All week long, Pitt players and coaches talked about how they couldn’t sleep on Western Michigan. They couldn’t rest on their laurels of a win in SEC country. They had to put that seemingly momentous occasion at Tennessee in the rear-view mirror, play mistake-free, tackle well and buck the Broncos’ upset bid.

Well, they didn’t.

Pitt — a team that set high expectations for itself in the preseason, one that wanted to be “different” than the mediocrity that preceded it — lost to Western Michigan. The Panthers were gashed in a 44-41 defeat to the tune of 516 total yards, inarguably the worst loss of Pat Narduzzi’s seven-season tenure.

“Obviously a disappointing performance by our guys,” Narduzzi said. “It starts with me. Obviously I didn’t have them ready to go. ... We got outcoached today, and we’ve got to do a better job.”

Advertise with us

Pat Narduzzi recaps Pitt’s upset loss to Western Michigan on Saturday afternoon at Heinz Field

Pitt, a 14-point betting favorite, was ripped to shreds by the Broncos’ run-pass-option offense. Quarterback Kaleb Eleby, a 2020 All-MAC selection, completed 23 of 35 passes for 336 yards with three touchdowns. Most of his receivers were obtusely open, either because of poor coverage or ill-timed blitzes.

Shoddy tackling, an issue last weekend, reared its ugly head again. The Panthers were broken, not bent, in the second half, allowing conversions on 5 of 8 third-down opportunities. At one point, Pitt gave up a 54-yard touchdown because two defensive backs collided. Every error the Panthers could make, they made.

“They did a good job picking us apart,” linebacker SirVocea Dennis said of Western Michigan. “... They came out here and balled.”

Offensively, Pitt tried to keep up. Kenny Pickett threw for 382 yards, completing 23 of 31 passes. He also scrambled for 49 yards, leading the Panthers in rushing in the total absence of a ground game. Not by coincidence, Narduzzi’s team lost the time of possession battle 40:15 to 19:45.

For a minute, it looked like that wouldn’t matter. Pickett connected on 10 passes of 15 yards or more. His six touchdown passes were the most by a Pitt quarterback since Tom Savage against Duke in 2013. Three of them went to star receiver Jordan Addison. Two landed in the hands of tight end Lucas Krull. And his final score found Jaylon Barden with 3:48 to go in regulation.

Advertise with us

Naturally, Pickett wasn’t satisfied with that. He said the offense’s weekly goal is to score 50 points. “So we came up short there,” the fourth-year starter said.

But while leading for only 4 minutes, 26 seconds of the game’s 60 minutes — against a team that was picked to finish third in the MAC’s West division — Pitt’s pass-heavy attack at least gave it a chance. The defense just needed to make a stop after Barden’s score. And like it did all afternoon, it failed, ending Pitt’s hopes for an unblemished non-conference slate and casting doubt on a team that backed itself as an ACC Coastal division contender.

“We’ll move forward,” Narduzzi said. “It’s one game. It’s not an ACC game. All of our goals are still ahead of us. It’s one ballgame.”

“We’ll see how tough we are, right?” Pickett added. “When things are smooth sailing, it’s easy. Now we have a loss [when] we should’ve won.”

Moving past Marino

Advertise with us

With his first touchdown of the day, Pickett made a bit of history, bypassing Dan Marino and claiming the second spot on Pitt’s all-time passing yards list.

Pickett entered the game fourth, needing 50 yards to surpass Tino Sunseri (8,590) and 57 to topple Marino (8,597). He jumped both on a 67-yard connection with Addison.

Pickett, who now has 8,923 career passing yards, will need a productive rest of the season to challenge for the top spot. Alex Van Pelt’s 11,267 is the number to beat.

Injury scare

One of Pitt’s three turnovers was a fumble by Pickett while scrambling. But what followed could’ve been worse than the giveaway.

Advertise with us

After diving head-first for a first down, Pickett exited the field flanked by team trainers, holding his left shoulder in obvious pain. He immediately left the sideline and walked down to Pitt’s locker room area to be evaluated further.

In his absence, Nick Patti stepped in and performed fine, completing two passes for 33 yards. But when Pickett returned, he did so with aplomb. On his first two full drives back, Pickett completed 7 of 7 passes for 109 yards and two touchdowns.

Pickett said he’ll be fine for next week’s game, Pitt’s final non-conference meeting before ACC play begins.

Up next

The Panthers will have a week to lick their wounds before hosting New Hampshire.

Advertise with us

New Hampshire, a Football Championship Subdivision (FCS) school, is a contender in the Colonial Athletic Association. The Wildcats were ranked No. 23 in this week’s FCS top-25 poll after beating Stony Brook and Towson in their opening two games.

Still, the Panthers ought to be big favorites — even after Saturday’s disappointment.

Johnny McGonigal: jmcgonigal@post-gazette.com and Twitter @jmcgonigal9