Every so often as she speaks about one of the bigger developments in college sports over the past several years, Heather Lyke will take a pause.
It’s complex, the Pitt athletic director says. It’s challenging, she’ll add.
What is unfolding in college sports at the moment — with the NCAA board of governors having supported rule changes that would allow athletes to receive compensation from endorsements, personal appearances and other endeavors — is both of those things from the vantage point of an experienced administrator. Change can often be worthwhile, but it’s seldom seamless.
So, for Lyke, while there’s openness to enhancing a player’s rights to their name, image and likeness, there are also questions about what will come next.
“I think there’s trepidation a little bit,” Lyke said in an interview last week with the Post-Gazette. “It’s extremely liberal, some of the concepts. I think we absolutely need to modernize and consider other options for our student-athletes in the future. I think that there’s quite a bit of concern over the extent to which some of these concepts went.”
Perhaps the biggest areas of concern to Lyke, those “liberal” concepts she referenced, are related to an athlete’s ability in this system to sell merchandise and sign autographs.
Read More
“That somehow doesn’t feel quite right,” she said.
Her uncertainty isn’t limited to those elements of the recommendation.
Lyke, who has a background in compliance and worked at the NCAA in enforcement from 1995-96, believes schools need to figure out the role of boosters. Among the “guardrails” the NCAA would require with new name, image and likeness rules would be that schools and boosters can’t use name, image and likeness in recruiting.
She knows that an NCAA working group that studied the name, image and likeness issue prioritized recruiting and the effect rule alterations could potentially have on it when crafting its recommendations. She doesn’t want people to lose sight of the value of what schools already provide — scholarships, academic help, medical support — while additional benefits are discussed.
Many of her concerns or questions are aligned with principles and guidelines the NCAA espoused when it made the announcement on April 29. That list included things like “reaffirming that student-athletes are students first and not employees of the university” and “ensuring rules are transparent, focused and enforceable, and facilitating fair and balanced competition.”
“There will be a lot of work between now and, frankly, January to develop guardrails and try to understand the unintended consequences of these things and try to really preserve the focus for our student-athletes on getting their education and not going to the school that can make them a quick dollar,” Lyke said. “It’s really important to understand the original intent of how and why we did it and try not to lose focus on the student-athlete experience and the value of the education. That’s the important focus.”
Though she doesn’t profess to be an expert on Title IX — which legislates equality in college athletics, requiring that men and women be provided with equitable opportunities to participate in sports and that they receive scholarship dollars proportional to that participation — Lyke noted that the law may not be applicable to the NCAA’s proposed name, image and likeness framework, which would theoretically stand to benefit football and men’s basketball players the most.
Universities and athletic departments, as she sees it, won’t be involved in arranging deals or opportunities for athletes; rather, they will be created by a market that exists independent of those entities.
“This will be driven more by student-athletes who may have an idea or something they want to do,” Lyke said. “It will be more independently managed by student-athletes. The funding isn’t coming from athletics. They’re not using our marks. They’re not using our institutional logos. We’re not really the hands-on person involved in that.”
Victory Heights update
The ongoing COVID-19 pandemic has affected college athletic departments in any number of ways financially, altering or outright scrapping plans that were in place as recently as two months ago.
While Pitt hasn’t been forced to take measures as drastic as some of its counterparts nationally — some of which have cut staff pay or, more drastically, sports — it has had to change course slightly on its biggest, most ambitious undertaking: Victory Heights, an athletic facilities project that includes a 3,500-seat arena for multiple sports, an indoor track and an athletic performance center. That endeavor comes with a $250 million price tag that will be funded as much as it can be through private funds.
Pitt had, according to Lyke, been aggressive in those fundraising efforts, securing 15 “major gifts” in a 16-week span before the pandemic. Since then, however, Lyke said the athletic department has been in “a little bit of a holding pattern.” Priorities have shifted from regularly seeking formal contributions to checking in on donors and building relationships with them.
“It really respectfully does not make a lot of sense to be aggressively fundraising right now,” Lyke said. “People know it’s on our radar. There have been a couple of gifts that have come in, which is great. But we just haven’t been active.”
Craig Meyer: cmeyer@post-gazette.com and Twitter @CraigMeyerPG





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.