Brian Batko: Hello, everyone. Pitt takes on Penn State at 3:30 p.m. Saturday at Beaver Stadium. Let's begin.
DoubleM: How do you feel about the media blackout by Narduzzi w his players this week? I think it's a mistake. Pitt football needs all the hype it can get in this pro sports town, right?
Brian Batko: Good afternoon, DoubleM. Truth be told, I'm a bit surprised this is the first question for me, given that I've been told all week that "no one cares" about this story. Well let me say this: It's an inherently self-serving discussion for media members to have, so it's something of a lose-lose for me to comment. I don't think it's a mistake. I just think it's silly, because I don't think it will have any outcome on the game. The angle of Pitt needing more publicity doesn't do much for me, either.
Brian Batko: Moving on...
RaleighPittFan: What are your thoughts on Max Browne? I thought he played horrible against a FCS opponent and explains why he transferred from USC.
Brian Batko: I'd say he didn't play great, but he wasn't terrible, either. And it's fair to wonder: How much of his issues were due to a vanilla game-plan? How much of his issues were due to an offensive line that struggled - more on that in a minute - to keep him clean in the second half? I'm not out on Max Browne yet, but we'll know a lot more after Saturday.
Read More
RatKing17: The O-line was horrible against Youngstown! I was shocked at how they physically outplayed by a lesser FCS opponent. Will there be any changes to the starting 5?
Brian Batko: Astute observation, my dear RatKing. The line struggled much more than I thought it would, especially in pass protection in the second half. Upon rewatching, undersized but athletic YSU defensive ends were just blowing past the tackles to get to Max Browne. I think the one change you could see is Alex Bookser moving into the lineup somewhere, possibly at center to replace Jimmy Morrissey. Or maybe Alex Officer moves over from left guard to center. If I had to guess the first 5 out there Saturday, I'd say (left to right): O'Neill-Bookser-Officer-Hodges-JonesSmith.
H2P333: The LBs were NOT good against YSU in my opinion. They didn't fill the gaps and couldn't cover anyone! Do you think there will be any changes with players or schemes against Penn State? If not, then it could be a long season.
Brian Batko: I don't think they were all bad, my friend. Sean Idowu seemed to be around the ball a lot. Saleem Brightwell at middle, you'd probably like to see more production out of him than 5 tackles. Elijah Zeise was picked on a few times with that wheel route, but even he had a play that probably should've been ruled a fumble where he stripped a YSU ball-carrier. They need to be better, obviously, but I'm not sure there are other options. Backups Jalen Williams and Anthony McKee on the outside have never done anything to write home about, while Chase Pine is only a redshirt freshman behind Brightwell. And now, Quintin Wirginis is out for the year, not just the first three games. These are the guys at LB.
M96: I thought Brian O'Neill played a subpar game against Youngstown State. Is he completely healthy or just struggling with the move to left tackle?
Brian Batko: Agreed, he was "below the line," as Mike Tomlin would say. Not quite "varsity," perhaps. But anyway, with as cautious as Pat Narduzzi is, I don't think O'Neill's out there at all if he isn't 100 percent. The flip from right tackle to the blindside was maybe more difficult than expected, but he should be better as the season goes along. He didn't allow a single sack last year on 366 pass-blocking attempts, according to Pro Football Focus.
H2P333: Don't you think that recruiting matters?!?! Pitt struggled against a FCS opponent! It comes down to the material and/or coaching. I expected better from both fronts in Year 3 of Narduzzi. Neither appears to be getting better and that is concerning.
Brian Batko: Recruiting very much matters, but I suspect that was a rhetorical question. YSU recruits much better than the average FCS school; if I had a dollar for every time Pat Narduzzi mentioned the amount of FBS transfers on Bo Pelini's roster last week, I might've quit this damn job (kidding).
But yes, things are still a work in progress at Pitt. It's easy to be discouraged after an overtime win vs. Youngstown State, but how soon people forget a victory last year at Clemson...
