Brian Batko: Happy Halloween, everyone. I hope this chat is more king-size chocolate bar than popcorn ball. Let's go trick or treating...
Robert B. Bottleservice: With V’Lique doubtful what’re the chances Duzz gives us a peak at Paris? His hs tape makes us drool.
Brian Batko: V'Lique Carter isn't officially doubtful, but Pat Narduzzi kind of went out of his way on his radio show last night to sort of cast more doubt on his status for this week. In case you missed it: http://www.post-gazette.com/sports/Pitt/2018/10/31/vlique-carter-injur...
As for Paris Ford maybe getting some of those jet sweeps, lining up out wide, etc., I don't know. All I can really tell you is that I didn't see Ford working with the offense like Carter was Tuesday morning for the half hour we got to watch. He's done that previously this season and in training camp.
Joe: Why isn’t Paris Ford playing?
Brian Batko: Another Paris Ford question. Joe, I'm not sure there's any deeper answer or reason here other than Pat Narduzzi and his defensive staff don't think he's a better option right now than the defensive backs they are using. As far as I know, he's still at cornerback, where Dane Jackson and Phillipie Motley are starting, and Jason Pinnock and Damarri Mathis are clearly ahead of him. Maybe it's still the mental aspect of learning the defense, maybe it's focus - Narduzzi has used that word a ton lately - or maybe he's still just not as technically sound as the other guys who have been playing that spot for a whike.
Read More
Brian Batko: As for why he's not playing at safety, either, Narduzzi's explanation earlier this year was that it's a really involved role from a knowledge standpoint. But if you ask me, that's where Ford should be given a shot.
Pete: Brian, does UVA running a 3-4 mean more “between the tackles” runs for Pitt this week? How did Carrigan look as a blocker against Duke?
Brian Batko: Possibly. But Pitt already runs between the tackles plenty. That's the best strength of this offense, even considering how effective the jet sweeps were a week ago. Grant Carrigan seems to be doing his job from what I see, and I think he and backup offensive tackle Carson Van Lynn are pretty interchangeable right now as those big blocking tight ends. If you're looking for one to get involved in the passing game, I think it'll be Will Gragg or even George Aston playing more of an H-back role on the edge.
Douglas Reigner: Brian, do you think we match up favorably with Virginia. Looking at both teams schedules (Pitt's is insanely difficult) there seems as if there is not much difference with the two teams. Any thoughts?
Brian Batko: I don't think it's that lopsided on paper, no. You could certainly argue that Pitt is better than their record, and might even have the same as Virginia or better if they played that schedule. But let's not underestimate the Hoos. Virginia has some dudes on both sides of the ball, and it seems like individual talent is finally adding up to the sum of the parts this year for Bronco Mendenhall, who I think is a pretty sharp coach.
Goodman: Hi Brian, if Pitt is able to pull out 6 wins is there a chance they can to to the Military or Pinstripe Bowl?
Brian Batko: Pinstripe is probably out given that Pitt was just there a couple years ago. Military Bowl seems like a legitimate possibility. Florida State went 6-6 last year and got stuck with the ACC's spot in the Independence Bowl in Shreveport, Louisiana. Duke was 6-6 and ended up in the Quick Lane Bowl in Detroit, the day after Christmas. Let's all hope against hope that doesn't happen again.
All Academic All the Time: Brian, given the wins against Syracuse and Duke do you think the Pitt program is heading in the right direction again?
Brian Batko: That's a rather narrow premise for a broad question. But I must say, it seemed like things were gonna really go sideways on this season and, by extension, Pat Narduzzi's tenure before those games when this team was sitting at 2-3. Admittedly I picked Pitt to lose both, and the fact that they found a way to squeak those out obviously is encouraging, but it doesn't completely mask some of the same issues (passing game, defensive inconsistency) holding back this program.
Jay: if they go to Shreveport I know a great and I mean great Italian restaurant a little south of Shreveport.
Brian Batko: Let's keep this in mind
George Costanza: Would you purposely sit out V'Lique Carter for a couple weeks to keep his redshirt, or would you play him until you are out of contention?
Ryan Sanders: How is Narduzzi handling the red shirting in your opinion? Personally, if you have a freshman that can help you win NOW, I think he should be playing consistently. Not saving him so he's on the team 5 years instead of 4. Thanks!
Brian Batko: Two similar questions, so I'll fold them into one. I absolutely understand where Narduzzi is coming from on this, because why lose a whole season for a guy if you don't have to - take advantage of the rule and make it work for you, right? - but you don't wanna be too clever by half. If a guy can help you win right now, right now is always the most important. I generally lean toward not worrying about that fifth year down the road, because even if it can result in some pretty fine players - Quintin Wirginis, Alex Bookser, etc. - so much can change between now and then.
Brian Batko: So, to answer: Yes, I'd keep playing V'Lique Carter and burn his redshirt. MAYBE I do it until I hit the four game mark and there's not much of significance to play for, or it's clear he's not ready for a consistent share of touches, etc.
