The Final Four tips off Saturday, the glorious culmination of college basketball season. You don’t need me to tell you it was a not-so-glorious college basketball season for Pitt.
Meanwhile, on the South Side, the Pitt football team goes through the paces of spring practice three days a week, six months from the start of the real games, mind you.
So why not liven things up a bit with a hypothetical combining football and basketball? Maybe it’s just because I’m a huge basketball guy who now covers football, or maybe because Pitt football has had a lot of great basketball players in recent years (Darrelle Revis, Jon Baldwin, Mike Shanahan, T.J. Clemmings, etc.), but I felt compelled to pose this question: Who would be the best basketball starting five comprising players from the current Pitt football roster?
I posed this question to some former and current players, as well as the head man, Pat Narduzzi. I also have my own take after some painstaking research on this very important subject. But first, a master list of all the current Pitt football players who hooped in high school (as best I can tell from official team bios) and what we know about their careers on the hardwood:
• Maurice Ffrench - guard/forward, 11.4 points per game* at New Brunswick (NJ)
• Ben DiNucci - starting shooting guard, mostly a 3-point specialist at Pine-Richland
• Max Browne - 5.5 ppg, 4.2 rpg** at Skyline (Wash.)
• Damar Hamlin - 3.4 ppg** at Central Catholic
• Tre Tipton - 11.4 ppg, all-section guard at Apollo-Ridge
• Aaron Mathews - starter at Clairton
• Henry Miller - played at Gateway (Fla.)
• Quadree Henderson - once ranked the No. 8 7th-grader in Delaware!
• Ruben Flowers - starting forward for Lima Senior, which lost in the Ohio state championship
• Dane Jackson - 28 ppg, section player of the year, Class A all-state at Cornell
• Avonte Maddox - starting guard at Detroit’s Martin Luther King High School
• Rashad Weaver - 6.7 ppg, 7.9 rpg** at Cooper City (Fla.) with outdated YouTube highlights
• Ryan Winslow - starting center at La Salle College High School (Pa.)
• Jake Zilinskas - starter at WPIAL champion Indiana (Pa.)
• Elijah Zeise - 11 ppg, starting center at North Allegheny
• Bricen Garner - 5.7 ppg**, starting guard at Central Catholic
• Kaezon Pugh - 11 ppg, 10 rpg for undefeated WPIAL/PIAA champion Aliquippa
• Mark Bernsdorff - played at Sylvania Northview (Ohio)
• Rob Boatright - played at Clairton
• Devon Edwards - 5.6 ppg** at Eastmoor Academy (Ohio)
• Rimoni Dorsey - played at Trinity Episcopal School (Va.)
• Erik Sellers - played at Clearfield (Pa.)
• Jim Medure - starter for Neshannock
• Jaryd Jones-Smith - played at West Catholic (Pa.), can throw down and is very happy about it
• Quintin Wirginis - played at Fox Chapel
• Tony Pilato - 12 ppg, 9 rpg at Hempfield Area
• Brian O’Neill - 13.5 ppg, 8.2 rpg, 3 bpgm first-team all-state, Delaware Player of the Year!
• Bryce Hargrove - 20 ppg, 10 rpg, 1,400-point scorer at Coventry (Ohio)
• Jester Weah - 12.2 ppg, Wisconsin all-state at Madison Memorial, has a legit AAU mixtape
• Rashad Wheeler - 4.1 ppg, 1.8 rpg** at Central Catholic
• Shane Roy - played at Reading (Ohio)
• Deslin Alexandre - played at Deerfield Beach (Fla.)
• DeAndre Schifino - 16.4 ppg, 1,000-point scorer at Penn Hills
* per NJ.com
** per maxpreps.com
Who would be the starting five basketball players from PItt football?
