Each week during the 2017-18 season, Craig Meyer, the Post-Gazette’s Pitt basketball writer, will answer fan and reader questions about the Panthers. And some other stuff, too.
If you want to submit a question, you can email Craig at cmeyer@post-gazette.com or hit him up on Twitter @CraigMeyerPG.
Kenneth: Now that Pitt Basketball is either a minor league franchise or a bad mid-major do you think all of the people who were so unhappy with the "style" that Jamie Dixon's teams played want that style back? If they are unsure which style we speak of that would be where you score more points than the other team.
Craig: I didn’t live here for the majority of his tenure, so I say this as an outsider who watched his program from afar, but the interpretation of Jamie Dixon’s style of play always seemed to be based off how well his teams were doing. When Pitt was a perennial top-10 program, it made them a tough and rugged team that so quintessentially embodied the conference in which it played and the city it represented. Once the Panthers’ fortunes started to decline later in his tenure, it became unwatchable slog-ball that only seemed to compound the teams’ problems. Not only were they not what they once were, but they were boring to watch.
I wrote about this last year, but one of the great misconceptions of Dixon as a coach is that his teams were offensively incompetent. They may not have posted gaudy point totals, no, but they’re consistently among the most efficient teams in the country. Each of his teams in his coaching career have finished among the top 50 nationally in offensive efficiency, something only Mike Krzyzewski can also claim to have done during that span. His teams’ low points-against totals weren’t the product of great defenses, as Pitt’s defensive efficiency numbers were a little more across the board during Dixon’s tenure. He’ll tell you as much. Rather, it had more to do with the Panthers’ pace of play. They played at a deliberate pace, meaning the other team had fewer opportunities to score.
Which brings us back to the style of play argument. When Dixon left for TCU in 2016, then-AD Scott Barnes talked about bringing in a coach who employs an exciting brand of basketball. He wasn’t entirely wrong, as only one of Dixon’s 13 teams at Pitt ranked among the top 200 squads nationally (of 351) in tempo. While Kevin Stallings’ teams certainly play faster, it’s a low bar to clear. Only three of his final 15 teams at Vanderbilt ranked among the top 120 teams nationally in tempo. This season, Pitt is 315th in tempo, which isn’t all that surprising given its inexperience. TCU, meanwhile? It’s 74th, which, if the season ended today, would be the highest a Dixon team has ever ranked, by a wide margin.
Is everyone healthy for Saturday’s big game?
— Barry J (@BarryJ23) December 14, 2017
Craig: Not everybody is healthy for Pitt, though Stallings said he doesn’t expect anybody to be out. Jonathan Milligan is still struggling with a hamstring injury, one he played through against West Virginia. Meanwhile, Peace Ilegomah has a case of turf toe and Monty Boykins sprained his ankle in practice. But there’s nothing incredibly serious or game-altering.
This is a complaint and a ? The door is wide open for a polished 4 or 5 to come in and play significant minutes next year. Brown, Ilogomah and George are developmental guys. We desperately need a good big man! Any feedback on how the 3 FR bigs are doing in practice?
— John Enright (@johnenright46) December 14, 2017
Craig: The inherent problem for a school like Pitt is polished freshmen bigs rarely come to, well, a school like Pitt, instead opting for the Dukes and Kentuckys of the world. Even a top-10 recruit like Steven Adams wasn’t exactly a finely tuned, immediately college-ready prospect (as good as he was at times during his lone season in Oakland). Guys like DeJuan Blair are the exceptions, not the rule.
As for the current freshman bigs, I think the general thought is they all still have a ways to go. Terrell Brown is probably the furthest along of the group, but even he looks out of place and occasionally overwhelmed when he’s in the game. Ilegomah is ideally someone who would redshirt, but as we know, Pitt’s not exactly in a situation right now that caters to the ideal. Samson George is only 6-foot-7, but still probably qualifies as a big. He’s a really tenacious player who rebounds well and provides a good level of energy, but he, too, also needs his game to be refined a bit before he gets any kind of notable minutes.
Update on players who transferred out this year? Update on any recent players playing pro ball (nba, G league, Europe, Asia, etc)?