Pitt OL Alex Bookser previews Virginia game
K-Moose: If played this Saturday, would Pitt get smoked by PSU again?
Brian Batko: It would probably be closer now that Pitt has switched holders
Walt Harris: If Pitt wins out, could they make a New Year's Day Bowl?
Brian Batko: I suppose, Walt, if they finish 9-4 with a win over Clemson in the ACC title game, yes, they would backdoor their way into that. Actually, they'd be charging through the front door, because they'll have reeled off six consecutive wins, probably at least half of which would be against ranked teams.
SOMD Panther: What would be the most "Pitt" ending to this season? Convincing win on Friday, then lose out?
Brian Batko: Hmmmm. Yeah, I guess so. Or, lose the next three, then beat Miami again in the final game? Tough to say.
Q: I think we all assume Devin Danielson will one of the "mystery freshman" who will make their debut of Friday? Any prediction on the other?
Brian Batko: I'm not so sure there will be a second. Pat Narduzzi didn't sound as confident about that on his show Wednesday night, and I don't think any obvious names really come to mind.
Sibb's Off: What happened with Ricky Town, he came in with big credentials. I am quite surprised he has been relegated to 3rd string.
Brian Batko: To quote Bill Lumbergh, I'm gonna have to go ahead and disagree with you there. Town came in as a guy who spent time at three other colleges and never became the outright starter at any of them, even a JUCO. It was pretty clear from the outside that bringing in Jeff George when they did was a bad sign for Town's progress.
SDWC: Is Todd Sibley still on the team? As I recall he was a 4-star recruit but I have never heard his name mentioned in any capacity.
Brian Batko: Yes, he's actually been getting some reps on special teams, but hasn't been in the backfield mix, which is rather crowded and top-heavy these days.
Keith : Good afternoon! So how in the last camp scrimmage can Carter look so good that it catches our offensive line coaches eye, but it takes game 8 for our Head Coach to use him in a game?
Brian Batko: Hello, Keith. That's exactly why I think if they're really being honest, Pitt's coaches couldn't have seen this coming. Sure, they thought Carter was ready to get his feet wet in a game, see what he's got, but if they knew he could go off for 137 yards on seven carries, he would've been playing sooner. He'd be doing a lot more things sooner. Believe me, Pat Narduzzi wants to win games.
Donnie from Oakland: I was just at the O and heard that Pitt is building an on campus stadium in 2021
Brian Batko: Oh nice. Make sure there's a roof on it. Retractable roof, actually.
Joe: I think coach was talk talking about Motley being hurt and not playing. He said he’s not sure yet about Carter
Brian Batko: Uhhh, when? Last night on his show he was clearly asked about Carter and clearly replied that he has "a little something something" that's hurting his chances of playing. This is the first I'm hearing of a potential injury to Phillipie Motley.
JW: Do you have a sense of how much Pitt's defensive calls are made by the sideline versus reads by the players? Combo of both? It was frustrating seeing Pitt's middle LBs repeatedly smash into the Duke O-line, then have passes completed across the middle. Was wondering how much of that is based on players' pre-snap reads, or straight coach's playcalling.
Brian Batko: Definitely a combination of both, and that's why you always hear Narduzzi talking about how necessary the cerebral part of playing in this defense is. He called Mike Caprara and Matt Galambos "genius" guys as his linebackers. The Amir Watts interception against Syracuse, when he dropped off the line of scrimmage, that was a check made by Elias Reynolds. So it's all gotta be working in harmony.
Panther Paul: In your vast analysis of game tape, is UVA legit? I mean, their head coach is named "Bronco" so they must be tough, right?
Brian Batko: I don't get paid enough to work long enough hours to do a vast analysis of UVA film. But I do know I've seen a lot of their QB Bryce Perkins scrambling around, throwing the ball on the run, and making defenses look silly. They play football, so yeah, they must be tough.
Arthur: Given the news that Pitt will open against an FBS Team next season, how long do you think it will take the Panthers to score a point in the second half of a game?
Brian Batko: Probably not as long as this year, but you never know.
willie jn socal: why does pitt never throw to the tight end?
Brian Batko: Maybe they haven't tight ends worth throwing to
Crazy Town: We must give KUDOS to Shawn Watson with his offensive game plan last week where they gained over 400 yards running the ball. What do you think about the progress with the offense?
Brian Batko: Hey, when it's doing that, it's working. Alex Bookser was saying yesterday that just because teams load the box to stop Qadree Ollison and Darrin Hall between the tackles doesn't mean Pitt has to throw the ball as a result. He said those jet sweeps that get the defense moving laterally can be just as explosive a way to counter a loaded front. Not too long ago, Watson was public enemy No. 1 for Pitt fans, and that uproar seems to have quieted down a bit.
