For the second year in a row, Pitt has a remarkably daunting football schedule. Case in point, ESPN.com is remarking on it, putting the Panthers atop its list of toughest non-conference slates for the 2018 season.
If that sounds familiar, it’s probably because ESPN did the same ranking last year, and yes, Pitt also took the top spot (the Panthers checked in at a paltry No. 5 in 2016). Three opponents have changed, but not much else in terms of Pitt’s obstacles outside the Atlantic Coast Conference this season, and indeed, Penn State’s presence on the schedule is a consistent factor upping the ante as the Nittany Lions find themselves tabbed as national title contenders once again.
While these are nothing more than arbitrary ratings based mostly on ESPN’s own projections for the 2018 season, concerns about last year’s challenging schedule came to fruition. Pitt finished 5-7, 2-2 outside the ACC, and missed a bowl game. As was expected, back-to-back matchups against top 10 teams Penn State and Oklahoma State proved to be too much to handle in Weeks 2 and 3, and one could argue that a lack of early season momentum didn’t give a rebuilding team much of a chance to get on track.
And now 2018 is probably even more of a gauntlet, with a trio of likely Top 25 opponents in Penn State, Central Florida and Notre Dame. Granted, Pitt couldn’t have known UCF would be quite so formidable when it agreed to this home-and-home series in January 2017, but as such, calling the Panthers’ non-conference schedule the most grueling in college football is “a no-brainer.” You likely knew that already if you follow Pitt football, but now you have national media outlet validation, if you needed it.
So maybe most interesting is renewing the debate of whether this is a bad thing or a good thing for Pat Narduzzi’s program. On one hand, it’s all the more sweeter to beat very good teams, right? And it’s more enjoyable to play host to, or just play, a premier opponent, yes? On the same hand, but with a much less ambitious approach, at least it’s something of a built-in excuse to explain away what could be a disappointing record at the end of the day.
On the other hand, squaring off with Penn State and Oklahoma State a year ago didn’t necessarily make a below-average season any easier to stomach. Also on the other hand, you don’t have to beat the best to be the best. At least not all the time, not outside your Power Five league, and not in college football, where you can beat up on Fresno State, Colorado State and Mercer in three of your four non-conference games and be totally fine. You can even be Alabama, because that’s what Alabama did, playing one high-profile non-SEC game against Florida State and otherwise cruising.
Read More
That's...not a good thing
— Jordan (@jmb22392) June 7, 2018
I used to think this was a good thing, but stacking wins and high profile bowls are way better.
— James Tierney (@jtierney9) June 7, 2018
Some of my favorite Pitt program memories ever are wins against teams like Notre Dame and Penn State, so why should the school schedule fewer games like that?
— Dan (@DanInPittsburgh) June 7, 2018
There’s also the notion that rigorous out-of-conference contests are better to prepare you for conference play, which matters most, but that’s more of a college basketball concept, where early season clashes matter much less in the long run. Plus, three of the next four in ESPN’s list of difficult schedules are Florida State, Clemson and Georgia Tech, so Pitt’s not alone among ACC schools that have it rough this year. A more persuasive idea is that the more appealing (read: competitive) your opponent at Heinz Field, the better your attendance, but the 38,952 who came to see No. 9 Oklahoma State last September weren’t exactly packed in like sardines.
Basically, there’s the faction of Pitt fans who’d just as soon sign up to go 4-0 with four victories against two MAC also-rans, a Sun Belt soup can and an overmatched FCS foe. Not much nuance can fit into a win-loss column, and no one can tell you that you aren’t still, say, 8-4 when it’s bowl time. The other side is that anyone who deeply cares about Pitt football wants to slug it out against the elite, with the inherent belief that Narduzzi and company will find a way to come out on top regardless of who’s opposite them. Just win, baby, or something like that.
Speaking of Narduzzi, don’t expect him to temper expectations just because you or the Post-Gazette or ESPN tell him that Penn State, UCF and Notre Dame is a bear of a threesome. Even if, realistically and logically, the upshot is that the Panthers will be hard-pressed to win any of those, let alone run the table. When it comes to Pitt’s scheduling, is some potentially very sweet juice worth a very strenuous squeeze?
Brian Batko: bbatko@post-gazette.com and Twitter @BrianBatko.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.