Pat Narduzzi after Pitt's 27-20 win at Syracuse.

SYRACUSE, N.Y. — Kenny Pickett couldn't bite his tongue.

When Pat Narduzzi finished his usual halftime address, Pickett popped to the forefront of Pitt's visiting locker room. His teammates, sitting at their orange lockers, cleats planted on the blue Carrier Dome carpet, perked up as No. 8 raised his voice.

Pitt led Syracuse by 18 at the break on Friday night. But Pickett saw too many smiles. He saw a team — or at the very least, a handful of players — sitting pretty, feeling too good about itself. Pickett took it upon himself to try and bring the Panthers back to reality. To erase whatever rosy picture they were already painting for themselves. To remind the Panthers that they've been in this position before.

"The game was far from over. We learned that last week," Pickett said in a makeshift media room, steps from the locker room where he made his speech. "That's why at halftime I got out there and said what I wanted to say."

Advertise with us

Pickett's message — one emphasizing focus and urgency — was appreciated. Senior safety Damar Hamlin said it "turned us all up for sure," and Narduzzi added that it showed leadership. "He did something we needed to make sure we had our heads straight," wide receiver Maurice Ffrench added.

But Pitt didn't heed Pickett's warning. Whether their heads were still in the clouds or not, the Panthers' second-half problems persisted in upstate New York.

Pitt won on Friday night, edging Syracuse 27-20. The Panthers are 5-2 overall, 2-1 in ACC play and 5-1 in games decided by 10 points or less. But that last stat isn't necessarily something to be proud of.

Pitt beat Ohio by 10 in a game it dominated, needed a fourth-quarter touchdown to slide past Delaware and blew considerable leads against UCF and Duke before rallying. The Panthers led the Knights 21-0 and the Blue Devils 26-3 in their Week 4 and Week 6 matchups, respectively, and ceded both advantages. And Pitt darn near did it again at the Carrier Dome.

"It's definitely starting to wear," Pickett said, relieved by the win over Syracuse but disappointed in how it happened. "There's a difference between learning how to win in a tight game and learning how to win and putting people away and just finishing the game the right way. I think we're still trying to figure out how to do that."

Advertise with us

"We don't win the easy way," Narduzzi added.

No, the Panthers don't. Hamlin called Pitt "battle-tested," but a more apt adjective might be wildly volatile.

Pitt kicked Syracuse's tail in the first half. It wasn't close. The Panthers had 305 yards to Syracuse's 133. Pitt converted 6 of 10 third-down attempts, while the Orange managed two conversions on nine tries. Pitt overwhelmed Syracuse's shoddy offensive line with six sacks, and, most importantly, the Panthers found the end zone three times.

Pickett (18 of 33, 232 yards) connected with Aaron Mathews on a 43-yard trickeration touchdown. A.J. Davis (16 carries, 103 yards) scored in his first game back from injury since the UCF win. And Pickett later linked up with Ffrench (six catches, 92 yards) with 23 seconds left in the second quarter.

The Panthers were up 24-6, and Syracuse coach Dino Babers had clearly seen enough. He ordered quarterback Tommy DeVito to kneel out the second quarter with all three timeouts at his disposal, sick of witnessing his quarterback's face hit the off-color turf. The Orange needed halftime.

Advertise with us

Pitt's Kenny Pickett on his halftime speech at Syracuse.

Pitt thought it made use of its break, regrouping behind the leadership of Pickett. But even though the Panthers recognized what the junior said and nodded their heads in agreement, Pitt's play didn't align with Pickett's message.

The offense stagnated. The defense allowed a fluky, but bad 94-yard touchdown in the third quarter. As a team, Pitt was penalized five times for 55 yards in the second half alone.

A game that could have been Pitt's first three-score win since Wake Forest in Nov. 2018 turned into another nail-biter. Syracuse engineered a 15-play, 75-yard touchdown drive (with its backup quarterback) to cut Pitt's lead to 27-20 with less than three minutes to go in regulation.

Now, the Panthers — who have lacked a running game all season — salted away the game with Davis and an offensive line itching to prove itself. Davis picked up two first downs, and Pickett kneeled the clock to double zeroes.

But the postgame vibes weren't overly joyous or celebratory. Pickett wasn't giddy in his postgame press conference, neither was Narduzzi or Ffrench.

Advertise with us

There were positives to build on, sure. Pitt finished with nine sacks, the most it's had in a game since a 33-7 win at Temple in 2001. The running game came to life. And, yes, it's a win. "There are no easy games in the ACC, and we know that," Narduzzi said.

But Friday night could have been an easy one. Frankly, it should have been.

Instead, Pitt flailed about. It did what Pickett passionately spoke out against at halftime. The Panthers lacked consistency and found themselves fighting a battle they could have avoided.

Maybe when Pitt hosts Miami at noon on Saturday, Oct. 26, that will change. Maybe not.

John McGonigal: jmcgonigal@post-gazette.com and Twitter @jmcgonigal9.