Sixty-one minutes before its game Tuesday against Louisville was set to tip off, Pitt came forward with the news it had known for about 24 hours — standout forwards Justin Champagnie and Au’Diese Toney would not be playing, both of them sidelined with injuries.
Whether it was intentional or not, the announcement came with a bit of gamesmanship. Down their top two scorers, the Panthers entered their matchup, one in which they were already underdogs, at a decided disadvantage. By Pitt not revealing those absences until the moment it did, the Cardinals’ pregame plans that revolved largely around their opponents’ two best players were, in an instant, useless.
There’s no hiding that anymore. While Toney could be back for the Panthers’ Tuesday game at Duke, Champagnie is out for the next six to eight weeks. Pitt’s opponents for at least the next month and a half know they’ll be facing a team without its most productive player and, unlike Louisville, will be able to plan accordingly.
Champagnie’s knee injury is devastating for the Panthers, dashing burgeoning hopes about this team and what it might be able to accomplish. It’s a fallacy to say that Pitt will try to replace Champagnie — not that it can’t try, because it certainly can, but it won’t succeed in doing so. There simply is no combination of players that can replace the 6-foot-6 forward.
The ways that he impacts and betters the team are too far-reaching and fundamental.
Scoring
Read More
The Brooklyn native is the team’s leading scorer at 17.8 points per game, but that only tells so much of the story.
While Xavier Johnson is the team’s primary ball-handler, Champagnie is maybe the most integral part of Pitt’s offense. In the six games he played, he took 30.6% of his team’s shots while he was on the court, the 94th-highest mark of any Division I player and the highest mark of any Panthers player, six percentage points ahead of the next-closest finisher (John Hugley at 24.6%).
For a Pitt offense that has struggled at times this season, ranking last among ACC teams in offensive efficiency, Champagnie was at his best capitalizing on high-percentage looks, many of which he created for himself. Nearly half of his shots came at the rim and he made a ridiculous 76.3% of those looks, nearly 14 percentage points higher than any of his teammates with more than a couple attempts. Of Pitt’s 172 points at the rim this season, Champagnie was responsible for 58 of them, more than a third of the total.
The Panthers have options to at least try to fill that void, certainly more than they would have had under circumstances that could have very easily been drastically different.
Toney’s pronounced offensive improvement and efficiency means that he, also at 6-foot-6, could assume a Champagnie-like role, similar to what he did as a freshman when he was the team’s de-facto power forward. While he’s positionally not similar, the recent eligibility of Nike Sibande provides Pitt with another scorer who can try to mitigate the damage of a team losing one of its three players averaging more than 7.3 points per game. Johnson will have to be much more available than he was in the loss to Louisville, when foul trouble limited him to 22 minutes. There are, theoretically, freshmen like William Jeffress and Femi Odukale who can develop while playing in smaller lineups Pitt may have to embrace in Champagnie’s absence, as well as players like Hugley and Abdoul Karim Coulibaly who can try to replace some of that low-post scoring.
Those options, workable as they may seem on paper, have their limitations. Toney isn’t quite the same rebounder Champagnie is, meaning he can’t feast on second-chance opportunities the same way his sophomore teammate does. Sibande’s an extremely welcome addition — think of where Pitt would be now had the NCAA not acted on granting all transfers immediate eligibility — but it’s unreasonable to expect a player who averaged 13.9 points per game in the Mid-American Conference last year to maintain that level of production in the ACC. With shooting figures of 44% from the field and 32% from 3-point range last season, he’s also not a particularly efficient player. Jeffress, Odukale, Hugley and Coulibaly are all promising players in their own way, but they still have a ways to go before they can be leaned on very heavily.
“I don’t think this is any shock — IT [Ithiel Horton], X and Nike have to step up,” Pitt associate head coach Tim O’Toole said after the loss to the Cardinals. “I think John’s got to be a presence, and AK [Coulibaly], he did some good things, but we’ve got to keep finding ways. Maybe we have to slow it down or pick it up to get more possessions in transition. That was the thing where we couldn’t rebound, we couldn’t even get out, and when we did, we were sluggish with it. So we’re going to have to keep looking at all different things, but the backcourt has got to be the strength, at least right now.”
