Even 12 years after the fact, Jeff Capel lets out a small, almost pained chuckle when Scottie Reynolds’ name is mentioned.
“That’s kind of a sore spot for me,” Pitt’s new men’s basketball coach said Wednesday.
In that way, Capel isn’t too different from the fan base that now surrounds him and his team.
The image of Reynolds streaking up the court at Boston’s TD Banknorth Garden on his way to a game-winning runner at the buzzer to send Villanova past Pitt and into the Final Four in 2009 is a recurring nightmare for any Panthers fan.
In a small way, Capel helped to create it.
In 2006, Reynolds, a 6-foot-2 guard out of Herndon, Va., was a four-star recruit and ranked among the top 80 players nationally in his class. For colleges vying for his services, little of that mattered. The previous March, he signed his national letter of intent with Oklahoma and was set to play for the Sooners and coach Kelvin Sampson.
Read More
Plans quickly changed, though. That March, Sampson left to become the head coach at Indiana, depriving Reynolds of the man with whom he had developed a close bond. In his place stepped Capel, a 31-year-old coach coming off a successful four-year run at VCU.
With those moves, Reynolds was presented with a choice, one that ultimately helped dictate the fortunes of more than a handful of programs. He could honor his commitment and move halfway across the country to a place where he would entrust his future to a man he barely knew or he could seek opportunities elsewhere.
“I’m not 100-percent sure I want to be at Oklahoma,” Reynolds told the Washington Examiner in 2006. “I need to be 100-percent sure and in order for that to happen, I need to explore other options.”
On the other end of the equation was Capel, a rising star in the coaching profession going to a state in which he had never set foot until his opening press conference. He was, by his own admission all these years later, naïve about what awaited him at Oklahoma.
Together, he and Reynolds attempted to navigate the situation in which they were thrust. Reynolds maintained an open mind, keeping the Sooners among his top three choices even after being released from his letter of intent. Capel made a big push to persuade him to stay, telling him what he believed Reynolds and the program could accomplish together.
“[Capel] talked to me about how to carry myself through the situation and things like that,” Reynolds told the Oklahoman in 2006. “I learned a lot from him just talking from when he got the job to the end of the recruiting process.”
Those lessons didn’t translate into what Capel and the Sooners desired the most. In late May 2006, Reynolds committed to Villanova, where he was a four-year starter who led the Wildcats to the Final Four in 2009 and earned Associated Press first-team all-American honors as a senior in 2010. Oklahoma and Capel did fine without him, making the Elite Eight in 2009 with future NBA All-Star Blake Griffin. But the thought of what those teams could have achieved with Reynolds running the point still lingers, as it does for those around Pitt who think of how their fate may have been altered had Reynolds never made his way to suburban Philadelphia.
To some extent, as it does for many coaches who lose a recruiting battle, it has stayed with Capel.
“There was a big effort made,” Capel said. “I thought he was staying. That’s what I was told. It didn’t happen. That was tough.”
Jeff Capel introduced as new Pitt head coach
Craig Meyer: cmeyer@post-gazette.com and Twitter @CraigMeyerPG





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.