Before he said anything, before he tried to explain the seemingly inexplicable, Jeff Capel needed a second. Twenty-eight seconds, to be precise.

His Pitt team had just gone on the road for the first time in this pandemic-marred season and beaten a major-conference opponent. The 71-70 win itself wasn’t nearly as inconceivable as the way it unfolded. Over a 40-minute contest, the Panthers led Northwestern for just six seconds. With just 3:36 to play, they trailed by eight and with 35 seconds remaining, they were down by five. They had missed 22 of their first 24 shots and, later in the evening, had connected on just eight of their first 44 attempts as they stared at a 12-point deficit with about 16 minutes remaining.

Capel needed that extended pause to look at a copy of the box score sitting in front of him, a sheet of paper filled with its rows and columns of numbers that provided every last measurable detail of what had just unfolded. It told the unbelievable story he had seen end mere minutes earlier. Somehow, some way, Pitt had won.

Sophomore forward Justin Champagnie finished with 20 points, including the game-winning dunk with 5.6 seconds remaining, and a career-high 20 rebounds to lead the Panthers to an unlikely victory, capping off a 13-4 run to end the game. He became the first Pitt player since DeJuan Blair to have at least 20 points and 20 rebounds in a game, and at 6-foot-6, he’s the shortest ACC player to reach those marks in the past 25 years. Capel happily added that he had coached one other player who had achieved that rare feat -- Blake Griffin, who played for him for two seasons at Oklahoma before becoming the No. 1 overall pick in the 2009 NBA draft.

Advertise with us

All of those rebounds provide something resembling an explanation to the puzzling question of how, exactly, Champagnie’s team won. Five of those rebounds were among Pitt’s 19 offensive rebounds Wednesday, giving it 15 more than the Wildcats. From those rebounds, the Panthers got 18 second-chance points in a game in which every last point mattered.

Impressive and historic as Champagnie’s night was, Pitt’s triumph was far from a one-man show.

Au’Diese Toney added 18 points and eight rebounds, five of which came on the offensive end. Xavier Johnson had a team-high 21 points, 16 of which came in the second half to key the Panthers’ comeback.

“One of the great things about Xavier is his competitive spirit. One of the things that hurts him at times is his competitive spirit,” Capel said. “He really wants to win. He wants us to be good. He wants his teammates to be good. At times, he can think ‘OK, well I have to do it. I have to do it.’ One of the things we talked about at halftime was ‘We have to do it.’ There’s not an individual in here that can do this.”

Johnson saved some of his best work for the moments in which his team needed it the most.

Advertise with us

With 25 seconds left, Pitt had trimmed Northwestern’s lead to one, 70-69, following a Champagnie layup off an assist from freshman Femi Odukale, who had forced a steal as his team applied full-court pressure to try to accelerate their comeback.

After being intentionally fouled, Northwestern sophomore guard Boo Buie missed both free throws on the other end, opening a door that should have been closed, locked and sealed much earlier in the night. With the ball entrusted in his hands, Johnson came off a high ball screen to knife through the Wildcats’ defense and draw the collective attention of it. As he felt his opponents close in on him ever so slightly, Johnson dished it off to an open Champagnie lurking along the baseline, who rose up and slammed it home, sending his teammates and coaches on the sideline into uncontrollable joy.

“Coach knew that the play was working for us, the head-tap play,” Champagnie said. “He just said rebound, get it to X and let him do his thing. He came up big for us at the end of the game. He made a good pass and I finished.”

“I was just taking what I saw,” Johnson said. “I saw [Northwestern forward Pete] Nance come up. He was too far and me and Justin were making eye contact, eye to eye. I dumped it down. I didn’t think he was going to dunk it, but he dunked it. He said he was cramping and I was like ‘No, you weren’t cramping.’”

A tightly contested 3-pointer from Northwestern’s Chase Audige fell well short as the final buzzer blared, delivering the Panthers the win in a game in which such a result, even 15 minutes earlier, would have seemed laughable.

Advertise with us

Pitt went scoreless for the first 4:14 and didn’t make a field goal for the first 5:35. Little came easy and even when it did, it still found a way to make it arduous. The Panthers sank just four of their nine free throws in the first half and, at one point, missed 14 of their 15 layup attempts. Lightly contested shots at the rim continually bounced off the rim, as if there were a lid over the basket. Attempts from 3 not only went awry, but were apparent misses within a second of leaving a Pitt player’s hand. Attempted put-backs caromed off the rim harder than the missed shots they were trying to collect. A free throw was air-balled.

If there was one thing keeping the Panthers in the game, it was their defense. After scoring 203 points in its first two games -- albeit against Arkansas-Pine Bluff and Chicago State, both rated among the worst 10 teams in Division I -- Northwestern shot just 36.8% overall and 28.6% from 3, down from the marks of 51.5% and 47.2%, respectively, it averaged heading into Wednesday.

“We came in at halftime and we told our guys just to relax,” Capel said. “You could tell the guys were putting so much on their plate and were so frustrated and were wearing their frustration on their face because of our offense. They were kind of missing the fact that we defended at such a high level.”

As the game continued, that defense remained stout and became that much more critical as, at last, Pitt’s offense escaped from its maddening misery. After starting eight of 44 from the field (18.2%), the Panthers made 17 of their final 27 shots (63%).

Earlier in the season, Capel had lamented his team’s tendency to panic when faced with adversity or early stumbles, something displayed most egregiously in a 10-point loss to open the season against Saint Francis (Pa.). On Wednesday, in just its fourth game of the season and against a superior opponent, the Panthers remained strong and poised. It was, as Johnson believes, the kind of game they wouldn’t have won last year when the team’s most important players had less college experience or were still in high school.

Advertise with us

It was, as Capel and the players said, a sign of maturity, of mental toughness, of growth. And even those traits only go so far in making sense of a bewildering and, for Pitt, exhilarating night.

“There was just so much going on and for our guys to respond like this is spectacular,” Capel said.

Craig Meyer: cmeyer@post-gazette.com and Twitter @CraigMeyerPG