Likely no statistic better encapsulates the uphill battle Pitt faces offensively without Champagnie than this one:
In the Panthers’ first six games this season, they scored 403 points on 362 possessions while Champagnie was on the court, an average of 1.11 points per possession. Without Champagnie, they scored 47 points on 61 possessions (0.77). If that doesn’t seem significant, consider this: using the 72 possessions per game Pitt has averaged this season, that’s the difference between scoring 80 points and 56 points over the course of a contest.
Rebounding
As it is with scoring, Champagnie’s team-best rebounds-per-game figure reveals his importance in that area only so much, even as he averages 7.3 more rebounds per game than his next-closest teammate (Toney).
From a sheer output standpoint, Champagnie has exactly double the number of defensive rebounds of his next-closest teammate — also Toney, who has 26 — and that gap exists despite the fact he has played one fewer game than much of the rest of his team. At the time of his injury, Champagnie was grabbing 28% of available defensive rebounds while he was on the court, with only Hugley, at 18.1%, within 10 percentage points of him.
Why’s that so consequential? For the previous three seasons, the Panthers finished among the bottom 30 Division I teams in preventing offensive rebounds. A nadir was reached last season, when they were 349th of 353 Division I teams in that category, only hauling in 65.5% of its opponents’ misses. They have improved on that mark this season, up to 73.4%, but there’s reason to fear they might fall off without Champagnie.
The same gulf between Champagnie and his teammates doesn’t exist on the offensive boards, as Hugley (12.2%) and Terrell Brown (23.2%) both have higher offensive rebounding percentages than their star teammate (12%).
Still, nobody on the team is as effective at capitalizing on those opportunities as Champagnie. In its first six games this season, Pitt had 81 second-chance points. Champagnie was responsible for 30 of those points, either by grabbing the offensive rebound that eventually led to the basket or by scoring the points himself. Sometimes there was flair to it, but often, it was creating a small bit of room for himself in a crowded group of bodies in the paint and finding his way to the ball before immediately putting it back in the hoop.
For a team like Pitt, with some of its offensive shortcomings, the importance of those second-chance points and the rebounds that led to them can’t be discounted.
Combating a kryptonite
One of the most encouraging aspects of Pitt’s 5-1 start to the season was its ability to calmly and capably work against zone defenses. For coach Jeff Capel’s first two years, it was something that regularly flummoxed the Panthers and, not surprisingly, their opponents would gleefully throw various forms of a zone against them, usually to great effect.
Part of that had to do with a dearth of quality 3-point shooters, at least last season, but part of that ineffectiveness against the zone came from Pitt not having a big man who can deftly work inside the zone’s soft spots.
With a year of college experience, Champagnie looked to be someone capable of doing that early this season. Some of those came off second-chance looks — zones generally increase the likelihood of offensive rebounds — but Champagnie impressed by working in the high post, where he would either take a shot, find a cutting teammate or take it off the dribble.
There are people who can replicate some of what Champagnie has done in that area. Coulibaly is making 75% of his 2-point jumpers this season and has shown nice vision, making him an appealing option in the high post, and Toney and Jeffress have shown an ability to penetrate the zone.
None of them, though, can provide exactly what Champagnie did.
The bottom line
Dire and deflating as Pitt’s situation is, it isn’t without some silver linings, at least if one is willing to search deeply enough for some.
His absence could prove to be a catalyst for the development of a number of young players who will be earning more minutes and being counted on in ways they otherwise wouldn’t have been, guys like Jeffress, Noah Collier and, to a lesser extent given the positional difference, Hugley and Odukale. These next two months could very well be a formative experience for them, accelerating their improvement and, in the process, strengthening Pitt’s bench and beefing up its rotation once Champagnie returns and aiding it significantly going into next season.
In the meantime, though, those hopeful visions of a future that may not come to be only mean so much. Without Champagnie for the majority of ACC play, a team that had shown progress, maybe enough to lead it to the postseason in some form, will now try to make the best of a season that could very easily be defined more by what could have been than what ultimately occurred.
For a program that appeared to be making tangible steps out of the frustration, disappointment and occasional misery that gripped it for much of that past four years, that hurts.
Craig Meyer: cmeyer@post-gazette.com and Twitter @CraigMeyerPG





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.