For what it’s worth, Jeff Capel won the news conference Wednesday at Petersen Events Center, marking the first win for a Pitt basketball coach in quite some time (Dec. 22, to be precise).
As you know, it doesn’t always go that way when a Pitt coach is introduced.
Remember the Michael Haywood “Freddy Krueger” horror show? How about the Kevin Stallings pep rally/inquisition, which occurred two years earlier, to the day, of Capel eloquently and forcefully blowing away his audience without the use of notes.
A Pitt official told me he hadn’t seen such a thing — no notes on the podium — since Larry Fitzgerald announced he was leaving for the NFL.
On any sane scorecard, Capel scored a knockout. That doesn’t guarantee success, obviously. He has taken on a monumental task. His previous head-coaching job, at Oklahoma, ended in disaster and later with vacated wins because of an assistant coach’s misdeed.
But my gut tells me Capel is the right guy at the right time. It tells me he is a man who, like Penguins coach Mike Sullivan, might have learned from early career misadventures and will return a better coach at the still-young age of 43.
Read More
I also believe Capel symbolically and finally could mark Pitt’s official transition from the Big East Conference to the ACC — especially for those who still pine for the Big East days and really need to move on.
In Capel, Pitt has an ACC lifer. He played there. He won major recruiting battles there. He rode shotgun to the greatest coach in conference history (arguably) for the past seven years. And he was only going to return to the business end of the bench for a coaching job there.
I think we’re going to look back at this as one of the best Pitt hires in recent memory, and the person we’ll have to thank — more than any other — is athletic director Heather Lyke.
That’s who I really want to talk about here, because it feels like a lot of people, for whatever reason, were unwilling to give Lyke much leeway in this search. Maybe it was the scars of previous Pitt searches gone bad. Maybe it was a case of misogyny here or there. But I kept hearing Lyke was in over her head. Not up to the task. Had no Plan ‘B.’
People panicked. Lyke never did. That much is clear. She stayed patient and persistent and landed a coach who has been almost universally praised as a home run hire.
She says she paid zero attention to the chatter.
“[Ohio State] president [E. Gordon] Gee told me a long time ago, ‘In order to be a really successful leader, Heather, you’ve got to always have a sense of humor, you’ve got to have thick skin and you’ve got to have nerves like sewer pipes,’” she said.
Jeff Capel introduced as new Pitt head coach
Capel’s hire was confirmation that Pitt is a good job. Is it top 20 in Division I, as Lyke claimed Wednesday? Highly debatable, but it pays that way. It’s in a prestigious conference. The facilities and tradition are good. The atmosphere when the team is winning is fabulous.
If I had told you over the weekend that Pitt’s new coach, in the wake of the Dan Hurley rejection, would be a “name” candidate who would please local fans and national pundits alike, you would have laughed.
Turns out Lyke did have a Plan B, although we’ll call it Plan ‘C,’ as in Capel, and it wasn’t just a name she took from a search firm. I asked whether her “consultant,” longtime college coach Eddie Fogler, was the first to suggest she might want to contact Capel.
“No,” she said.
OK then, how did it come about?
“Well, as an athletic director, that’s my job, right? To figure out great potential candidates out there,” she said. “You have to always be thinking in those terms. And you study coaches a lot. People think we just go to games for a living. No, you know, you go to a game and you watch demeanor on sidelines, you watch relationships, just as a coach studies a recruit. That’s what we do.”
Fogler endorsed Capel from a coach’s perspective. That left Lyke and others, including chancellor Patrick Gallagher, to make the read on his character and charisma. But it was ultimately Lyke’s call.
She asked some tough questions about Capel’s Oklahoma ending and about college basketball’s ongoing pay-for-play scandal (Duke was mentioned in initial reports, though not in a way that would cause alarm). She sensed immediately this was meant to be.
Capel did, too, largely because of Lyke.
“There was a connection right away, and I felt it,” Capel said. “The main thing I need is an athletic director who believes in me.”
He found one, just as Lyke found a coach who believes in her. I’m guessing he has plenty of company at the moment.
Pittsburgh sports news in my inbox? Yes, please.
Get the PG Sports Feed newsletter each weekday here.
Joe Starkey: jstarkey@post-gazette.com and Twitter @joestarkey1. Joe Starkey can be heard on the "Starkey and Mueller" show weekdays from 2-6 p.m. on 93.7 The Fan.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.