Frankly, it’s been quite a while since we last heard from Pitt athletic director Heather Lyke. She fired former basketball coach Kevin Stallings on March 8, conducted a nearly three-week search process for his successor, and finally landed one Tuesday in Duke assistant Jeff Capel. So after Capel’s opening news conference Wednesday, Lyke took questions from reporters for more than 20 minutes about how the hire came about, what happened with Stallings and much more:
What can you tell us about how you went about the process?
Heather Lyke: “I don’t know that there’s anything more important when you hire people. You can’t ever do jobs alone, so it’s about the team, it’s about the people you surround yourself with. Hiring a head coach is the most important thing that I do, I think, as the leader of the athletic department. And it’s something I think I do really well. Because it’s about building genuine relationships with people and getting to know, first of all, why do you coach and why do you want to come to Pitt? If you can’t answer those two things in a real, genuine way, then it might not be the right fit. I think when Jeff and I had a chance to talk on the phone, I felt it, and then respectfully gave him some space because of his preparation at Duke and what he needed to do there, which was the right thing, which says a lot about him from the start. Then when we had the chance to talk in person and visit, he’s just in it for the right reasons. And those are hard to find sometimes. But he’s genuine and he has a strong desire to lead a program and I think he has learned a tremendous amount in his career, and he’s prepared. He’s watched it now, and he’s excited about building it here at Pitt.”
What’s the tie with Eddie Fogler?
Lyke: “He’s a good friend, a trusted friend.”
Was that your search firm?
Read More
Lyke: “He was my search consultant.”
Was he the first one who mentioned you might want to give Jeff Capel a call, is that how that came about?
Lyke: “No.”
How did it come about?
Lyke: “Well, as an athletic director, that’s my job, right? To figure out great potential candidates out there. You have to always be thinking in those terms. And you study coaches a lot. People think we just go to games for a living — no, you know, you go to a game and you watch demeanor on sidelines, you watch relationships, just as a coach studies a recruit, that’s what we do. You build relationships across the industry. You know people who know people who have worked with them or interacted with them, so there’s no question, Eddie is a trusted adviser. So, when it’s a basketball-specific question, obviously he coached for a long time, so I’m gonna trust his advice on the basketball side of things, but the people side of things is what we need to assess.”
Jeff Capel introduced as new Pitt head coach
Between when you guys made a run at trying to get Dan [Hurley] and you decide to go with Jeff Capel, that week in between, what transpired then to allow you to say OK this is the right guy? Why did it take you that much time to get to Jeff?
Lyke: “I don’t think you’re ever gonna know until you get to know people. You gotta spend time. This is not about identifying one person and knowing that that person is the person without ever talking to them and sitting across the table face to face and understanding who they are and knowing who we are and what we want and seeing whether it’s a connection. So you know, you’ve gotta go through the entire process, and it’s not about speed. It’s about, in my opinion, getting it right. That takes some time and some thoughtful evaluation, and I think every step of the way leads you to the right decision.”
Would you have been willing to wait all the way through until the Final Four before you talked to anybody else if Duke had gone that far?
Lyke: “I don’t know. I think it would’ve depended on a conversation with him on Monday.”
Is it accurate to say you only offered the job to two people?
Lyke: “That is accurate, with Jeff being the No. 2.”
And Dan being the No. 1?
Lyke: “That’s correct.”
Was there ever any concern as this process unfolded that you wouldn’t find the right person?
Lyke: “Oh, never. Never. I’ve hired a lot of head coaches in my career — nine at Ohio State, I lost track at Eastern Michigan, and I guess Keith [Gavin, wrestling] and Sam [Snider, gymnastics] and [soccer] Coach [Randy] Waldrum here already. No, I never doubt that we’re gonna find that right person. Like I said, you can’t settle. With all due respect, I don’t listen a lot, because I’ve gotta stay laser-focused on what we want and what’s best for the university and really, ultimately, what’s best for our student-athletes. If they don’t coach for the impact that they can have on those young people and they don’t wanna be at Pitt and generally wanna be here, then it’s probably not gonna fit with me and with us and what we’re trying to build here. It just takes time. It takes a lot more time than everybody wants, but there was no doubt that there’s tremendous people in the industry. There was tremendous people that we met and talked with, there really are, but this was the perfect fit in my opinion.”