Mike Bierce: What's your prediction for the Pitt vs. Penn State game?
Brian Batko: Thanks for the question, sir. But maybe I should leave that for the end...
PittGuy81: How is our defense still SO bad in year 3 of Coach Duzz? I get that our recruits have not been highly rated, but Narduzzi was labeled a defensive genius at Michigan St. When will we see this at Pitt?
Brian Batko: Actually, PittGuy, some highly rated defensive recruits HAVE chosen Pitt since Narduzzi arrived. This time a year ago, a secondary featuring Jordan Whitehead, Damar Hamlin and Paris Ford looked dang good on paper. But guess what, all three of those guys haven't quite panned out as expected yet for various reasons. It's almost like the year-long debate about the Pirates this season - do you blame the players who are out there for not getting the job done, or do you blame the coaches for not doing more with what they've got/not planning for unexpected setbacks? Beats me.
Scaztastic: Could Pitt start the season 1-3? Penn State and OK St look grim after last week's debacle against Youngstown. How do you like Pitts chances against Ga Tech in week 4?
Brian Batko: Pitt could absolutely start 1-3, Scaz. A few chats ago, someone asked me the percentage of Pitt starting 0-3. I think I said 22 percent. Ask me now the odds of them losing the next three, I might say it's higher than that. Georgia Tech impressed me even in a loss the other night to Tennessee. TaQuon Marshall looks like a real problem at QB. We know Penn State beak Akron a billion to zero. And in case you missed it, Mason Rudolph threw for 303 yards, with James Washington getting 145 of those, in OK State's 59-24 rout of Tulsa. Pitt fans know what that looks like...
KingNattyDaddy: Do you think the plays Narduzzi held back against YSU will really make a difference to upset Penn State this week and make Max Browne look like a good QB?
Brian Batko: KingNattyDaddy, my man, don't drink too many Nattys on Saturday. I don't think Pitt has enough tricks up its sleeve to BEAT Penn State, but I do think Max Browne will look better with more of the playbook available to him. And not only that, but I think there will be more of a nothing-to-lose mindset this week. Ergo, more deep balls for Jester Weah to go up and get it, more touches for Quadree Henderson, etc.
Moto: Pitt's D line didn't seem to do much at all especially the DE. Hendrix? Edwards? Is that how you saw it?
Brian Batko: That's pretty much how I saw it, Moto. And that's pretty much how Pat Narduzzi saw it, too. He said flat-out after the game Saturday that he wasn't happy with the pressure, four or five-man pressure. Hendrix certainly needs to be more of a factor to live up to the hype that's preceded him for two seasons now. Edwards, I barely noticed. Will Pitt rotate on the D-line less this week than last? I think that's a possibility. I counted 10 D-linemen in the mix against YSU. That's a lot.
Cleveburgh: Pitt was a heavy favorite heading into the opener. YSU out-gained Pitt 418-348 in total yards, had 3 sacks and dominated Pitt in the second half after adjustments. Narduzzi said in his post-game news conference that he expects to see YSU in the FCS national championship game again this year. Was YSU that really that good or are there serious red flags for Pitt this season? Both?
Brian Batko: Ha, you referencing that Narduzzi comment reminds me of the old go-to presser line from Jamie Dixon about some of the soup cans Pitt beat over the years. "We expect them to be at the top of their conference," or some such quote. All the things you lay out are distressing, of course. I don't proclaim to know enough about the FCS national landscape to really answer that, but I thought YSU did some pretty impressive things defensively that 2nd half. Still a red flag, though.
Matt N.: Did Browne play like a granny in the Fall camp scrimmages too or was he really being sandbagged by Narduzzi vs YSU? If so, they did an amazing job making him look like a 1 1/2 - 2 star instead of five.
