EL PASO, Texas — In an alternate universe, and for many the preferred universe, Pitt’s ACC championship berth earlier this month also would’ve put the Panthers just one step away from reaching the College Football Playoff to contend for a national title.
As No. 1-ranked Alabama and No. 2 Clemson head back to the national championship to play each other for the third time in four years, the discussion continues about whether college football’s postseason remains broken. For the most part, the same programs make the four-team field each year, while a few others inevitably gripe about being left out. Public opinion keeps gravitating toward an expanded playoff system, one that would feature six, eight or perhaps even 16 teams, bringing the highest level of the sport closer to the Football Championship Subdivision’s 32-team playoff, or even college basketball’s March Madness.
A few Pitt players gave their thoughts Saturday after practice on their sport’s method for deciding a champion, as they prepare to meet Stanford in the Sun Bowl.
“I think the expansion would be good. It’ll be good to give more teams opportunities, because I definitely feel like more than just four can win the national championship,” junior safety Damar Hamlin said. “I feel like four keeps it exclusive.”
Hamlin’s thesis statement might not hold up all that well after seeing Clemson and Alabama throttle Notre Dame and Oklahoma later Saturday. But to his point, Georgia fans can argue their team would’ve been better equipped to win either of those matchups. Ohio State could say the same. And then there’s Central Florida, unbeaten for the second consecutive season, and still kept out of the big dance.
Senior safety Dennis Briggs is about to wrap up his football career, but if it were up to him, he’s with Hamlin.
Read More
“I don’t see why not,” Briggs said of adding to the playoff. “It’d be interesting, because even in the NFL, there are favorites going in, and something crazy always happens.”
Perhaps the most common suggested format would be to give a bid to all five power-conference champions, ensuring that those league titles would still be meaningful, and then having the CFP committee select three at-large teams (maybe with one spot guaranteed to a program outside the power five).
In that hypothetical scenario, Pitt could’ve reached the field by upsetting Clemson, and gone into the Playoff with an 8-5 record. But in that case, the Panthers would’ve just proven they can beat an elite opponent on their best day.
“It just makes teams have to be too perfect, and that’s just not how football is,” Hamlin said of the current structure. “Some teams might lose early or lose late, and it affects the playoffs when really they might be the best team out there. So expansion would be good, but I feel like four keeps it exclusive.”
An interesting perspective from Hamlin, who might be too far along in his career to ever experience an expanded postseason. Senior fullback George Aston is one Panthers player who definitely won’t get that chance, but he seemed more focused on the final game of his career than opining on one of the sport’s biggest issues.
“I haven’t even really put much thought into it,” Aston said. “I think usually they do a pretty good job of picking the best teams to be in it, anyway.”
Aston’s philosophy is in line with his coach. Pat Narduzzi “could go either way” on the number of teams that make the field, he acknowledged Sunday morning, almost 24 hours from his bowl game.
“I don’t think it’s changing for a while. … I think the committee can pick four of the best teams in the country,” Narduzzi said. “Did they get it right? Who knows? I really don’t believe there’s another team that could’ve fit into those four. We played two of the four, and I kind of thought Clemson was probably a little ahead of the other one, just because of the athletes they had, and obviously that was the case.”
For the record, Aston, Briggs and Hamlin all also picked Clemson to beat Notre Dame before the matchup Saturday between two teams they lost to this season. Aston said “definitely,” Briggs predicted it would be a close game, and all three picked Alabama to beat their conference mates Jan. 7 in the title game.
So with two of the usual faces heading back for a Round 3, is so much dominance by just a few schools bad for college football?
“It could be,” Narduzzi said. “The bowl games used to be so important, and now you’ve got kids skipping the games. That’s what I don’t like about it. I think we’ve determined the national championship for years without having those, and making the bowl games important. I’m just worried about beating Stanford.”
Brian Batko: bbatko@post-gazette.com and Twitter @BrianBatko.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.