Each week through the end of the 2020-21 season, Craig Meyer, the Post-Gazette’s Pitt basketball writer, will answer reader questions about the Panthers. And some other stuff, too.

If you want to submit a question, you can email Craig at cmeyer@post-gazette.com or hit him up on Twitter @CraigMeyerPG.

JD: have what you seen from this team so far changed your perception of what you thought their ceiling was compared to the start of the season? Do you think they finish in the top half of the ACC or are we getting ahead of ourselves to think that?

Craig: The biggest thing, by far, is that each of its top three players has been as good as my more optimistic outlook for them. In Au’Diese Toney’s case, he has surpassed even that with the strides he has made offensively. I haven’t done a ton of research on every team in the league, but I would have to think Toney is one of the most improved players in the ACC, if not the most improved. Justin Champagnie has clearly taken that next step. Or, more accurately, the next five or six steps. Thus far, Xavier Johnson has bounced back from a disappointing 2019-20 season and would be even more productive were it not for getting himself into early foul trouble in a few games.

Advertise with us

Aside from those, at least two of the freshmen, Femi Odukale and William Jeffress, have shown themselves to be productive, useful players. John Hugley was in that category, too, before his indefinite suspension. Noah Collier could make it in there, but he’s not playing quite as much and has been tasked with being the team’s tallest player on the court for extended stretches. The freshmen, to me, were the biggest variables and they’ve shown themselves to be capable complementary pieces, even as Pitt’s top three players carry such a large share of the load.

Given all of this, I absolutely think a top-half finish in the league is possible (I round up and consider eighth in a 15-team league part of the top half). Once you get there, you’re firmly in the NCAA tournament conversation, which would have been on the edge of my most optimistic projection for them heading into this season. But a lot of that depends on whether they can answer my biggest question — can this team not fall apart in the second half of the ACC schedule the way its two most recent predecessors did?

Michael: Are all of the delayed games hurting or helping the teams development?

Craig: It undoubtedly makes things strange, and I think for the freshmen, and even someone like Abdoul Karim Coulibaly, there is the potential for their development to be hurt by not taking part in games and, instead, competing against the same guys exclusively for weeks.

For the team’s success this season, though, I think it helps. For starters, all of the delays meant Champagnie missed only two games when he would have been out for six otherwise. It also made this a much more well-rested team, something that could be a crucial factor in helping the Panthers avoid a late-season slide in which they look fatigued in most games.

Advertise with us

Matt: I dont mean necessarily this year, but what do you think champagnies pro potential look like?

Craig: He’s projected as a top-40 pick in the 2022 NBA draft, so he’s definitely someone viewed as a viable prospect at the next level. That’s for next year’s draft and carries an implicit message — there are some things he still needs to refine.

His 3-point shot is an obvious one, as he’s shooting just 25% from beyond the arc this season after shooting 26.2% last season. If he can add a consistent outside jumper to his repertoire, he’ll be a truly enticing offensive prospect, a tough-minded player who can finish effectively down low AND stretch the floor. While he’s not a bad on-ball defender, his off-ball defense needs a lot of work, too. He has a tendency of losing track of his man while being too fixated on the player with the ball.

Victor: One thing that stood out to me in Champagnie and Pitt’s great game Saturday is that Champagnie had zero 3 pt attempts and did lots of damage around the rim. Given the success, is shooting less 3s something they could emphasize him doing going forward, or was this just a fluke?

Craig: It’s kind of fluky. It was only the third time in his Pitt career that he didn’t hoist at least one 3 in a game, one of which, interestingly enough, also came against Syracuse. I don’t know how intentional it was. It was likely just part of the game’s natural progression. He was having so much success around the rim, especially in the second half, that it didn’t make much for him to stray too far away from the basket.

Advertise with us

Coaches and teammates still think he could be a good 3-point shooter — if nothing else, he has a nice stroke — so I don’t think placing harsh restrictions on him from beyond the arc is fair to an NBA prospect trying to develop that area of his game. But for an often lethargic offense, it doesn’t make a ton of sense to have someone making only one of every four attempts to be firing off a bunch of shots.

Donald: CBS has Pitt as one of the last four out. You think they should be in or out if the season ended tonight?

