After wrapping up the 2018 class in early February, Pitt football landed its first 2019 recruit Sunday evening, the first one to “turn on the lights” since that slogan emerged in March with a “1” and “9” standing in for the “I” and “G.”

Put aside the fact that it was the latest start to a recruiting class since Pat Narduzzi arrived four years ago; actually, it’s the latest start Pitt has gotten since at least 2004, which is as far back as the Rivals.com database goes in keeping track of commitment dates.

But you knew someone, eventually, would have to be the first. Not that college football classes are often “built” around a single prospect, but when Miami linebacker Leslie Smith gave his verbal pledge to Narduzzi over the weekend, he became the temporary face of Pitt’s 2019 recruiting efforts.

So, will Smith blossom into a contributor, starter or even star sometime down the road, recalled fondly for being the first to jump on board at a time when the going was tough (or at least seemed tough from the outside)? Obviously, no one can project that with any certainty. Smith, not yet ranked by any of the three major recruiting services, still has a senior season to play at Northwestern High School.

Advertise with us

But if Smith finishes his college career with the Panthers, let alone becomes a standout, he would buck a disappointing trend for Pitt’s initial recruits in a given class. Really, you could argue he would do that simply by honoring his commitment and signing a letter of intent later this year.

Because since Narduzzi arrived in December 2014, the leadoff recruits in his first three classes never made it to campus. They didn’t even make it to signing day. Three-star Ohio defensive back Tony Butler committed to Pitt in March 2015, three months after Narduzzi got the job, but flirted with other schools thereafter and officially withdrew his pledge in July. The 2017 class started quickly, with three-star Johnstown defensive back Exree Loe committing in August 2015, he also continued to visit other programs and was back on the market 10 months later. And last year, then-unranked Massachusetts tight end Jay Symonds kicked off the 2018 class in March, only to flip his commitment to Stanford in October.

Butler ended up at Nebraska, where he played in two games last year as a redshirt freshman; Loe at West Virginia, where he redshirted last season; and Symonds did indeed sign with Stanford in December. None were particularly highly touted players either before or after their association with Pitt, but each were deemed worthy of an offer and excited tweet from Narduzzi when they picked the Panthers, so losing a verbal pledge is never fun.

None of this is to say that missing on an early recruit, especially one early enough to be first in a class, is unique to Narduzzi. It’s definitely not unique to Pitt, whose stretch of bad luck with No. 1 commitments long predates the current coaching staff. In the seven previous years, only two of Pitt’s original commitments graduated from the program (three including 2010 signee Derrick Burns, whose career was cut short by a stroke before his redshirt sophomore season).

Two of those “firsts” never signed, and both were WPIAL products, as Blackhawk quarterback Chandler Kincade decommitted after the departure of Todd Graham and Sto-Rox defensive back Marzett Geter had his Graham-given scholarship offer pulled by new coach Paul Chryst (who not only wasn’t at Pitt when Geter committed, but also didn’t take kindly to some of his social media behavior). The two who signed but went on to transfer were tight end Sam Collura (2011) and offensive lineman Alex Paulina (2015), who ended up at Delaware and Division III Waynesburg.

Advertise with us

The two, the proud, who in the past decade kicked off a Pitt football recruiting class and never severed ties with the program were offensive lineman Cory King (2009) and tight end Scott Orndoff (2013). Orndoff, perhaps ironically, became Pitt’s first commitment of that class after decommitting from Wisconsin and following Chryst to his next stop.

Seeing the first player in a class fizzle out, whether once he reaches campus or later in the recruiting process, shouldn’t be surprising. On one hand, you might suspect that the first prospect committed should logically be the most committed, given his enthusiasm for joining up. But we know that’s not always how it works in recruiting; the earlier you make a decision, the longer you have before you can make it official. Many factors can complicate that, from opposing schools not taking “no” for an answer, to coaching instability at the program you thought would be your future, as has commonly been the case at Pitt since 2009.

Although history, notably recent history, suggests the odds don’t favor Smith becoming a Panthers player to remember, that wouldn’t be any different if he were the second, sixth or 17th recruit in the class. Still, though there might be something to be said for being first, at Pitt, lately that has not been true.

Brian Batko: bbatko@post-gazette.com and Twitter @BrianBatko.