Each week through the end of the 2020-21 season, Craig Meyer, the Post-Gazette’s Pitt basketball writer, will answer reader questions about the Panthers. And some other stuff, too.

If you want to submit a question, you can email Craig at cmeyer@post-gazette.com or hit him up on Twitter @CraigMeyerPG.

Barry: I am a big fan of Capel, but am starting to have some serious doubts. In two and a half years he has yet to develop a point guard, three point shooting is a mess, been unsuccessful with transfers, the big men are average at best and the scariest of all is that there does not seem to be any hope in recruiting. The one exceptional player that they have might leave after this season. How can we be optimistic of the future?

Craig: It’s wild to think how far we’ve come in not even two weeks, going from the exuberance of beating Duke to three straight losses. But after the most recent one, a 26-point drubbing against Notre Dame, I can’t say I blame people for feeling this way.

Advertise with us

Right now, I’d have to imagine it’s hard to be optimistic about the future, something I don’t think necessarily changes with, say, an unexpected win on Wednesday against Virginia Tech. In just eight days, Pitt severely hampered its NCAA tournament resume, losing to the last-place team in the ACC and then the aforementioned implosion against another bottom-tier team in the league. It’s now 91st in the NET rankings, putting an NCAA tournament berth that seemed so obtainable 11 days ago that much farther out of reach. The fear of a third late-season collapse in as many years looms.

If that doesn’t materialize and the Panthers make a postseason of some kind, be it the NCAA tournament or the NIT, that’s a nice step for them as a program. But what happens after that, especially if Justin Champagnie leaves for the NBA after this season? And with nobody committed for the 2021 recruiting class? Things can obviously change, and do so quickly, but right now, it’s perfectly reasonable to be a little frightened or, at the very least, profoundly uncertain.

Rich: Just wondering your thoughts on whether it’s possible to have a sustained winning program in a city like Pittsburgh where there is little local talent, stiff competition from professional teams (with HOF talent) for fan interest, and little philanthropic giving to the university for the sports program?

Craig: It’s certainly possible because Pitt has shown in this century that it is, finishing in the top 20 10 times in a 12-year period from 2001-13. In five of those instances, it was in the top 10. Ben Howland, Jamie Dixon and the bevy of talented players they coached showed it can be done.

Now, how likely is it that such a run can be replicated? To me, it’s not. Prior to that stretch, the Panthers had only finished the season ranked in consecutive years once, back in the 1987 and 1988 seasons. Even the Billy Knight-led Elite Eight team in 1974 was an outlier, as that was the only time in a 17-year span that Pitt made the NCAA tournament. It’s hard to do it sustainably here for some of the reasons you mentioned. Pitt’s not in a talent-rich region for basketball, it’s a college in a pro-centric market and it doesn’t have the same resources the sport’s major powers do.

Advertise with us

Could it have become that way if that 2000s success continued at the rate it was? Sure. But even by the end of Dixon’s tenure, things had fallen off a bit and five years after Dixon left, this is a program still trying to make it back to the NCAA tournament, something that was once a given to the point where it was taken for granted. If anything, I think Dixon’s final five years at the school, when the Panthers made three NCAA tournaments, is a more feasible bar for success at a program like this, though you’d hope one of those years could come with something better than a No. 8 seed.

Victor: It seems that people have used the lack of energy/focus/preparation line about Pitt frequently during Capel’s tenure. How much of that actually is on the coach, and how much of it is that there’s only so much a coach can do, and this is just what this group of players is?

Craig: It ultimately comes down to something innate within the players, their personalities and what makes them tick. Capel, or any coach, can’t completely control that, but they do have a significant role in helping to channel that or to shape the mentality of these players and how they approach the game. It’s not something you can simply throw your hands up at if you’re a coach. Trying to get hard-headed college-aged men to change their ways is difficult — I get it — but this is why you get paid $3 million a year.

Evan: Saturday’s game was an absolute train wreck in every way, and Pitt’s next few games are a tough stretch. What’re they going to have to do/ change up to get back on track and possibly get back in the discussion for the tourney?

Craig: It’ll take quite a bit and not just a single win. We’re talking about an extended stretch of victories or games against elite opponents in which they’re actually competitive. That wasn’t something I worried about with this team until that Notre Dame game. Now, I look at their schedule and can talk myself into them losing every matchup that remains. While they’re 91st in the NET right now, well beyond what could be considered the NCAA tournament bubble, they have several opportunities for wins against highly ranked opponents the rest of the way that could enhance their tournament resume. They have three games against teams that are currently Quad One opponents and two others against Quad Two foes.

Advertise with us

Whirlybird: Is this what Pitt expected from Nike Sibande, or were they counting more on production from him? Was conditioning an issue while his eligibility lingered?

Craig: I think they expected more. I know I certainly did. I didn’t think he was going to be one of the team’s top scorers, but a guard who averaged at least 13.9 points per game for three years in the MAC is someone you’d expect more from than 3.2 points per game. The circumstances surrounding this season have obviously been unusual, with him effectively shelved for weeks waiting on a favorable NCAA decision, but he was practicing and working out with the team throughout that time.

It’s possible he finds his footing and becomes a reliable fourth or fifth scorer for Pitt. He has shown signs that he could do that. It’s only on 10 attempts, but he has made 40% of his 3-pointers, an outside shooting touch his team could use to complement Ithiel Horton and Champagnie. Then again, he’s three of 11 from inside the arc, which goes against the athletic slasher he was billed as. Based on what we’ve seen of late — 1.6 points in 8.4 minutes per game — it’s fair to wonder what exactly he’ll be able to contribute.