Craig: I saw a couple of mock brackets Monday that had Pitt in as an 11 seed, so it’s on the bubble, at the very least. It’s 54th in the NCAA’s NET rankings, which is the thing that basically replaced the RPI when looking at a team’s tournament resume. Given that there are 68 teams in the tournament and about 20 one-bid leagues that automatically get a team in, I would say that puts Pitt on the outside looking in. But thankfully for the Panthers — or unfortunately, given how things have gone in recent years — there are still a lot of games left.

Halvy: If Hugley is done for the season, who is the best option to provide quality minutes?

Craig: Terrell Brown makes the most sense, as you could use him and Coulibaly as a passable two-man rotation at the five, with Coulibaly playing a majority of those minutes. As we saw in the Syracuse game, when both of them got in foul trouble, it doesn’t always work that neatly, so in those instances, I would expect to see small lineups with Collier as the de-facto center.

Advertise with us

Pitt has been burned defensively with Collier down low, which isn’t totally unexpected. He’s already playing out of position, he’s a freshman who is still developing physically and he’s having to go against much bigger, more experienced players. As the season goes on, and then going into the future, he could become a more intriguing option down there. But right now, it’s more of a stopgap.

Dave: Any insight on Max Amadasun?

Craig: He’s really raw, with only five total minutes this season. He was brought in as more of a developmental player, someone who probably would have redshirted in a season that counted against his eligibility clock. I wouldn’t expect much from him this season.

Barry: Craig - in your opinion, what is the biggest surprise, both positive and negative, so far this season?

Craig: I’d say Toney has been my biggest surprise. I’ve always liked his game and am well-aware of what he is able to do on the defensive end, but I didn’t think he’d develop into the type of offensive threat he has evolved into. Then again, Champagnie coming back in 27 days from an injury that was supposed to keep him out six to eight weeks also qualifies.

Advertise with us

On the negative end, it’s Hugley. I really, really liked him as a prospect and was encouraged by what I saw from him in his first seven games. While his Pitt career isn’t officially over, it’s obviously in a perilous position.

Sam: What are the 3 point splits between the first and second half of games for the Panthers? I feel like Xavier Johnson especially has made a lot more 3s in the second half compared to the first.

Craig: That’s a great observation. There’s definitely a sharp split. In the first half of its nine games this season, Pitt is shooting 24.1% from 3 (27 of 112). In the second half of those contests, it is making 39.8% of its attempts (33 of 83). A lot of that has been influenced by how the Panthers did in three games — the wins at Northwestern, Miami and Syracuse. In those matchups, they went 4 of 33 in the first half (12.1%) and 18 of 35 (51.4%) in the second half.

Jim: Any idea last time Pitt scored 96 in any regulation conference game?

Craig: It scored 98 in a March 2008 win against DePaul, but if you don’t consider DePaul circa 2008 a major-conference team, you have to go back to Jan. 1991, when it scored 101 in a victory against Providence.

Advertise with us

Corey: In honor of Inauguration Day, who would be your starting lineup if you formed a basketball team of Presidents?

Craig: Donald Trump is not on this team. I know, I know — the vote was rigged against such an obviously great, majestic athlete. But let’s dig into the guys who made the cut, going in order from guards to big men.

• Dwight Eisenhower: People like to talk about point guards as being “floor generals.” Well, this guy was an actual general who helped defeat fascism in World War II. He also played football at West Point, so he’s got the proper athletic background.

• Barack Obama: Probably the most prolific basketball player to ever hold the office. He’s a genuinely decent player, especially for someone his age. That lefty stroke is sweet, too.

• Teddy Roosevelt: Every basketball team needs a goon, someone no opponent would dare cross. I’d say Teddy qualifies in that department.

Advertise with us

• Gerald Ford: Probably the most athletically accomplished president we’ve ever had, despite the satirical portrayal of him as a clumsy oaf. Ford was a two-time national champion football player at Michigan.

• Abraham Lincoln: At 6-foot-4, the tallest president we’ve ever had. Granted, basketball wasn’t invented until 26 years after Abe was assassinated, but it’s important to remember he was born in Kentucky. Speaking as a fellow Kentuckian, that sport is in our blood, even if, like me, you’re not particularly good at playing it.

Craig Meyer: cmeyer@post-gazette.com and Twitter @CraigMeyerPG