By 9 o’clock Wednesday night, at least some of the mystery surrounding the 2020-21 Pitt men’s basketball team will have eroded.
The Panthers will have played a full game and, given the opponent, will likely be relishing a victory. A starting lineup will have taken the court. Something resembling a rotation will have started to emerge. And after more than eight laborious months without it, college basketball will be back.
But what should be expected of this team? Who are the players who will help determine the successes and failures Pitt will experience in its third season under coach Jeff Capel? With as many as seven players in their first season of eligibility with the program, what sort of role will these new faces play?
Here’s a look at this season’s installment of the Panthers, position by position.
Guards
There are positional groupings on the Pitt roster that face more questions, but there is none that has a bigger gap between what it can be and what it is right now than the Panthers’ guards.
Read More
Much of that comes down to the eligibility of Nike Sibande. Should the NCAA reverse its original ruling and allow him to play this season after transferring from Miami (Ohio) — and even Capel can only shrug his shoulders when trying to figure out when a decision will come and what it might be — Pitt’s backcourt is suddenly its biggest strength. Without him and, well, it’s a little more dubious.
The guards’ success or failure will rely heavily on Xavier Johnson, who used 25% of his team’s possessions while on the court last season, ranking him among the top 350 Division I players. A squad can often go how its point guard goes, and with Johnson, that’s especially true — particularly now that he’s a junior with a deeper familiarity with Capel and what he wants to do.
Last season, many of Johnson’s negative tendencies were too often apparent. He’d overdribble, and as useful as his acceleration is to blow past defenders, his drives too regularly went nowhere.
Not all of that was his fault, as he was on a team without a scholarship teammate who shot better than 33.1% from 3-point range and without a reliable offensive big man to work through or dish it off to when needed. Because of that, Johnson would have to revert to some of those hero-ball tendencies and had to do so against teams that could sag off the perimeter and pack the paint against what became a woefully predictable offense.
Capel believes this season could be different for Johnson.
“In his first two years, if I’m not mistaken, I think both years he’s been in the top five in assists in our league,” Capel said. “I think maybe last year somewhere like fifth or sixth, but it was a two thing separation from Number 1 to where he was. I think he was at 4.9 last year and that was on the worst shooting team in the history of this program. So all the sudden, if we can shoot the basketball better from the 3-point line, if we can score a little bit better inside, if we can drop it off and go up and finish, he has a chance, we think, to be one of the top guards in our league. And so challenging him with that, he has, knock on wood, played very well for us in these practices and hopefully that’s something that carries over.”
Johnson’s improvement, if there is any, is likely to come down to how he fits with the team’s other guards. On paper, it seems like a better, more sensical match than what he had last season with Trey McGowens.
Ithiel Horton was a relatively high-volume shooter as a freshman at Delaware in 2018-19, attempting about six 3s per game — by comparison, nobody on Pitt last season attempted more than 4.2 — but he was quite efficient with those shots, going 40.9% from deep. For a program that couldn’t even crack 30% as a team last season, it’s a welcome addition, to put it mildly. With lower possession usage numbers than McGowens, Horton doesn’t require the ball quite as much, either, which could lead to more harmony in a backcourt that lacked it at times in 2019-20.
One concern for Horton could be rust, as he sat out last season in accordance with NCAA transfer rules. And heading into Wednesday night, he will have not played a college basketball game for nearly 21 months.
“We understand it’s going to be a challenge right away just because it’s new,” Capel said. “But we need his energy every day and we need his ability to shoot the basketball.”
The backcourt has been further bolstered by the relatively rapid recovery from arm surgery for freshman Femi Odukale, who has been a full practice participant for about a month. He provides not only some depth, but at 6-foot-5, there’s also a level of versatility that could allow him to slide between the two guard positions, meaning he could spell both Johnson and Horton. In his one season at Commonwealth Academy in Massachusetts, he did a little bit of everything, averaging 17.5 points, 8.2 rebounds, 8.8 assists, 1.2 blocks and 2.7 steals, and shooting 52% from the field and 39% from 3.
Should Pitt need more help in the backcourt, walk-on Onyebuchi Ezeakudo remains an option, like he was last season.
Wings
If you scroll through Pitt’s roster and feel as if you’re watching an endless parade of players between 6-foot-5 and 6-foot-8, you’re not imagining things. Athleticism and versatility have been among the biggest priorities for Capel in recruiting, and it’s reflected most notably among the Panthers’ wings.
It’s here that a relatively inexperienced team has some strong foundational pieces.
Justin Champagnie is coming off an excellent freshman season in which he led the team in scoring (12.7 points per game) and rebounds (seven per game). He was an exceptionally instinctive player who was seemingly always in the right spot offensively, which allowed him to capitalize on second-chance and high-percentage looks. He shot 62.9% at the rim last season, easily Pitt’s highest mark for a non-center, and even as a freshman, he was great at limiting mistakes, with a turnover percentage that ranked him among the top 35 Division I players.
