Narduzzi previews Miami
Sixty-five college football coaches vote weekly in the Amway Coaches Poll, and Pat Narduzzi isn't one of them. Which is probably for the best, because Narduzzi also isn't a fan of said rankings.
Pitt was close to cracking the Associated Press and Coaches polls on Sunday, featuring in both "others receiving votes" categories. But when asked Monday if he thought the 5-2 Panthers deserved to be nationally recognized in a top 25 poll, Narduzzi shrugged.
"I don't really care," Narduzzi said at his weekly press conference. "Our goal is to be there at the end of the season. That's when you want to be ranked. In the middle of the season, it doesn't matter. Preseason rankings don't matter. It's postseason rankings, that's what matters."
In four-plus seasons at the helm, Narduzzi's Panthers have been ranked in the AP poll just five times — twice in 2015, twice in 2016 and once last year. None of those occasions were in the season-ending rankings. In fact, Pitt hasn't found itself in a postseason poll since 2009, when it finished 15th under Dave Wannstedt.
Ten years later, Narduzzi's Panthers have a chance to not only finish in the top 25, but make it in October and maybe stay there. The Panthers are already in the conversation, but Saturday's game against Miami provides the perfect opportunity for Pitt to prove it really belongs.
Pitt's road so far
Read More
The Panthers came out of a rigorous opening four-week stretch with a 2-2 record, better than some thought they would.
They fell to Virginia in disappointing fashion, outgained Penn State in Beaver Stadium and took down Group of Five juggernaut Central Florida. Considering the Week 1 flop and unconvincing win over Ohio in Week 2, the back-to-back performances against Penn State and UCF were encouraging.
Those four weeks helped turn Pitt into, as safety Damar Hamlin called it Friday night, a "battle-tested" squad. Those early experiences helped Pitt rattle off a four-game winning streak, subsequently gaining respect from the computers.
Pitt's strength of record ranks 23rd in the country. What does that mean? Well, strength of record, a statistic created by ESPN, measures how strong a team's record is given its schedule. In this case, it's based on the chance of an average top 25 team having the same 5-2 record (or better) against the seven teams Pitt has played to date.
Interestingly, Pitt is the only team in the country with a top 25 Strength of Record that isn't in the actual AP poll. Iowa State (23rd in AP, 28th in SOR) is the lone outlier.
So, why aren't Panthers ranked?
For one, four of the five 5-2 teams ranked in the AP poll were in the preseason rankings. Which are useless, of course, but are often clung to by voters.
More importantly, strength of record — while a valuable tool — doesn't take into account how games are won, just simply that they are won or lost.
So, when the Panthers go up 21-0 against Central Florida, surrender the lead and need a "Pitt Special" to win it, SOR doesn't care. When the Panthers require a fourth-quarter touchdown to edge Delaware, SOR isn't taking the ugliness of that victory into account. And when Pitt blows a 26-3 advantage at Duke and darn near gives up a 24-6 halftime lead at Syracuse, it doesn't affect its sterling SOR.
But human voters see that. Eight of 62 AP voters put Pitt in their top 25 this week. Conspiracy theorists might think that everyone's angling against Pitt. What's more likely is, it's the writers not liking what they're seeing — a team that starts strong and can't properly put opponents away.
Unlike SOR, the AP and Coaches poll voters aren't rewarding Pitt for simply winning. Not yet, at least.
Miami and beyond
The Hurricanes are 3-4, but (as it stands) they're the best team on Pitt's schedule not named Penn State or UCF.
Miami is No. 31 nationally in Bill Connelly's S&P-plus rankings, which measures a team's efficiency on offense, defense and special teams. Unlike SOR, S&P-plus focuses more on how a team performs, not necessarily the result of its games.
So the Hurricanes, fresh off a baffling defeat to Georgia Tech, are still ranked higher in S&P-plus than 23 teams with two losses or fewer — including Pitt, which ranks 52nd (directly behind 2-5 Tennessee).
That might be frustrating for Pitt fans, but, really, Miami's position should be welcomed. If the Panthers— who opened as 3.5-point favorites — defeat the Hurricanes, their fifth consecutive win will look that much better.
Plus, as far as the AP and Coaches polls are concerned, Miami is a brand name with, as Narduzzi said, "four- and five-star football players."
"We know they're as talented as any team in the country," the coach added.
A win over Miami might get the Panthers into the polls, and a likely win over Georgia Tech (70% win probability, per ESPN's FPI) next week would then put Pitt at 7-2 entering its second bye week.
The path to a firm position in the polls is there for Pitt. The Panthers just need to do what Narduzzi preached on Monday.
"We're going to keep doing our job," the coach said. "We were ranked at 1-0 last week. And this week we'd like to be 1-0, as well. That's the ranking I'm worried about, what that win column looks like."
John McGonigal: jmcgonigal@post-gazette.com and Twitter @jmcgonigal9






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.