You had Kevin [Stallings] here for basically two years, what led to the decision to get rid of him, when did you decide you were going to get rid of him, what were the factors that you thought about?
Lyke: “I’ve been here literally almost a year, actually a couple days over that, so I think when you evaluate any program, any of our athletic programs, it’s a comprehensive evaluation. It’s not just simply about what’s on the court. It’s the total program evaluation. From how they run their budget to how they build relationships with student-athletes, to how they connect in the community, alumni, donor relations, academics, compliance. All of the elements of a program, and ultimately, there’s a feeling, and it’s a relationship feeling. Does this person want to be at Pitt? Are they really making progress in some of the quantifiable ways that we need to see progress being made? So we agreed to part ways.”
When did you come to that conclusion, was it before the end of the season, at the end of the season?
Lyke: “I don’t think it’s fair to ever do it before the end of the season. I really don’t. I think you have to keep an open mind. Sometimes, it’s hard to do — I mean, I’m sure it’s hard to do from your perspective; you see the numbers — but in fairness to our student-athletes and to the coaches that are working hard, it’s not for a lack of work. It’s not for a lack of effort. So I think to take that away from them and to make decisions before the conclusion of a season is not right.”
What were the things that gave you confidence that made this an attractive job and what were the things you put out there to candidates you were talking to that gave you reason to believe they could be successful at Pitt?
Lyke: “First of all you’ve got — I believe this is a top-10, top-20 job in the country, for sure. You have a platform to compete in the ACC that you can go and be competitive in the highest level. I want coaches who want to compete on that stage, in that setting. You’ve got unbelievable resources, you’ve got unbelievable university support. The chancellor and our team of senior staff here at Pitt are extraordinary. They are really fantastic people that really care about athletics and how it is a part of the fabric of this university. I don't know how many donors I’ve met that have said, ‘My experience at Pitt was about being in the Oakland Zoo.’ So that is an important piece, and so our basketball program is an important piece for us — to build the program and to have, obviously, unbelievable tradition. I don’t think it’s anywhere near where it can be. I think we only have the ability to go up, and I don’t know if we’ve really adapted well yet to the ACC at the time. So for us, it’s unbelievable facilities, you’re in the heart of campus, there’s great tradition, it’s a world-class academic institution, and we’re gonna be partners in this. My job is to provide them with the tools and resources necessary to be successful, and we’re gonna do that, so I feel confident.”
You talk about being laser-focused during the process, everyone criticized in some form or fashion, how hard is it to block that out and ultimately find your guy?
Lyke: “Well, the only thing I feel really bad about is a lot of times I get my news on social media, and I just sort of — I had to watch the real news, you know, to get my news. Because you have to be laser-focused. I know who I am as a leader, I know what great coaches — I’ve been fortunate to be around national championship-caliber coaches in the country. I’ve been a part of lots of national championships in 15 years at Ohio State, conference championships at Eastern Michigan, so I know what it looks like, I know what it feels like and I know how to build it. So for me, it was really doing as much of my own homework as possible to assess them on what I’m gonna have to work with them. I’m gonna have to connect with them, I’m gonna have to feel comfortable introducing them to the media, to our community, to our donors and to our kids. So with all due respect, you have to keep a sense of humor. [Ohio State] President [E. Gordon] Gee told me a long time ago, ‘In order to be a really successful leader, Heather, you’ve got to always have a sense of humor, you’ve got to have thick skin and you’ve got to have nerves like sewer pipes.’ So I took some humor in it all, but I knew what we wanted. And our world is just instant mode, instant stories, and I knew it was gonna take a little time. Then you put the tournament into it and that always plays — you never know what’s going to happen with the tournament.”
Can you just speak to [Capel’s] intelligence or maybe how he sort of struck you, non-basketball-wise, just as a human or a person?