Brian Batko: Hi, Matt. "Play like a granny" - that's pretty funny. I'm not sure if he was more granny or Danny (Marino) in the scrimmages, as we don't get to see them, but Pitt's coaches always spoke highly of his performances there. Then again, what gives me a bit of pause is that they didn't often praise him for his physical traits as much as for his mental ones. I believe there was a level of sandbaggery there, but how much, I can't say for sure.
Bulk: Brian,
Brian Batko: Bulk,
Bulk: Brian - Last year we saw the jet sweep work successfully. Do you believe this year they will use some spread option type packages for Dinucci as a change of pace this week at PSU?
Brian Batko: No, I don't think so. Yes, DiNucci is more mobile than Browne, but I'd be surprised if something like that is waiting in the wings for Penn State. Narduzzi's sneakery knows no bounds, but that seems like a stretch.
Brian Batko: What I'd like to see is Brian O'Neill line up in the shotgun
Roman: What do you expect to see differently from the offense this game?
Brian Batko: I sorta mentioned this earlier, but I think you'll see more jump balls for Jester Weah. Or just more passes to Jester Weah, in general. I think Quadree Henderson's touch count might double from the 10 he got Saturday - whether that's short passes, jet sweeps, whatever. I mean, there's only so many things you can do on offense in football - pass or run - but I just have to assume there's more creativity to Shawn Watson's offense, which everyone has said will be similar to Matt Canada's offense, which was quite creative.
Brian Batko: Oh, one other thing I think you might see - more Matt Flanagan doing George Aston-like things, and thus, Chris Clark doing more in the passing game at tight end. Just a thought.
Roman: Any word on Moss?
Brian Batko: Nope, just that it sounds like he was held out for some sort of non-injury reason Saturday. He was dressed and everything, just nowhere even close to offensive huddles while the game was going on. He was not gonna get in there unless, like, 17 people got hurt.
GregBrownsToupee: Will HCPN try and mess up PSU's snap count again with some hand clapping? You think he has any other tricks up his sleeve for this game?
Brian Batko: Would've been a great question to ask Pitt's linebackers this week. Crap, I said I wasn't going to mention that again. Next question, please.
Matt N.: Methinks AJ Davis was being held back as well, and do you think he might be unleashed on an unsuspecting PSU?
Brian Batko: That's a good point. I do agree we might see more A.J. Davis this week. I was a little surprised that he was seemingly used as something of a short-yardage back Saturday. Not really how I thought of him or how Pitt's coaches have talked about him. Maybe he's in for more work, as he might be Pitt's potential game-breaker. The gloves (redshirt) are off.
Joe Nghu: Brian, do you think Pitt would benefit to stack the line to limit Barkley, or would it leave their cb's on too much of an island?
Brian Batko: Well Joe, Narduzzi always stands firm that first things first: stopping the run. I think he'd rather leave his CBs out there to try to lock up Penn State's wideouts, and hope Avonte Maddox or Dane Jackson make the play, than let Barkley further cementer his Heisman campaign vs. the Panthers.
Kevin: The knock from fans on Watson at TX and Lville was he was an awful play caller. I thought that the play calling especially down the stretch was down right atrocious I'm hoping it was due to Pitts vanilla offense but a part of me thinks that this might continue so what are your thoughts on Watson's week 1 performance
Brian Batko: Hey Kevin, I've certainly heard that as well. I mean, at Texas, Charlie Strong basically confirmed as much by demoting Watson from the team's play-caller. But vanilla or not, isn't one game too early to judge him? Geez, isn't one game too early to judge anyone? Aw, shucks.
LBModel: The linebacking crew looked lost at times last week. The LB recruiting has been subpar for this staff. At what point does Coach Harley start to shoulder some blame?
Brian Batko: You mean recruiting coordinator Rob Harley? I'm with you, LB, that the position isn't very deep right now for Pitt. Narduzzi would even agree with you there, as he said last week that he can't imagine playing more than 4 or 5 LBs. But beyond his positional duties, Harley's also landed some key recruits in his area, locally. Paris Ford comes to mind...