— Davin Brown (@davin_brown) December 14, 2017
Craig: I touched on the players who transferred out a couple of weeks ago, but Pitt has a good amount of ex-players in various leagues around the world. Here’s a look at how they’re doing:
Steven Adams (Oklahoma City Thunder): 14 points/game, 8.7 rebounds/game, 64.9% on field goals, 1 block/game, 1.2 steals/game, 1.7 turnovers/game. His scoring and rebounding numbers are career highs.
Jamel Artis (NBA G League): 19.7 pts, 6.7 rebs, 2.7 assists/game, 46% FGs, 35.1% from 3-point range, 1.2 stls, 2.9 TOs. He made his NBA debut Wednesday for the Magic, playing one minute and missing his lone shot attempt.
Mike Young (G League): 12.5 pts, 5.7 rebs, 2.2 asts, 42.1% FGs, 26.6% 3s, 0.5 blocks, 1.3 TOs.
JJ Moore (G League): 9.3 pts, 2.1 rebs, 0.9 asts, 38.8% FGs, 29.4% 3s.
Alonzo Nelson-Ododa (G League): 6.9 pts, 6.1 rebs, 0.9 blocks, 1.6 TOs, 53.6% FGs
Lamar Patterson (Italy): 12.3 pts, 5 rebs, 3.1 asts, 1.8 stls, 2.3 TOs, 44.2% FGs, 24.2% 3s.
James Robinson (Germany): 6.5 pts, 3.2 asts, 1 TO, 0.8 stls, 40.8% FGs, 28.1% 3s
Sam Young (Lebanon): 25 pts, 7.4 rebs, 1.8 asts, 1 stl, 2.2 TOs, 52.2% FGs, 36.8% 3s
Brad Wanamaker (Turkey): 10.6 pts, 3 asts, 2.1 rebs, 1 stl, 60% FGs, 45% 3s
Sheldon Jeter (Bulgaria): 4 pts, 2 rebs, 50% FGs
Ashton Gibbs (Dominican Republic): 15.3 pts, 2.5 asts, 1 TO, 54.1% FGs, 52.5% 3s
Antonio Graves (Turkey): 19.7 pts, 3.7 asts, 3.2 rebs, 1.5 stls, 2.3 TOs, 50.5% FGs, 44.7% 3s
Gary McGhee (Greece): 11.2 pts, 8.4 rebs, 2.6 TOs, 54.8% FGs
Ronald Ramon (Brazil): 6.8 pts, 2 asts, 1.2 TOs, 66.7% FGs, 43.8% 3s
Chevon Troutman (Argentina): 9.2 pts, 8.6 rebs, 2 TOs, 65.6% FGs
Talib Zanna (Israel): 12.9 pts, 8.4 rebs, 1 stl, 1.3 TOs, 46% FGs
Is there anyone in Pitt Nation who did not see d i n u c c i transferring after the milk toast support he received from narduzzi?
— Martin Cribbs (@cribasbaby) December 14, 2017
Craig: I wouldn’t have been surprised if he had returned, but it’s also not really a stunning development that he opted to transfer. It’s difficult to have the starting job for any period of time only to have it taken away by a player who, as was seen in the final regular season game, is very clearly the future for the program at that position. I can’t fault Ben DiNucci too much for leaving.
It’s Hanukkah so let’s sport-ify the Maccabees. What’s the most miraculous underdog game (or I suppose season) you’ve witnessed in person?
— Corey Cohen (@CoreyECohen) December 14, 2017
Craig: Besides when my wife said yes when I proposed to her (sorry, dad joke), I guess the natural answer would be when Robert Morris beat Kentucky in the NIT in 2013, back when I covered the Bobs. The thing with that game, though, was that Robert Morris wasn’t that much of an underdog. I remember the spread only being a few points. It was a really good and experienced low-major team playing against a Nerlens Noel-less Kentucky team made up mostly of freshmen, a decent amount of whom looked like they really didn’t want to be there.
I’d actually argue RMU’s team the following season was the bigger Cinderella story, as a squad with just eight players (following transfers, suspensions, etc.) came within a game of making the NCAA tournament. But that’s just me.
Craig Meyer: cmeyer@post-gazette.com and Twitter @CraigMeyerPG




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.