Lyke: “Two things: One, I don’t know if you guys read the Players’ Tribune article that he wrote about his father — that speaks exactly to the depth of a person that he is. Put all the coaching stuff aside, right, what kind of person is this we’re bringing into our family? Then, there’s no question he has the intellectual capability. Our first conversation demonstrated that to me. The thoughtful process, the questions that came at us on Monday about who we are and what we’re about, I mean, it was not shallow stuff. So, I could see that right away in our conversation. He tells the story that he calls Monday night, and I’m pretty — we left there really high, because I just felt like he was the right fit, I felt like he was a dynamic person with an unbelievable partner and family and all that sort of thing. It felt right to me. So we got home, and he’s gonna call me, and so I’m waiting on this call, and I’m thinking he’s taking the job, right? Because I told him, ‘We gotta move.’ I don’t want people to take jobs because they feel pressured, but I also don’t want people to linger on. You know in your heart. I knew when I got this job offer, I accepted it, I wanted to be here. So you know when people wanna be here. So he says to me, ‘Hey Heather, it was a great conversation,’ he says all these nice things, but then, ‘I’m gonna sleep on it.’ I’m like, ‘Uhh’ — you know? I sort of wilted. And I thought OK, I hung up the phone, I thought, ‘You’re gonna sleep on it — I’m not gonna sleep a wink, but you’re gonna have a great night’s sleep.’ But the next morning, when he called first thing, he said, ‘My dad taught me that any great decision, big decision in life, you need to sleep on it.’ I think it says kind of who he is and the depth of a person that he is and the impact that his father had on him, and the impact he wants to have on other kids. I’m glad he thought it through and was very sure about his decision to come here.”
‘Nerves like sewer pipes,’ was that tested in between when Dan accepted the job at UConn, were there procedural harangues you guys had to go through dealing with another team in the conference? What did you have to do there and was that part of the reason why all that stuff got kicked up social media about the coach from Bonaventure, the coach from Buffalo saying he’s not interested?
Lyke: “I don’t pay attention to that, honestly. I feel bad, but I didn’t, because I knew what we were gonna strategically do. I felt very comfortable. You gotta get in front of people, and I wanted to talk to some people, and when it would be appropriate, we would do it.”

When Jeff left the program at Oklahoma, they were put on probation for something an assistant coach did there. We see there’s an ongoing investigation in college basketball at large involving recruiting, Duke has been mentioned, is there concern there that something could blow up, whether asked questions about that, whether you had to do due diligence into Jeff’s past as a recruiter?
Lyke: “We had to do due diligence from the get-go on all of our candidates. It’s interesting, obviously it’s a really tenuous time in the world of college basketball, and it did cause certain candidates to maybe not be on the radar and certain programs to not be on the radar. We definitely had a very frank, candid conversation about integrity, about decisions, about the staff you surround yourself with, how you run your program. Real open, real honest with Jeff, and I felt very comfortable with his comments, his philosophy and how he’ll lead this program.”
He was not implicated in that, but if one of your head coaches had an assistant go rogue, if he came into your office, would that be an acceptable excuse to say he didn’t know anything if that was one of your coaches?
Lyke: “At this point in time, today, I think obviously the expectations are a bit different. There’s head coach accountability and responsibility now under the NCAA rules, so the head coaches know that they are now very clearly responsible for the acts of their assistant coaches.”
Seven years is a long time for a contract, was this his suggestion?
Lyke: “No, that was our offer. If you get it right, I wanted to be committed to him, and I wanted him to be committed to us and understanding it’s not about how fast you build it. It’s about building it the right way, and with integrity. We’re not interested in a quick-fix, for lack of a better term. It’s gonna take some time. We have patience, but we believe in you, and I believe we got it right, so that’s really what seven years says to him.”
Pittsburgh sports news in my inbox? Yes, please.
Get the PG Sports Feed newsletter each weekday here.
He’s a known guy, he’s coached a Big 12 program, he comes from Duke, does that buy patience from your fanbase, from the alumni, the donors, to say he might have to overdo a full roster here, the fact that he’s the commodity that he is, how much does that play into your thinking of why it was worth it to invest yourself?
Lyke: “I think what it does is it shows belief in him. I’m confident that he knows how to build the program. He’s gonna start to build relationships with kids today. Yesterday, it was the first thing he asked me, ‘Can I get everyone’s phone number?’ when he accepted the job. So he went right to the student-athletes, right to building relationships, so I feel great about it. I think it shows belief in what he’s about and how he’s gonna build it.”
The length of the deal is one thing, but the financial component of it, where does it put Jeff in terms of ACC coaches or even nationally?
Lyke: “It’s very competitive. We have an unusual conference, right, with a few outliers in that pool. But I think it’s extremely competitive. If you want to compete at the highest level, then there’s compensation that goes alongside that, as well. I feel very good about it, and I know he does, too.”
Brian Batko: bbatko@post-gazette.com and Twitter @BrianBatko.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.