KyleB: Was Browne being sacked 3 times by YSU an OL problem, Browne's fault or a combination? Any chance that whatever it was will be fixed before the Penn State game?
Brian Batko: Is this Kyle Busch? Good luck this weekend. Had no idea you follow Pitt football. Anyway, I think it's a combination of both. Browne probably has to have a better pocket presence about him, especially given how long he's been playing college football, but the O-line was expected to be a strength for this team. At least I expected it to be. We'll see what happens when you add Alex Bookser back to the equation.
BigPitt: As bad as Pitt played in second half against a good FCS team, 21 point underdog to a "rival". What does Vegas know?
Brian Batko: Vegas knows that Penn State returns something like 16 starters and Pitt lost 5 players to the NFL draft among several other key contributors. That makes for a BigPitt spread in the wrong direction.
Jim: I know this is a dumb, common question but... is there ANY chance Pitt can pull it off? What are the three things that will have to happen?
Brian Batko: Sup, Jim. I don't think it's dumb at all. Common, yes, but not dumb. With 20 minutes left in the chat, let's put it to a poll, shall we?
DougWilson: Do you believe in this yinzer phenomanon known as "PITTing"? It has some merit for Pitt football since 1982. But I think it started as Murphy's Law.
Brian Batko: (honestly, if the use of "Pitt-ing" could get Narduzzi to go off on a rant like that, that would be fun)
Chris : I still don't get what the deal is with Damar Hamlin. Is he still out indefinitely?
Brian Batko: 'fraid so, Chris. While I knew he was limited all camp, I was actually a bit surprised to see Hamlin not dressed Saturday vs. YSU. I take that to be a bad sign, but I'll defer to Narduzzi's remarks that Hamlin will "no doubt" play at some point this season.
The RVS: Do you really think a girl got Rice dumped on her head bc she was wearing a PSU shirt? This is the hardcore reporting we expect.
Brian Batko: RVS - I am INTRIGUED by this story! We were just discussing it in the lunchroom at the Post-Gazette and whether it's fake news. First, let me say, if it is legitimate, that's completely awful, imbecilic behavior. But I'm pretty sure on social media that the victim in question turned right around and started tweeting Chipotle for free food and Penn State for free tickets to the game. I'm skeptical...
YinzerStyle: If there is one player who needs to have a big game on Saturday for Pitt to win, who is it? My vote is for Quadree Henderson, think he's the only player who can single handedly change the game for Pitt
Brian Batko: QH is a good pick, but I actually think it's the guy I've been asked about most in this here chat: Max Browne. Granted, maybe all he needs to really do is manage the game and get the ball to his playmakers, but come on. Pitt needs to score points, a lot of points, to win this game, and that's going to fall on Max Browne. So he's my choice.
SOMDPanther: Bricen Garner was a pleasant surprise on Saturday. Can you give us the name of the guy who will surprise us on Saturday?
Brian Batko: Sean Idowu - I've got him down for a splash play or two
The RVS: Is the game on Saturday Penn State's Super Bowl?
Brian Batko: Yes
YinzerStyle: Would you consider this a bad season for Pitt if they finish 7-5, don't beat Penn State and don't win the Coastal Division?
Brian Batko: Pretty much, yeah. I mean, that's basically what I originally predicted and more-or-less expect to happen, but when does a Pitt football season ever really go as expected?
DK: Did you see any marked improvement in the secondary from last year debacle ?
Brian Batko: In some sense, yes. I thought Avonte Maddox and Dane Jackson both made some nice plays on the ball. Bricen Garner impressed me, as brilliant chatter SOMDPanther mentioned above. I'm not sold on the unit, but if it can make more plays than last year and just sort of hold the line until Jordan Whitehead returns, that's something of a win.
peanutbutter: Do you find value in the obviously vanilla gameplan? It seemed to work last year, but that was a much more veteran team. I wonder if the reps could have helped a young team. I could go the other way too, maybe PSU will look at the Ytown score and not know whats coming. Your thoughts?
