Jeff Capel compared it to a baseball batter facing a knuckleballer after playing all game against a pitcher throwing nothing but fastballs.

In the figurative 10-round fight Capel regularly discusses with his Pitt players, it is sparring with a southpaw in the eighth round after going the previous seven against a right-hander.

Whatever the sports metaphor of choice is, the message behind it is clear —  the Syracuse 2-3 zone Pitt is preparing to face Saturday is a befuddling and formidable challenge.

The Orange’s vaunted defensive scheme, honed over decades of careful cultivation by coach Jim Boeheim, is a look unlike any Pitt will face this season (except, of course, when the two teams meet again on Feb. 2). Because of that, the matchup in the Carrier Dome could be a telling test for a resurgent Pitt team.

Advertise with us

“No one can really replicate what they do,” sophomore guard Khameron Davis said. “It’s a totally different experience. Practice is definitely different, too. They’re a very unique team. I don’t think we’ve played a team who plays a zone like they do and probably won’t.”

Boeheim’s zone has come to define both his teams and his program, as well as its rise in the college basketball hierarchy.

The traditional 2-3 zone, as the name implies, has two (usually smaller) players at the top of the alignment, around the high post and the top of the key, with three others behind them in something resembling a line so that when set, the five players form a trapezoidal shape. A defender covers an area of the court, rather than a specific player.

Though many teams opt for man-to-man defense, zone defenses are relatively common at the college level, proving to be effective against still-developing, far-less-polished players than one would find in the professional ranks.

While Pitt has been playing Syracuse’s zone at least once annually for the better part of 40 years, the Orange’s defensive look and the wrinkles of it are no less taxing, particularly for players who have either never faced it or have limited experience doing so.

Advertise with us

“It’s so different,” Capel said Thursday in an interview on 93.7 The Fan. “It’s unlike any zone you’ve ever seen. It’s not a 2-3; it’s more like a 2-2-1, so to speak. It’s constantly changing, so it’s hard to get a rhythm. It makes you think. It makes you stand up. It makes you hesitant.”

That hesitancy comes in part because of the sheer length and athleticism that makes the zone so effective for Boeheim, who regularly fills his roster with wiry, long-armed players. This season isn’t an exception. In Syracuse’s most-used starting lineup, its shortest player is 6-foot-5 Frank Howard, with 6-6 Tyus Battle joining him at the top of the zone. The back line is filled out by players who are 6-6, 6-8 and 7-2.

For a Pitt team with only one player taller than 6-6 on the court at any time, that size has been impossible to simulate in practice, meaning Capel has had to get creative, giving some players objects like sticks with a pad affixed on the end to hold and increase their reach.

As Capel and Davis explained it, that length can sometimes provide a false sense of security, with openings in the zone closing in a flash, potentially allowing the Orange to force a turnover and get out in transition. With defenders guarding an area of the court rather than a designated opponent, a team can sometimes be deceived into taking 3-pointers, believing it’s a good shot when in actuality it isn’t. For big men, according to center Terrell Brown, one can’t be trapped along the baseline, something he dubbed a “red zone” to be avoided at all costs.

With the Panthers’ most effective offensive strategy — dribble penetration from fast guards such as Xavier Johnson and Trey McGowens — somewhat neutralized by the zone, Pitt players believe the best way at countering the zone is by attacking it from the inside rather than being lulled into shooting 3s. Such a strategy would involve bringing a player to the high post, a soft spot between where defenders are positioned, who can receive the ball in the middle of the zone and try to pick it apart from there, either by taking mid-range jumpers or dishing it out to teammates. Who that player will be, most likely Brown or freshman guard/forward Au’Diese Toney, is uncertain, but there’s confidence in what the Panthers’ freshman backcourt can do.

Advertise with us

As many of Pitt’s games have gone this season, the end result of Saturday’s matchup may well come down to the play of Johnson and McGowens, the team’s top two scorers. Against a defense that can fluster opponents with what Brown termed “false pressure,” poise from young players will be as important as it has at any point this season.

Trying to hit a knuckleball can be jarring, but there’s a way to do it.

“Teams are really good and players are really good when they’re instinctive, especially when you’re young,” Capel said. “When you’re young and you have to think more, that slows you down a little bit. Hopefully by Saturday, we have a little bit better of a feel.”

Craig Meyer: cmeyer@post-gazette.com and Twitter @CraigMeyerPG