James: Sorry for the sudden change to Pitt basketball, but if there was a scrimmage against Dayton the other day..... theoretically, how did Ellison look?
Brian Batko: Sorry James, I don't have anything for you in terms of a detailed player report or stats. While some college basketball teams eschew the idea of a "secret" scrimmage, Pitt and Dayton agreed pregame to not publicize theirs, so we're in the dark like the stone ages.
SDWC: Does a bowl game count as one of the 4 games a player can play and still get a redshirt?
Brian Batko: The bowl game is not exempt from the rule. If the bowl game is the fifth game you play in, you're a sophomore next year.
SOMD Panther: With injuries on the D-Line, and 4 games left to play, may John Morgan (DeMatha '18) be in line for some game reps?
Walt Harris: What other young freshman who we haven't seen yet should we keep our eyes open for?
Brian Batko: The injury bug has hit Pitt at D-tackle, rather than DE, so I'm not sure who John Morgan would plug in for. Rashad Weaver is playing well, Dewayne Hendrix and Patrick Jones have had flashes, James Folston is a senior. Pat Narduzzi said today that Thomas Jefferson's Devin Danielson is ready to go at DT, if needed, and you could see him at UVA.
Keith : Also you have to give credit where credit is due, our defense did come up with some pretty big stops at the end of the 1st half and in the 4th quarter!
Brian Batko: Good job by you, Pitt defense.
Jay: pitt has a chance to go to the ACC title game if they win out, I wouldn’t be surprised if they win out or lose them all, what do you think?
Brian Batko: I'd be surprised if they win out, and I'd be surprised if they lose out, but I don't think any of the remaining games are unwinnable and I don't think any of them are cakewalks. If that makes sense. I haven't seen enough yet to make me think that Pitt is capable of stringing together four, really what would be five, consecutive all-around performances.
JT Parkland: How many WR's and DB's does Pitt graduate this year?
Brian Batko: Only two each, and that's counting wideout Kellen McAlone, who was a walk-on until just before the season started. And here's a little nugget for you on that front: Narduzzi also said on his show last night that he "promises" Maurice Ffrench will be seen on defense again someday. Why? I can't answer that. But he said it.
Ryan Sanders: Who would you say is Pitt football's top recruit target right now?
Brian Batko: Reeling in MJ Devonshire from Aliquippa would be nice, both for what he can do on the field and for perception and for keeping a foot in the door at that powerhouse. His teammate Will Gipson is firmly on the radar now, though he's currently committed to Ball State. It's also worth noting how crucial it is to regain all the guys already committed. That's just as much a grind in college football recruiting these days as going out and landing new ones.
Q: Can Maurice play boundary safety!? Because that would be ideal. Seems strange though considering how good he's been on offense.
Brian Batko: Well, he was always a cornerback when he was playing two positions. But yeah, I don't understand why you'd mess with that. Unless it'd be a gadget type deal, and we do know Narduzzi likes to try some odd things at times.
runthewildcat: What is the status on ollison as he seemed to have pulled his hammy last week?
Brian Batko: He totally brushed it off after the game, but that's a trickle-down effect from the head coach's stance on injuries. I'm sure he got some treatment on it early this week to try to get ready on five days rest, but I'd be surprised if he's really 100 percent. Then again, who is this time of year, right? Period.
Walt Frank: FYI...Penn State would smoke Pitt today, tomorrow and next year. I can't believe Pitt wants to continue the series..Are they nuts?.
Brian Batko: Thanks, Walt. I'll ask.
Jay: Ok I will email you the name of the restaurant if they go there
Brian Batko: Sounds great, Jay. Wouldn't want word getting out about a hidden gem. Is it called V'Lique's Italiano, by chance?
SDWC: Is Ffrench good to go for Friday, after hopping off the field after the game winner last week?
Brian Batko: Wow, more injury questions. Yes, Ffrench said after the game it was just a cramp, and he looked fine in practice Tuesday.
SOMD Panther: Do you see Kessman as the guy on the floor who can only hit 3's, but has no mid-range game? Or is it the case of a young kicker with consistency issues.
Brian Batko: Alex Kessman is a big golfer, so maybe he's more like a dude who can drive the ball a country mile but struggles with his short game. Really though, I think he just is what he is at this point: Strong leg, a weapon for an offense from long range, but an inaccurate kicker.
Joe Montana: Will Kenny Pickett win more super bowls than I have?
Brian Batko: The odds say no
Arthur: With everything happening yesterday at Maryland, what are the chances Matt Canada returns to Pitt?
Brian Batko: The odds say no
tata: You picked Duke last week, predictions this week?
Brian Batko: I did pick Duke. Thank you for remembering, Tata. And again this week, I will pick against Pitt. But I'll say Panthers cover the spread, in another defensively challenged game, with Virginia winning 42-39.
Brian Batko: Thank you, good friends. Be careful tonight trolling the streets for candy.



Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.