David: Don’t you think that given the number of Pitt football players likely to be drafted in the upcoming NFL draft, the team should’ve performed better and had a better record in the ACC this past season? Why didn’t they in your opinion?

Craig: Given some of the talent it had on that defense, and when that was paired with a senior quarterback who had some decent weapons around him, going 6-5 really feels like a squandered opportunity. Pitt has produced some remarkably gifted NFL players the past 20 years, but it has often come with a question — how can the Panthers have had all these guys and still be so consistently mediocre? Depending on how Rashad Weaver, Patrick Jones, Jaylen Twyman and Paris Ford do at the next level, it’s a question we could continue asking.

Advertise with us

Dan: Craig it seems to me, that Pitt has three very good players (Champagnie, X, Toney) and the supporting cast just isn’t very good yet (not to say they’re bad, so many are very young) so if the top three aren’t 100% locked in we get results like what we saw against ND. Am I wrong?

Craig: They’ve shown an ability to still do well if only two of them are clicking, like in the Duke game. But if only one of them is playing to their expected level, Pitt’s in deep trouble, as has been the case during the three-game losing streak. And that’s even with guys like Ithiel Horton and Abdoul Karim Coulibaly finishing in double figures in some of those contests.

Panther4Life: It seems that no other player impacts Pitt Basketball's chances of winning more than its PG "X". I've often said that Pitt will go as far as "X" goes. I still believe that he is a rare talent who can turn this season around if he becomes more consistent. What are your thoughts?

Craig: He’s naturally going to be important for them given how much the ball is in his hands and how much he factors into their transition game, which has been virtually non-existent the past two losses. But I’m going to veer a bit here and say it’s Au’Diese Toney. While Xavier Johnson’s scoring has been down during this three-game losing streak, his assists and turnovers aren’t drastically different, or changes in them cancel each other out a bit.

First six Power Five games: 13.7 points per game, 5.3 assists per game, 3.2 turnovers per game

Advertise with us

Past three games: 8.7 points per game, 6 assists per game, 3.7 turnovers per game

Meanwhile, using those same splits, Toney’s scoring went from 17 points per game to nine, his field goal percentage went from 43.1% to 34.4%, he went from shooting 33.3% from 3 to 11.1% and, most notably, he went from averaging eight free-throw attempts per game to 1.3.

Martin: Will the ACC tournament still be a traditional format with all eligible teams or will they reduce the number of teams because of Covid concerns/extra players and people entering the semi-bubble for the week?

Craig: As of now, it will be normal, but I wonder how many teams will ultimately opt out of it. I don’t know if there’s potential television money at stake that may prompt the conference to force their hand and make every team make the trek to Greensboro, but if you’re a team like Wake Forest or Boston College with no realistic NCAA tournament aspirations, or you’re a squad that is safely in the field and has nothing to gain, why jump through all those hoops to play?

PGH Mike: Thoughts on Capel decision to bypass Odukale for a walk on Saturday Both in game and again after X fouled out?

Advertise with us

Craig: I wouldn’t make too, too much out of it. It was a disastrous afternoon for basically everyone on Pitt. Capel has talked repeatedly about coaching on feel and how that dictates his in-game decisions. Given everything going on, he was trying to find something that might work or, potentially, send some kind of message. He’s only a walk-on, but the staff likes Onyebuchi Ezeakudo. His extended minutes signal something (or many things) didn’t go right for Pitt in that game, but I don’t know if it’s anything beyond that.

Hail to Pitt: When is an acceptable time to start a petition to ban panthers and penguins from playing the same night it seems like we can’t ever get wins on the same night? Obviously can’t include pirates because everyone knows nutting is a cheapskate

Craig: I haven’t watched a full Penguins game since the 2017 Stanley Cup, so I might be the wrong person to ask on this.

Ben: Top five memes of the last year or so?

Craig: It was a good year for memes. I typically traffic in SpongeBob memes, which are more timeless than recent, but from the past year, I’ll go with:

Advertise with us

5. The Glee “I am going to create an environment that is so toxic” one

4. Mike Pence and the fly

3. The Bernie Sanders “I am once again asking” one

2. How it started vs. How it’s going

1. Everything from the Last Dance, especially the “And I took that personally” bit. That documentary reminded us of the greatness of the greatest player to ever play the sport, but more important, it gave us a ton of memes.

Advertise with us

Corey: Winter is in full effect so let’s hear your ranking of the four seasons and justification please?

Craig: From top to bottom…

1. Fall: Fantastic weather and a busy, exciting time on the sports calendar. The leaves and stuff are cool, too, I guess. The only downside is the lingering dread of winter’s slow approach.

2. Summer: A little hot and muggy for my liking, especially because I sweat like Patrick Ewing. But the days are longer and there’s a lot to do outside.

3. Spring: This was my favorite season growing up in Kentucky because you got the lovely, mild weather of the fall for a solid month and change, but with summer to look forward to instead of winter. Problem is, I’ve lived the past 13 years in Pittsburgh and Boston, where spring is really just 50 degrees and raining six days a week, then one or two idyllic weather weeks followed by the sauna that is summer.

Advertise with us

4. Winter: Very, very little to like about it once you get past the holiday season. The main reason I love covering college basketball is because I grew up obsessing over the sport, but the second-best thing about it is that it keeps me so busy during January and February that I forget how miserable those months are.

Craig Meyer: cmeyer@post-gazette.com and Twitter @CraigMeyerPG