Put yourself in Heather Lyke’s shoes.

Pitt’s athletic director inherited a coach from Scott “West Coast Basketball Guy” Barnes, who figured Kevin Stallings was just the man to lead Pitt to a Final Four someday.

You'll see, Barnes said during that painful pep rally/press conference introducing Stallings less than two years ago: The new coach would “move the needle” with a “fun” brand of basketball.

He moved it all right. All the way to zero, which was about the average attendance at Petersen Events Center this season.

Advertise with us

As my colleague Craig Meyer pointed out, the 15 smallest regular-season crowds (and 23 of 29) in the Pete’s 16-year history all happened under Stallings.

So again, put yourself in Lyke’s shoes.

Are you just going to sit there and watch your basketball program die?

Lyke arrived right after Stallings Part I, the 2016-17 season, when the then-56-year-old coach regularly trashed his players and presided over the worst Pitt basketball loss in more than 100 years (a 55-point nail-biter against Louisville in which he got himself tossed).

In Year 2, he presided over perhaps the worst team in school history and quite possibly ACC basketball history.

Advertise with us

I’m sorry, but no matter how much or how little you pin all of that on Stallings, you cannot possibly blame Lyke for wanting to go in a different direction (up) with her chosen coach.

I was more than willing to give Stallings a chance — and I still believe Pitt can do better than the last five years of Jamie Dixon — but Year 1 was a major turnoff. I actually thought it was worse than Year 2.

It just never sat well how Stallings let it be known early and often that the team he inherited was deeply flawed and there wasn’t much he could do about it.

In other words, don’t blame me.

He regularly cited a lack of leadership that year, implicating seniors Michael Young and Jamel Artis every time. Even if the charge held truth — and it did — constantly proclaiming it led to a bigger question: What kind of leadership example was the coach setting?

Advertise with us

I have never seen a coach publicly rip his players more than Stallings did that year. He even topped Todd Graham.

After barely surviving the University of Buffalo in a non-conference game, Stallings said he wouldn’t throw anyone under the bus, a statement always to be taken as code for, “I could throw somebody under the bus, because somebody deserves to be thrown under the bus, but I will magnanimously restrain myself.”

He proceeded to get behind the wheel and drive the thing himself.

“I wouldn’t call it great,” he said when asked to rate his team’s leadership. He later went up to the reporter who asked the question and within earshot of others said he wished he could say more. The message was clear: He was holding back on what he really thought of his main guys. Nice.

It’s not as if the veterans on hand had a history of lethargy and underachievement. Save for point guard James Robinson — who must have been Chris Paul in disguise based on what transpired after he left — Stallings inherited an NCAA tournament team, albeit a terribly thin one on account of Dixon’s poor recruiting class (one Stallings kept intact).

Advertise with us

After the thousand-point loss to Louisville, Stallings said, “There are a lot of things I could say, a lot things I would like to say” and felt compelled to add, “I feel there's some fragmentation maybe in the locker room, unfortunately.”

What could possibly be gained from putting that out there?

I’ll tell you what was lost: the sacredness of team, which in this case would have been defined as keeping issues in-house. Stallings publicizing what he viewed as locker-room dysfunction became a story. Pitt’s story. ESPN broadcasters repeated it regularly during the Panthers’ ACC tournament loss to Virginia.

The company line on the Stallings hire was that he would unlock the handcuffs, differentiating him from control-freak Dixon. But this was Stallings by the end of a season that included a loss to Duquesne: “If the coach says run a play, how about just run the play?”

The second year pretty much explains itself in numbers:

Advertise with us

• ONE recruit rated by 247Sports as a composite top-200 prospect, as Meyer reported (this, for a coach who said recruiting pipelines shut off to him at Vanderbilt would gush at Pitt).

•  ZERO wins in the ACC, going 0-19 with all but four losses by double digits. Pitt was the only Division I team among 351 without a conference win.

• THIRTY-ONE-point loss to Penn State.

• ONE field goal in the first half against Virginia, tying the worst mark in college basketball history (in the shot-clock era).

So yeah, it didn’t go real well.

Advertise with us

Now try selling season tickets, or, more accurately, begging season-ticket holders to stay, on the promise of Kevin Stallings Part III.

Think you’re going to successfully promote a program on a coach who has not advanced as far as an Elite Eight in his 25-year career and who steered the S.S. Panther directly into an iceberg (though not before Cam Johnson grabbed a lifeboat)?

Don’t feel bad for Stallings, who leaves with a lottery check in hand. Feel bad for Pitt. This program sunk so far that some were calling a close loss to Notre Dame in the first round of the ACC tournament a turning point because the players tried (for the record, I don’t think effort was ever an issue with this team).

You’re up, Heather Lyke.

You can’t possibly do worse.

Joe Starkey: jstarkey@post-gazette.com and Twitter @joestarkey1. Joe Starkey can be heard on the “Starkey and Mueller” show weekdays from 2-6 p.m. on 93.7 The Fan.