Pitt's red-zone touchdown rate is the worst it's had in at least a decade, and it isn't particularly close.

The Panthers, poisoned again Saturday night by inching too close to pay dirt, have 16 touchdowns in 36 trips to the red zone this season. That includes a pair of hapless tries in their lackluster 26-19 loss to Boston College at Heinz Field.

In the second quarter of what turned out to be a one-score loss, Pitt settled for field goals at Boston College's 5 and 17-yard line on back-to-back possessions. Those blown opportunities moved the team's red-zone touchdown rate to 44.4% — which ranks 125th among 130 Football Bowl Subdivision squads.

The only teams that have found the end zone at a worse clip from 20 yards and in are Rutgers, Utah State, San Diego State, Akron and Old Dominion. Their combined record? 19-41. Frankly, it's remarkable Pitt has seven wins with an offense so incompetent at finishing the job.

Advertise with us

The thing is, though, this year's red-zone ineptitude is an aberration for the Panthers. Say what you will about the offenses Pitt has produced in the last decade, but none of them have stunk it up this bad this close.

Here's a breakdown of Pitt's red-zone touchdown rates (and how they stack up nationally) over the last 10 seasons:

2018: 64.1% (51st)

2017: 68.57% (27th)

2016: 76.27% (fourth)

Advertise with us

2015: 62.5% (53rd)

2014: 74.58% (second)

2013: 64.4% (50th)

2012: 61.40% (59th)

2011: 63.04% (45th)

Advertise with us

2010: 50.98% (104th)

2009: 56.9% (60th)

Pitt had one terrible red-zone season (2010). But aside from that, the Panthers have either been middle-of-the-road or actually pretty effective under seven different offensive coordinators.

So, why is Pitt's red-zone touchdown rate so bad in 2019 under first-year play-caller Mark Whipple? The guy who hired him tried to explain Saturday night.

"You can't put your finger on whatever it is," Pitt head coach Pat Narduzzi said, "whether it's a penalty or execution, blocking or making the catch, making the throw."

Advertise with us

That's a lot — but Narduzzi isn't wrong. The answer to, "Why isn't Pitt scoring from so close to the end zone?" is all of the above.

Down 6-0, Pitt opened the second quarter with a second-and-goal opportunity inside Boston College's 1-yard line. A quarterback sneak should have done the trick — and that's what the Panthers lined up to execute. But a false start penalty on senior wide receiver Aaron Mathews moved Pitt out of sneak range.

Two plays later, after an interestingly stacked backfield resulted in a Kenny Pickett rush for no gain and a third-down pass was batted away, Alex Kessman came on for his first of four field goals. He hit another on the next series, too — when the Panthers reached the red zone again.

On first-and-goal at Boston College's 9-yard line, Pickett was sacked for a 4-yard loss. Then he threw an incomplete pass before an unwise third-down call.

Instead of having A.J. Davis in the backfield blocking for Pickett (who was sacked four times in the first half), the ball-carrier was split wide for what looked like a designed screen in an empty set. Boston College sent pressure, got to Pickett with ease and forced a throw in the flat to Davis, who was dropped for a 4-yard loss.

Advertise with us

Those two missed chances — getting six points instead of 10 or 14 — served as a microcosm for the red-zone clumsiness that has hindered Pitt through 12 regular-season games. And at this point in the year, it's an issue without a clear solution.

When asked what is holding the team back in the red-zone, Pickett responded: "That's a good question."

"We have these long drives, and we get down there. We need to start making big plays and scoring farther back from the red zone," Pickett said. "We're going on 13-play drives, 11-play drives, and it's hard to continue to move down the field in that kind of fashion without big plays. And when we have big plays, we're not getting in the end zone.

"We have to figure out what we've got to do to get guys in the end zone and not always have to go 13 plays for 80 yards. That's how penalties and turnovers happen. We need to be more explosive and get in the end zone."

Numbers to know

Advertise with us

• From 2012 through 2018, no Pitt kicker had more than three field goals in a game. This year, Kessman has four conversions in two separate contests. Pitt lost both games (vs. Miami, Boston College). That's not a coincidence.

