About halfway through a question Monday about the struggles of his team’s run game on offense, Pitt coach Pat Narduzzi jumped in with a quick retort.

“It looked pretty good when No. 9 was in there, didn’t it?” he said at his weekly news conference. “Didn’t struggle when No. 9 was in there, did it?”

He’s not wrong. In the moments when the ball is handed to do-everything star Jordan Whitehead — No. 9 in the programs and No. 1 on the team in yards per rushing attempt — the ground attack seems dynamic, capable of carving apart opposing defenses and moving the ball with relative ease.

Though Whitehead’s presence on offensive has been a solution at times, it also highlights a glaring problem — Pitt’s most effective runner and its best offensive option is a safety.

Advertise with us

That problem doesn’t stem from the fact Whitehead is making explosive rushing plays on offense; after all, he’s been doing that each of his three seasons at Pitt. It’s that too often he is the only player capable of doing so.

A program that relied on accomplished running backs to carry it during Narduzzi’s tenure and for the past decade has struggled to gain any sense of traction from its backfield this season.

As a team, Pitt is averaging just 3.3 yards per rush, ranking it last in the ACC and placing it among the bottom 25 teams in the Football Bowl Subdivision. Halfway through the season, it doesn’t have one player with more than 250 yards. Its top four running backs heading into the season — Qadree Ollison, Chawntez Moss, Darrin Hall and A.J. Davis — are averaging 3.5 yards per carry on a combined 469 yards and the second member of that group, Moss, has been suspended indefinitely. Two of the Panthers’ four leading rushers are a safety (Whitehead, with 132 yards on 10 carries) and a wide receiver (Quadree Henderson, with 96 yards on 17 carries).

The pronounced dip from where things were even last year, when Pitt had James Conner and a group of players who collectively averaged 5.4 yards per attempt, raises questions and concerns about where it has gone wrong. Those questions, to Narduzzi, have no simple answers.

“It’s a great question, and I think I answer it every week,” he said. “It’s a little of everything. It’s a little bit of the backs. Sometimes, it’s a quarterback making the right check, depending on the game and who made that call. Max [Browne] has been really good at that. And then sometimes it’s the offensive line. It only takes one. When you put them all in a box and you’re in a two-tight end set and one guy misses a block, it can look like an ugly play, but four other guys really blocked well, but, if you miss one block, then it all goes downhill, and it doesn’t matter. It makes them all look bad.”

Advertise with us

The Panthers’ predicament poses not only questions about the running backs, but the offensive line behind which those backs are galloping (or, more accurately, too often aren’t).

After losing standouts Dorian Johnson and Adam Bisnowaty to the NFL, Pitt’s line — arguably its biggest strength the past several seasons — has been surprisingly suspect through six games. In addition to the run game’s shortcomings, the Panthers have allowed 18 sacks, ranking them among the bottom 20 teams in the FBS.

While the line has its mainstays like reigning Piesman Trophy winner Brian O’Neill, there has been little certainty at the position this year, with a cast of player shuffling between the various positions on the line, moves prompted by coaches looking for something resembling an answer. It’s a search that’s still ongoing.

“If there was five beasts up there, then we’d keep the five beasts,” Narduzzi said. “You can tell the guys that haven’t been out of the two deep or been out of the starting lineup, so we’re looking for the five consistent guys, and, if it’s all average, then keep them fresh and give them an opportunity to go play.”

Then, of course, there’s the matter of Whitehead. While a defensive player ideally wouldn’t be a team’s most viable threat on offense, Pitt finds itself in such a situation. It can be tempting to embrace it and enhance the junior’s role, but such a move would come with concerns about overworking the team’s best defensive player and leaving him more open to injury.

Advertise with us

Narduzzi acknowledged he doesn’t want to wear his most valuable player down, but, saddled with a struggling team, he has to find ways to manufacture wins. As he put it Monday, “I’m over balance right now.”

With six games remaining, all in conference play and all but one against teams with winning records, he has to be.

“He’s a great kid that wants to go,” Narduzzi said of Whitehead. “He comes off yesterday all smiles, and I said, ‘Hey, just keep going.’ We’ll do what we need to do.”

Craig Meyer: cmeyer@post-gazette.com and Twitter @CraigMeyerPG,