After firing coach Kevin Stallings on Thursday after two seasons, Pitt has thrust itself into a situation that comes with doubt but can end with tremendous reward, especially considering the depths to which the program has fallen. Athletic Director Heather Lyke and other university leadership will not only be searching for a new coach, but a new direction and identity for a program that has seemingly lost a sense of both.

It’s hard to imagine the Panthers being any worse than they were this year — they were the only Division I team without a conference win — but the next few days or weeks will determine whether the Panthers can come close to reaching the heights they once so recently did.

“Right now, you could make the argument that the next hire for Pitt is probably the most important hire the school has made since it hired Ben Howland [in 1999],” said Jon Rothstein, a college basketball analyst for CBS. “You’re in the best conference in college basketball, just like they were in the Big East, and you pretty much need to start from scratch.”

Success is obviously the desired outcome for Pitt, even if it isn’t quite what it was under former coaches Jamie Dixon and Howland, under whom it appeared in the top 10 of the Associated Press poll in 11 consecutive seasons. How it will go about achieving that success, though, is the much more interesting variable.

Advertise with us

‘Hire a plan’

From 2002-11, Pitt had an unmistakable and wildly successful identity. Built on the backs of talented three- and four-star recruits, largely players from around New York and Philadelphia who wanted to play in the Big East and attend an urban school, the Panthers mastered a brand of physical and tenacious basketball, with a plodding-but-incredibly-efficient offense. They were the toughest team in the sport’s toughest conference.

A move to the ACC in 2013 allowed them to escape the instability of the Big East, but it largely stripped Pitt of the factors that allowed it to become what it did.

Pitt doesn’t have to try to recreate that blueprint, grasping desperately for something that may no longer exist. But after wandering aimlessly in the final years of Dixon’s 13-year tenure and Stallings’ brief two-year stay, it needs something more from its next hire.

“Pitt doesn’t need to hire a coach at this point. It needs to hire a plan,” said Mike DeCourcy, a longtime college basketball writer for the Sporting News. “Whoever you bring in, I don’t care what his record is, I don’t care who is recommending him. That matters to me less than ‘OK, how are you going to do this?’ ‘Oh, we’re going to go out and recruit the best players.’ Oh, good for you. No, you’re not. What is your plan to get this better? The resume is important because it says what you’ve done, but what really matters at Pitt’s juncture is how are you going to do this? Because there is no obvious answer to this.”

Advertise with us

Part of that search for an identity can be tied to recruiting and where exactly the Panthers get their players. Pitt is in an interesting position, wedged between the recruiting hotbeds of the Northeast and Mid-Atlantic on one side and the Midwest on another. To its north, there’s the burgeoning talent pool in Toronto, which Stallings tried to tap into with players such as Marcus Carr and Shamiel Stevenson.

The relative lack of local talent isn’t a huge impediment, so long as Pitt, as it once did almost 20 years ago, can find a niche for itself.

“I would say it’s certainly a hindrance, but it’s not a hindrance that can’t be overcome in the modern recruiting world,” said Sam Vecenie, a senior college basketball writer for The Athletic, of the western Pennsylvania recruiting pool.

The questions then became not only about what Pitt can be, but what it offers.

It’s a major research university in a large city with nice, albeit slowly aging, facilities. Virtually every coach who would consider the job can remember what the program was even four years ago, one decorated with conference championships, top NCAA tournament seeds and one of the best home-court advantages in the country.

Advertise with us

Its greatest asset, both financially and competitively, may not have to do with the school itself, but the conference. Though there’s variance from year to year, the ACC is widely heralded as the sport’s best league.

That presents a problem, though. The ACC has long been anchored by Duke and North Carolina, and that was before the addition of powerhouse programs such as Louisville and Syracuse. Many of the league’s other programs are only getting better. For example, Virginia has become one of college basketball’s best and most consistent programs under coach Tony Bennett.

While Pitt can undoubtedly rise from its last-place standing, it’s fair to wonder how high it can climb.

“The plus that you have is there are programs you can easily pass if you do it right,” DeCourcy said. “That depends on them remaining in their current circumstances. That’s not a given. The second problem that goes with that is that if you pass them, now you’re in like 11th [of 15 teams]. It’s such a long way just to the middle of this league.”

Kevin Stallings is out. What now for Pitt?

In a better spot?

Advertise with us

The program certainly isn’t what it was when it was tasked with replacing Dixon two years ago, but it may be a more attractive destination. Instead of having to replace the best coach in school history, one, at least initially, only has to surpass Stallings.

“The way to do it is to give the coach like a six- or seven-year contract,” Vecenie said. “You just say ‘Hey, we’re going to give you all the rope in the world and build this program the way you see fit. We’re going to give you time and all the resources you need, or at least all the resources we can afford, and just go about building your program.’ I think that’s at least a viable workaround if they’re trying to go big-game hunting in the coaching carousel.”

That coach will be defined not by his standing before accepting the job, but rather how he does once he arrives. And those tasked with selecting him will be judged not merely by the process or how it is received, but what comes from it. A program in a fragile state can’t afford yet another misstep.

“Pitt is kind of caught in between worlds,” Rothstein said. “They obviously for a long time were associated with the Big East, but the problem is they’re closer geographically to the Big Ten than some ACC schools. It’s going to take somebody with a deep recruiting network and an unprecedented work ethic to turn this thing around and get Pitt competitive again.”

Craig Meyer: cmeyer@post-gazette.com and Twitter @CraigMeyerPG