-carrier, logging 11 attempts. Five of those carries went for either a loss or a gain of two yards or less. Israel Abanikanda had only one carry for a loss of one.
• Pitt’s lone positive from the afternoon was its passing offense. Lucas Krull became the first Pitt tight end to secure touchdowns in three straight games since Dorin Dickerson did so in five consecutive contests in 2009. And Jordan Addison became the first Pitt player to have three touchdown catches in one game since Tyler Boyd at Duke in 2013.
Johnny McGonigal: jmcgonigal@post-gazette.com and Twitter @jmcgonigal9






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.