Heather Lyke’s name was rarely mentioned during the prolonged standoff between the Pitt basketball program and its former shooting guard Cameron Johnson, who was hoping to land at North Carolina as a graduate transfer.

For the new Pitt athletic director, though, it was one of her first and perhaps highest-profile ordeals, the kind that can shape the tenor of a tenure and how it is ultimately remembered.

In the face of mounting public pressure, and with a clarification from the NCAA, the athletic department eventually relented, granting Johnson a full release after initially declaring he lose a year of competitive eligibility for transferring within the ACC, even as a graduate.

Having underwent what became a very public process, Lyke believes the NCAA needs to reassess its policies and rules as they relate to graduate transfers, going so far as to say graduate transfers should be subject to the same year-of-residence requirement before competing that undergraduate transfers face.

Advertise with us

“In a big-picture conversation, it’s a good opportunity for the NCAA to take a look at what’s happening with regards to graduate transfers,” Lyke said to a group of reporters Tuesday at Petersen Events Center, her first public comments since the saga surrounding Johnson concluded June 8. “The ones who are transferring, what’s the actual completion rate for the graduate degree for which they are transferring to? I think it’s significantly low. I think we need to reevaluate the graduate transfer rule in general.”

Graduate transfers can, by rule, be immediately eligible at their selected destination. Like many other schools, Pitt has benefitted from the rule even in the past six months, having received commitments from Max Browne (Southern California) in football and Monty Boykins (Lafayette) in men’s basketball.

With no NCAA rules prohibiting them from doing so, however, schools and conferences are able to place restrictions on the movement of those players, as Pitt did with Johnson. The elements of the case itself — from Johnson’s academic accomplishments, having graduated in three years with a 3.9 GPA, to the increasing attention paid to the rights and welfare of college athletes — made it a national talking point, one pushed most prominently by ESPN analyst Jay Bilas.

Though Pitt held firm to its stance for weeks, it gave Johnson an unconditional release after the athletic department was handed an interpretation of the graduate transfer rule that stated a graduate transfer who wasn’t given a full release was permanently ineligible, an option Lyke described as “unduly harsh.”

“That’s never what we intended,” Lyke said. “He did terrific things here. We want him to be eligible. We thought he should serve a year of residence like any other transfer in the country has to serve a year of residence.”

Advertise with us

Johnson’s situation was, Lyke said, a unique one she doesn’t envision being faced with regularly, if ever again. While his trial set a new precedent, it likely isn’t going to cause a flood of graduates eagerly looking to join an intra-conference foe.

As contentious and awkward as the stalemate was at times, Lyke believes it ended without any lingering animosity, adding she got a thankful text message from Johnson’s father, Gil, when the release was granted.

“Things ended as amicably as they could in that sense,” she said. “We certainly wish him well. I think they feel appreciative they have the opportunity to go and play. I don’t think there are bad undertones there.”

How Johnson’s departure and the drama that engulfed it will affect Pitt in the future — namely, whether it will mar the perception of the program and coach Kevin Stallings on the recruiting trail — is uncertain. The school that Lyke has gotten to know over the past three months, however, makes her confident in its ability to attract and retain athletes.

“To finish here in four years and graduate and think they want to go somewhere else, I don’t think we recruit that way,” she said. “The hope is they want to be a part of this program and they’ve had such an incredible experience and we’ve invested so much in them, they want to be a part of it.”

Advertise with us

Craig Meyer: cmeyer@post-gazette.com and Twitter @CraigMeyerPG

On the Clock: Will Pitt ever have an on-campus football stadium?