In the days leading up to one of the biggest moments of his life to that point — his Duke team’s appearance in the 1994 Final Four — Jeff Capel remembered getting a letter, one that his teammates and players on the other three teams received.
It was from Dick DeVenzio, a former Ambridge star who played at Duke in the late 1960s and early 1970s. What he penned was, at that time, something of a revolutionary idea: boycott the Final Four.
College athletics, as he saw it, was a fundamentally unfair enterprise, one he had spent years critiquing publicly, including in a book he authored, “Rip-Off U.” He wasn’t asking the athletes not to play, but rather strip the event of the pageantry that helps make it so profitable. He suggested playing the games in a gym with no television cameras and nobody in the crowd outside of family members.
Capel and his teammates didn’t give the plan much thought, ultimately losing that year in the national championship game to Arkansas, but the memory has stayed with him. With each passing year, it has proven to be more relevant.
“I’m not saying we didn’t understand things back then, but this stuff is more in the light now,” the Pitt men’s basketball coach said Wednesday in an interview with the Post-Gazette.
What seemed radical even 25 years ago — not a boycott, but the idea that high-level college athletes weren’t getting their fair share financially — is much more palatable and accepted now, perhaps even mainstream. That shift in public sentiment has led to unexpected destinations, maybe the most notable of which came last Wednesday when the NCAA announced that its board of governors supported a rule change that would allow college athletes to receive compensation for third-party endorsements, personal appearances, social media and businesses they may have started.
Read More
While that progress comes with stipulations and, as the NCAA termed it, “guardrails,” it’s a move that has the potential to alter the long-standing model of college athletics that, throughout its existence, prohibited financial benefits from an athlete’s name, image and likeness (NIL). It’s a change that Capel supports, viewing it as overdue.
“In college basketball, we’re so far behind the times,” Capel said. “That’s why we’re in this position. I don’t think we’ve modernized much stuff. I think it’s a step in the right direction.”
Pitt football coach Pat Narduzzi, through an athletic department spokesman, declined an interview request to discuss last week’s development and NIL-related topics.
The way Capel views the matter is rooted in a larger belief that the NCAA has often lacked foresight, instead fixing problems when they had virtually no other choice. He, like many others, remembers former Connecticut basketball star Shabazz Napier taking the podium after the Huskies won the 2014 national championship to tell a national television audience that he and some of his teammates would sometimes go to bed hungry. Within two weeks, the NCAA approved a measure allowing athletes to receive unlimited meals and snacks.
“That’s what I mean about being reactionary instead of adapting and looking at what’s in the best interest,” Capel said.
His perspective is also shaped by his own experience. Though nothing in the proposed rule changes is related to jersey sales, Capel can remember in his final three seasons at Duke seeing his No. 5 jersey available to purchase on campus and at other places in the state. Initially, he was thrilled by such a sight, but over time, he grew to question it. Not only was he not getting money from those jersey sales, but if someone else wanted one like his cousin or his younger brother, he would either have to pay for one or risk an NCAA violation by getting one from someone who handled the team’s equipment. He found it odd.
Additionally, over the past 15 years, he has coached some players — Blake Griffin, Jahlil Okafor, Jayson Tatum, Marvin Bagley, Jabari Parker, among others — who could have profited immensely from their success and visibility had such measures been in place.
Because of the potential for profit that once wasn’t there, at least legally, the way that programs have been built is about to evolve rapidly.
“I don’t care how good of a coach you are or think you are — if you don’t have good players, you’re not going to be a good coach. Period, at any level,” Capel said. “The lifeblood of a program is recruiting. This will be major in recruiting. This will affect recruiting in a major, major way.”
By his own admission, Capel hasn’t studied the topic extensively. He has his thoughts that are formed by his time in the game, but few people, if any, know what the rules will look like once they’re finalized.
Still, based on what he has read and seen, he envisions potential problems and loopholes waiting to be exploited. The proposal, to use one example, forbids schools and boosters from using name, image and likeness for recruiting purposes. What’s to stop those forces, however, from trying to lure a prized prospect by simply talking about how much people care about the program and support it (financially and otherwise), leaving the forbidden message technically unsaid but perfectly clear?
“As this thing is happening right now, as this working group is trying to figure out what exactly it is they want to do and what they want to get passed, there are already people thinking about how they’re going to use it to their advantage,” Capel said. “That’s what happens. This happens with everything. A couple of years ago, it was coaches trying to change the prices for when you go out and recruit in the summer with people gouging us with what they’re charging for these packets. Those people are brilliant. They’re smart. They’re already starting, ‘OK, this is what we’re going to do now. This is what you’re trying to do and we’re going to have something else for you.’ That’s the nature. You have to understand that.”
Capel believes one solution, for this matter and others, is making coaches more central to decision-making and governance in their sport. Capel said Mike Krzyzewski, his former coach and boss at Duke, has long advocated for someone to preside over college basketball, almost like a commissioner. Short of that, he would like to see fixtures of the sport like Krzyzewski, Jim Boeheim, Tom Izzo, John Calipari and Jay Wright have a seat at the proverbial table.
It would, if nothing else, provide a level of expertise in governing a sport of which they understand the nuances better than anyone else.
“There are a lot of things we find out about as coaches where you’re just like, ‘My gosh, where did that come from? Who made that decision?’” Capel said. “There are times when we as a coaching group may agree, like, ‘Man, we don’t think that’s a good rule.’ But then all of a sudden, you get something back where the legislation has changed and it has been supported unanimously by the college presidents or the faculty reps and it’s like, ‘Wait a minute, how did this happen?’”
Since the NCAA’s announcement last week, Capel, like many other coaches, has thought of what kind of an impact it might have on him and his program. How will he and others adapt the way they go about their jobs? What might be available now to his players that wasn’t previously? How can you maximize the positive effect such a rule might have?
Though the full impact of last week’s recommended changes is virtually impossible to predict and may not be evident for years, some other questions remain.
“I’m interested to see where this goes because it could be really good, but there are some pitfalls that could be there, too, that could be very dangerous for college athletics,” Capel said. “Hopefully this group is communicating with some coaches where they can get a feel for what those pitfalls could possibly be.”
Craig Meyer: cmeyer@post-gazette.com and Twitter @CraigMeyerPG





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.