There’s still ample room for improvement, which isn’t surprising given his age. Champagnie will have to get considerably better on the defensive end, which is particularly important for a player whose positional interchangeability forces him to defend most areas of the court. His lateral quickness, if nothing else, needs to progress. Like many of his teammates, he’ll also have to improve his outside shooting, as he’ll have to fare better than 26.2% from 3 to justify being the team’s returning leader in 3 attempts.
“We need him to rebound, we need his energy and we need his toughness,” Capel said. “We need all of those things, because when he plays at a high level that gives us a tremendous opportunity to be a good basketball team. If you looked last year when he played at a high level, we were pretty good. The thing we’re trying to get from him and the jump in becoming a good player is when you can be consistently good, and that’s what we’re trying to get him to become. If he can make that jump, then I think we have a chance to do that.”
Few, if any, Pitt players stood out in the final month of last season the way Au’Diese Toney did, beginning with a 27-point performance in a Jan. 28 loss at Duke. Already the team’s best perimeter defender, the now-junior showed a more refined offensive game as last season progressed, improving his field goal percentage from 36% to 46.1% and his 3-point percentage from 24.6% to 32.8%. That progress didn’t abandon some of the more admirable aspects of his game, namely a ferocity on both ends of the floor. With an influx of size into the program, it also seems unlikely he’ll have to play out of position on the low post like he did much of his first two college seasons.
If there’s a concern, it’s that his more pronounced offensive role came as his team’s season unraveled. Beginning with the Duke loss, the Panthers went 3-10 in their final 13 contests, a sharp break from their prior 13-7 record. While he has made strides, it’s highly unlikely that Toney will be an offensive centerpiece the way Johnson or Champagnie is, meaning he’ll have to set aside frustrations like, say, getting looked off by the point guard.
Elsewhere, Gerald Drumgoole is coming off an underwhelming freshman season in which the former four-star recruit averaged just 1.2 points in 8.9 minutes per game while shooting 18.4% overall and 12.5% from 3. This season will be an important litmus test. Were those numbers an unfortunate byproduct of an ankle injury that forced him to miss 12 games and further compounded his acclimation to college basketball? Or is it a sign he might not live up to his recruiting billing?
Those three will be joined by a pair of promising freshmen in William Jeffress and Noah Collier. Jeffress comes to Pitt with plenty of hype as a top-100 recruit and after a decorated high-school career in Erie, in which he became McDowell’s all-time leader in points (1,673) and rebounds (578) in just three seasons. At only 17 years old, though, the physical adjustment to college will be worth monitoring. Collier, at a rangy 6-foot-8, averaged 16 points, six rebounds and two steals per game while leading Westtown School to its fourth consecutive Friends School League title last season. While he’s the lowest-rated of Pitt’s freshmen by 247 Sports, the previous two players who held that title since Capel was hired — Johnson and Champagnie — had the best season among the team’s freshmen.
Big men
For years — really since the graduation of Michael Young following the 2016-17 season — Pitt has been defined in some part by a lack of productive size. Over the past three seasons, the Panthers haven’t had a player taller than 6-foot-6 who appeared in at least 11 games average more than 5.7 points per game. During that same span, they’ve finished among the bottom 30 Division I teams in defensive rebounding percentage each season, including a ghastly 349th-place (of 353 teams) finish last season.
Might this be the year that starts to change? Terrell Brown is the most experienced player of that group, as the only eligible senior on the roster. His 6-foot-10 size has made him a strong offensive rebounder and a capable enough rim-protector much of this career, but he has epitomized some of his teams’ shortcomings on the low post during his career, never averaging more than 5.7 points or 4.5 rebounds per game in a season.
Abdoul Karim-Coulibaly didn’t have flashy stats as a freshman last season — 2.7 points and 1.7 rebounds in 9.4 minutes per game — but he displayed a level of comfort and fluidity for a player struggling with not only an adjustment to the next level, but also a language barrier Capel said impacted him at times on the court. A notable step from him as a player this season wouldn’t come as a surprise, nor would lineups that feature him as one of two big men on the court.
The most promising option to fill that frontcourt void is freshman John Hugley. As a senior at Brush High School in Cleveland, Hugley averaged 24 points and 13.3 rebounds per game. At 6-foot-9 and 240 pounds, he’s a physical force with a somewhat surprisingly well-rounded game. The transition to college basketball, however, is often toughest on big men, the kind of players whose physical gifts allowed them to flourish for years against smaller players. For Hugley, at least early in the season, that may very well be the case.
Hugley’s not the only freshman who will be vying for time at center. Max Amadasun, a 6-foot-10 native of Dublin, Ireland, should provide some depth at the position, if nothing else. While helping lead Our Savior Lutheran School in the Bronx to a 36-4 record last season, he averaged 13 points and 11 rebounds per game.
Craig Meyer: cmeyer@post-gazette.com and Twitter @CraigMeyerPG





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.