Pitt cornerback Jason Pinnock on defensive struggles

Finger-pointing over Pitt’s disappointing 2-3 start can touch on seemingly any facet of the program, but a look inward is incomplete without focusing on the team’s maddening ability in racking up penalties.

In those first five games, Pitt has 40 penalties for 379 yards, a 75.8 penalty yards per game average that is the 19th-highest mark among 129 Football Bowl Subdivision teams and first among ACC squads (the latter by about 7 yards per game).

If it keeps at its current pace, it will finish the regular season with 96 penalties for 910 yards. Going back 10 years, to the 2008 season, the Panthers have never finished a season with more than 746 penalty yards and with the exception of 2017, each of those seasons featured an additional game (a bowl). In fact, they’re just six flags shy of matching their penalty total from all of last season, when they finished with 46.

They’re the kind of numbers that have presented harsh truths and prompted a search for answers.

Advertise with us

“I feel like we just need to be more smart overall,” defensive end Dewayne Hendrix said. “That’s on offense, defense and special teams. We really need to get those penalties down. I feel like we are going to do that this week. Coach has been talking about details all this week, so the little things matter. Once we get that taken care of, I think we’re going to be OK.”

“We’ve got smart guys, so that shouldn’t be the case,” coach Pat Narduzzi said Monday of the high number of penalties.

Indeed, all phases of the team have contributed to its ongoing penalty issues. Even those not actively participating on the field have played a part, as Narduzzi was flagged for unsportsmanlike conduct in a Sept. 8 loss to Penn State and Pitt was charged with sideline interference last week in a loss to Central Florida.

One side of the ball, however, has been disproportionately culpable. Of Pitt’s 40 penalties this season, 20 have been called on the defense, compared to 11 for the offense and seven for special teams, the last of which is quite concerning considering the relative lack of time that unit spends on the field. More than half of those defensive infractions have come from pass interference, holding and roughing-the-passer calls.

Perhaps the most alarming aspect of the penalties has been the frequency at which they’ve occurred against the team’s top opponents. Twenty-five of the Panthers’ 40 penalties came during losses against Penn State and Central Florida, the only two ranked teams they’ve faced this season. Part of that comes with pace, as both those teams, particularly the latter, play at a fervent tempo, something that leads to fatigue and makes mental errors more likely. Defensive back Jason Pinnock said Pitt’s practices preparing for Central Florida were harder, faster and more strenuous than the actual game. Still, the cumulative effect of defending that sort of speed is palpable.

Advertise with us

“I’m not going to lie to you, it’s kind of hard,” Hendrix said. “When you get tired, that’s when mistakes usually come, but that’s also when discipline comes in. You’ve got to be disciplined when you’re tired. We’ve been practicing that today and we’re going to keep practicing this week, so it should be better come Saturday.”

Pitt is working to find solutions. Narduzzi, as he has long done, starts every team meeting by reviewing the previous day’s practice, a discussion that begins with a sheet of paper. On that paper is a list of every penalty from the practice, including the period it occurred and which player was whistled for it. In the past, Narduzzi said, it has greatly benefited his team, though this season, the repeated mistakes are “uncharacteristic of a Pitt football team.”

Some of the problems, he believes, come from the number of inexperienced players upon whom Pitt is relying, something the team will have to “live with and try to correct.” Offensive lineman Connor Dintino sees growth that can come from the early miscues, as he said the team has become much more focused on identifying mistakes and holding teammates accountable for fixing them.

For all of Pitt’s struggles, there is some question of how much penalties or a lack of them really matter in determining a team’s overall success. Two top-15 teams, No. 9 West Virginia and No. 13 Kentucky, are directly behind Pitt in most penalty yards per game while two others, No. 3 Ohio State and No. 15 Michigan, are comfortably ahead of it.

For a team without the same talent with which to work, though, those shortcomings in execution have added up well beyond the nearly four football fields worth of yards it has gifted opponents. The impact of those mistakes has been felt by players, and, in its coach’s eyes, lessons have come from that.

Advertise with us

“I’m not going to run them, I’m not going to make them do up-downs,” Narduzzi said in late September. “They understand how it hurts, and it hurts worse in the second half. It hurts worse when you’ve got a 25-yard run, it’s a first-and-10, change the field, and now all of a sudden you’re backed up again, go back further, go deeper into the end zone. So they know, and it hurts, and they’re not trying to do it.”

Craig Meyer: cmeyer@post-gazette.com and Twitter @CraigMeyerPG