Brian Batko: peanutbutter asking about vanilla has me thinking: why is peanut butter and chocolate so popular but peanut butter and vanilla is not a thing? Is it bad? On their own merits, both peanut butter and vanilla are very good, in my opinion. We might've just broken new ground here, folks.
Optimist: Okay, lets pretend to be optimistic. Pitt beats PSU. Does that have them ranked heading into week 3?
Brian Batko: Ehhhh I think it depends on who else ahead of Pitt loses in this hypothetical
The RVS: Brian, do you want to pull your hair out reading some of these questions? Do you think people put too much stock on one game that Pitt wanted to show very little from a scheme standpoint?
Brian Batko: I don't want to pull my hair out ever, because I don't have that much of it
SOMDPanther: If you had to bring a Pitt QB back from the 2000's to play PSU this Saturday, which would you choose? Rutherford or Palko.
Brian Batko: Joe Flacco, bro
D2: Is it possible that Pitt can control clock with their running game and keep PSU off the field
Brian Batko: Interesting theory, D2. Not a bad idea, either. Qadree Ollison, Darrin Hall and the boys in the backfield could really help the cause if they can do some damage and churn out tough yards. But I still think Pitt needs to score a lot of points more so than shorten the game. Maybe I'm wrong, though; I'm not a football coach.
John : McSorley and Barkley are the ones who stand out on Penn State's offense, but their receiving threats (esp. Gesicki at 6'6" 250 lbs.) are just as formidable due to their size and athletic ability. The linebackers and defensive backs for Pitt will have their hands full trying to contain them.
Brian Batko: Yeah man, Mike Gesicki might be the best tight end in the country. The receivers on the perimeter are dangerous as well. Penn State's offense is really good.
mountain: Which o-lineman goes to backup now? The center?
Brian Batko: That's my guess, but I surmise Pitt's coaches would tell you that's the good thing about depth and competition, that no one can rest on his laurels.
Pope: Should we just stop the transfer QB stuff already and just let DiNucci play and get experience for next year? Otherwise, we will have the same QB growing pains again next year.
Brian Batko: Probably not, no, given that the coaching staff think Max Browne is the best option. But DiNucci should still have the inside track next season, assuming all the praise for him this camp was genuine.
Pete: whats up with Paris Ford?
Brian Batko: As far as I know, just still behind in the playbook and trying to get caught up. Obviously, Narduzzi wouldn't have felt comfortable putting Ford out there Saturday, because he wasn't even dressed. I find that a bit odd, but maybe he's really just that far behind the 8 ball.
The RVS: If Narduzzi and Franklin were to compete in a decathlon who would win?
Brian Batko: I have to see Narduzzi on an almost daily basis, so my money's on him.
HTP4ever: I see that Kwantel Raines will be at the Penn state game this Saturday....and standing on Penn State's sideline! This does not bode well for Pitt to land this guy from their own backyard if they lose big not to mention the big home crowd and game day atmosphere at Penn state.
Brian Batko: It's a home game for Penn State. I don't think this matters.
stashy: The D line was getting pushed around a bit. How big of a factor is the dismissal of Blair & Telani
Brian Batko: Certainly doesn't help to have your two most experienced D-linemen get the boot between spring and summer camp
Steen: With Franklin mentioning Henderson as their big concern in Pitt's offense, does that open up the possibility of more trickery off the jet sweep, similar to what we saw with Aston at Clemson? Keying on the jet sweep could open up the inside run game.
Matthew, NY: Prediction/final score?
Brian Batko: George Aston is gonna come out in the second half and lead the team back to a win Willis Reed-style.
but really, I'll say Penn State wins by a touchdown
Brian Batko: OK ladies and gentlemen, that's all for today. Sorry I couldn't get to all the questions. Maybe next week!






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.