• Pitt fumbled five times and lost three. It was the first time the Panthers lost three fumbles in a game since they lost six against Georgia Tech on Oct. 25, 2014.

• When Kessman converted his first field goal, it was just the third time Pitt scored in its previous 21 possessions.

• Pitt had three players eclipse 75 receiving yards vs. Boston College: Jared Wayne (100), Shocky Jacques-Louis (80) and Maurice Ffrench (79). The last time the Panthers had three pass-catchers with 75-plus receiving yards in a game was a loss to Connecticut on Nov. 9, 2012: Drew Carswell (83 receiving yards), Mike Shanahan (79) and Devin Street (76).

• Pitt allowed only 12 points off four turnovers.

Advertise with us

"Very well could have been 28," Narduzzi said, giving some recognition to his defense. "But you're not going to win any football games turning the football over four times."

A budding blueprint?

Saturday wasn't a terrible performance by Pitt's defense. Talking about red-zone touchdown rate earlier, the Panthers held Boston College to field goals of 22, 29, 30 and 32 yards.

But Jaylen Twyman emphasized the need for the defense to "get back to the drawing board" to account for Virginia Tech and Boston College's fruitful formula the last two weeks: Run more, pass less.

"They did a good job of not letting us get in position to get sacks," Twyman said after the Panthers managed one sack on Saturday, a season low. "They were either moving the chains with three yards and a cloud of dust, or if we got them in a sack around that area, they were ... trying to hurry up and get the ball out."

Advertise with us

Virginia Tech's Hendon Hooker — who was sacked thrice by Pitt — tallied 14 passing attempts last Saturday at Lane Stadium, while Boston College's former walk-on quarterback, Dennis Grosel, threw only 19 times at Heinz Field. In Pitt's other 10 games, it faced five teams that threw more than Hooker and Grosel's combined 33 attempts. That allowed Twyman and company to tee off.

But Boston College and Virginia Tech didn't need to rely on their quarterbacks' arms (and, subsequently, their pass blocking). They ran it, with the Eagles riding AJ Dillon to 178 yards and the Hokies leaning on Deshawn McClease to move the chains. When Boston College did throw it, it was effective. Six of Grosel’s nine completions went for a first down — and a seventh was a play-action touchdown pass to tight end Hunter Long.

"These last two offenses we've seen attacked us certain ways we haven't really practiced," Twyman said. "But we're going to try to get it right for this bowl game."

Did you notice?

• Pickett talked to Wayne as they walked off the field following the quarterback's third-quarter interception. According to Pickett, his true freshman receiver ran the wrong route.

Advertise with us

"It is a read. You know, Jared's got to cross that safety's face," Pickett said of Wayne, who instead ran behind the safety, resulting in what looked like a bizarre, horrible throw. "But he's been doing a great job, and I'm so proud of him. He shows up every day to work. ... He’s going to be a great player for us."

• Pitt's return game was abysmal. Jacques-Louis logged one kickoff for four yards, and John Vardzel had three yards on three punt returns. At one point, junior cornerback Jason Pinnock was back to return a punt for the first time this season. He let it hit the grass and roll a bit before being downed.

• Tight end Will Gragg recovered the fumble when Pickett was strip sacked in the second quarter — making amends for his own mistake. Gragg was torched off the line by Boston College defensive end Marcus Valdez, allowing a free hit at Pickett from his blindside. Gragg has glaringly struggled in pass protection several times this season, none more than that instance.

• Narduzzi put the blame for Dillon's 61-yard touchdown on the coaching staff. "It was more the call than our kids," Narduzzi said. "I'm sure someone could've made the tackle, but I didn't like the defensive call there."

Pitt middle linebacker Saleem Brightwell — who's in charge of lining up the defensive line and barking calls — said their gaps didn't fit well because the front-four had a stunt on.

Advertise with us

"They just hit us," Brightwell said. "It was a perfect play at the wrong time."

Injury update

Ffrench (broken jaw) played on senior day and had no issues. But he was without his tandem partner.

Taysir Mack (61 catches, 711 yards this season) did not play due to injury. However, Narduzzi said he'll be "ready to go for the bowl game."