Distant as it may seem, Michael Behonick can still remember his first day as an assistant coach with the Pitt men’s soccer program in January 2016, the moment when the full extent of the challenge he had accepted came clearly into view.
The Panthers were, to put it mildly, in a tough spot. A program that was already struggling in its final few years in the Big East was woefully overmatched in the ACC, with a 0-22-5 conference record in its first three years in the league. There was hope with the arrival of Jay Vidovich, a national championship-winning coach whose staff Behonick was joining, but for all of Vidovich’s accomplishments, could he truly replicate that success at a place so unaccustomed to it?
“We were really far off, from a culture side to a wins and losses side, to talent,” Behonick said. “Almost every facet of the program we had to make some significant changes to get where we are today.”
Where they are today is a drastically different place than the one they stepped into more than five years ago.
Pitt enters its second-round NCAA tournament game Sunday as the event’s No. 2 overall seed, earned after a 13-3 run through the regular season that saw it spend several weeks as the No. 1 team in the country. For a program that was riding a 52-game winless streak in conference play as recently as Sept. 2017, it has been a remarkable turnaround, likely one of the most impressive in Division I athletics this century.
The Panthers have found a way to not only compete in arguably the toughest conference in the country, but thrive. The conventional wisdom for Vidovich and his staff was that if they could break into the upper echelon of the ACC, they could viably contend for national championships. Now, they’re here, even sooner than the man at the helm of the operation expected.
Read More
“Did I really think within these five years that we’d be Number 1 and be the coastal division champions at this stage? Probably not realistically,” Vidovich said. “It’s not a realistic proposition.”
Accelerated as the timeline may seem, the road from unrealistic to reality was methodical.
From 2009-16, Pitt went 4-58-9 in conference games. Of its 22 losses against ACC teams from 2013-15, its first three years in the league, 18 were by at least two goals. The Panthers weren’t just losing; they weren’t competitive. For all the move to the ACC provided for Pitt’s reputation and bottom line, it had thrust the men’s soccer program into a seemingly unwinnable situation. Something had to change, and it had to be something drastic.
“They were one of the bottom teams in all of NCAA Division I, not just the ACC,” Behonick said.
In Nov. 2015, Joe Luxbacher, Pitt’s head coach for 32 years and a former standout player at the school who became synonymous with the program, retired from his post. As then-athletic director Scott Barnes searched for a replacement, an unexpected candidate emerged.
Vidovich had coached for 21 seasons at Wake Forest, securing five ACC titles, making four consecutive College Cups (college soccer’s Final Four) and winning the 2007 national championship. He left the Demon Deacons in 2014 to coach in the professional United Soccer League, but after one year, he yearned to return to the college game. In Pitt, Vidovich saw a chance to get back in the ACC and build a program in his own image. In Vidovich, Pitt had an opportunity to hire a coach a program in its shape would typically have little, if any, chance of landing. With that, an unlikely marriage was forged.
What followed was a wholesale rebuild. The foremost priority was talent acquisition. Honest, occasionally uncomfortable conversations were had with returning players about what their roles would be moving forward. When it came to recruiting, coaches had to sell an idea, not a tangible product.
“There are other programs in the ACC that have a long line of history. We didn’t have that,” Behonick said. “They had to understand that they were going to make their own history. They were going to build it from the ground up. If they could have success and find success, they would be a part of the history of this program.”
They found players willing to take that chance. Within Vidovich’s first two seasons, the Panthers secured commitments from three players who would eventually be drafted by MLS teams in the years to follow — Pol Planellas, Javi Perez and Edward Kizza — along with recruits like Alexander Dexter who are now standouts on the current team.
The results that came with that talent gradually began to show. After going 2-13-3 in Vidovich’s first season, Pitt started the 2017 season 8-6 before losing its final four games. It posted a nearly identical record the following year at 8-10-1 before a breakthrough in 2019, when it went 10-8-2, made its first NCAA tournament since 1965 and, once there, won its first ever game in the tournament.
Those triumphs set the stage for what has occurred this season, but it was a loss — a 5-0 second-round defeat to eventual national champion Georgetown — that may have played the biggest role in pushing the Panthers to the heights they’ve reached.
“They learned how to win last year, but they also saw what it was like to run into a team like a Georgetown,” Vidovich said. “When we ran into them in the NCAA tournament, they could tell — I think we all could tell — it was a different level.”
New additions have helped, as well, as Pitt brought in a new goalkeeper, two new outside fullbacks and a new center midfielder.
It’s the latest step in a roster construction project that has come with an unmistakable international influence. Of the team’s 11 leaders in minutes played this season, nine are from outside the United States, along with a 10th, Dexter, who was born in Brooklyn but attended high school in Germany.
Leading scorer Valentin Noel, who is tied for third among Division I players in goals, is from France. Among the Panthers’ other points leaders are players from Serbia (midfielders Veljko Petkovic and Filip Mirkovic), France (forward Bertin Jacquesson and fullback Raphaël Crivello), Spain (fullback Arturo Ordoñez) and Germany (Jasper Löeffelsend), as well as team minutes leader Jackson Walti (Switzerland).
Together, it’s a group that managed to win more ACC games in a single season (nine) than it had in the previous four seasons combined. The increased talent within the program has helped, but so, too, has a makeover of the program’s culture.
“They always search out ways to make themselves better — how to grow in their situation, how to handle the challenges to do it on a daily basis. There’s not really a secret formula,” Vidovich said of what separates good players from great ones. “It’s just that it’s very difficult. I think the human person is made to take shortcuts. The special ones are the ones who always get pushed on a daily basis.”
Whether that record-breaking regular season is the precursor of a long postseason run will begin to be answered Sunday. A win there followed by two more victories — No. 7 Washington is the next-highest-ranked team in their quadrant of the bracket — would send them to the College Cup and set a new benchmark for success for the Panthers.
For a program that had never won an NCAA tournament game until 17 months ago, it’s a rapid ascent that has led it to a brave new world. And if Pitt is able to adhere closely to the vision its coaches have for it, this season may just be the start.
“It’s the consistency across the board of no matter who you’re playing, no matter when you’re playing, no matter what conditions you play in that sets top teams apart,” Behonick said. “It sets the Barcelonas and Man Citys apart. It sets the teams that consistently win titles year in and year out apart.”
Craig Meyer: cmeyer@post-gazette.com and Twitter @CraigMeyerPG






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.