So with that out of the way, let’s get to the selections. First up, Brian O’Neill, the new starting left tackle, Piesman Trophy winner and, apparently, noted Delaware basketball phenomenon. I knew O’Neill was a good high school player, but didn’t realize (or forgot) he was state player of the year, even being on the same team as now-Villanova guard Donte DiVincenzo. Impressive. Here’s the squad he picked off the top of his head:
PG - Avonte Maddox
SG - Bricen Garner
SF - Dane Jackson
PF - Ruben Flowers
C - Brian O’Neill (obviously)
Bench: Ryan Winslow, Tony Pilato, Alex Officer
A couple things here:
• O’Neill felt pretty confident about Maddox’s skills, which is interesting because I couldn’t dig up much about his basketball career in high school. But Maddox’s athletic exploits were all over the place, from football to basketball and he was even an excellent baseball player who considered pursuing that sport in college, as well.
• Garner wasn’t a big scorer at Central Catholic, but he’s another freaky athlete (also a track & field standout) and was actually suggested by fellow WPIAL product Dane Jackson, who was standing nearby.
• Which brings us to Jackson, an obvious pick given his high-scoring days at Cornell
• O’Neill also wanted to give some love to a few other players, hence the bench. Can’t say I knew about Winslow’s basketball prowess, but I had seen Pilato play at Hempfield. He was a suggestion from Ben DiNucci sitting next to O’Neill, who then totally went off the radar by shouting out Alex Officer and his fundamental game. As far as I can tell, Officer never even played basketball at Eastridge in Rochester, N.Y., but O’Neill might just be biased toward his fellow lineman.
Also weighing in was wide receiver Tre Tipton, obviously snubbed from O’Neill’s team. But in the interest of unbiased research, he was unaware of that when I asked him to make his picks. He said the team plays together every once in a while, and here are his five:
C - Bryce Hargrove
PF - Devon Edwards
SF - Ruben Flowers
SG - Dane Jackson
PG - Tre Tipton
Bench: Quadree Henderson, Avonte Maddox
At first glance, O’Neill seems like a huge miss here, given what we know about his resume. But here’s some of Tipton’s logic on his selections:
• “Dane Jackson, for sure. He’s the GOAT [greatest of all time]. I’m not gonna lie, he’s the GOAT when it comes to playing basketball.”
• “Bryce Hargrove is good. The big man down low, he can post up, shimmy left and right.”
• “I’m gonna say myself, just because I believe I’m a good passer. If you don’t got confidence in yourself, then who you got confidence in? Point guard, I’m a little disher, I get some dimes here and there.”
• “Honestly, Quadree plays great defense. He’s honestly the most annoying defender I’ve ever been around. You can’t get around him. And then coming off the bench, we’d have, probably, Avonte. Gotta go defense a little bit, too.”
In addition to current Panthers, I consulted a recent former Panther, wide receiver Dontez Ford, who’s now preparing for the NFL. But Ford was a good basketball player himself at Sto-Rox High School, so I figured he was worth asking. Of course, he’d put himself on any Pitt football-fielded basketball team, but limiting it only to current players, here was his squad:
PG - Quadree Henderson
SG - Ben DiNucci
SF - Ruben Flowers
PF - Devon Edwards
C - Brian O’Neill
• “I know Brian can hoop. Ruben Flowers can hoop. I haven’t seen Ben play, but I heard he was the point guard or shooting guard at Pine-Richland. It’s hard to come up with a starting five because I don’t really know everybody’s game, but Ruben and Brian gotta be on there for sure. Dev Edwards, he can hoop.”
• I suggested Aaron Mathews, who like Ford is a receiver who played football and basketball at a small WPIAL school in Clairton, but Ford wasn’t quite buying it: “I never played against him, but when we scrimmaged Clairton, they were terrible [laugh]. They whooped us in football, but in basketball, they weren’t that good.”
• Lastly, Ford rounded out his five with Henderson, whom he he heard “was decent at point guard back in Delaware.”
And perhaps the most important opinion here, the top dog himself, Pat Narduzzi. I put him on the spot after practice Thursday to pick a starting five off the top of his head, and here’s what he came up with (he did not give positions, but I’ll designate those):
PG - Jordan Whitehead
SG - Dane Jackson
SF - Jester Weah
PF - Jaryd Jones-Smith
C - Brian O’Neill
Wow, that’s a lot of beef down low.
• Right off the bat, he said he’s going to take O’Neill underneath the hoop “at the 5, or whatever you guys call it now.”
• He then went right to Dane Jackson, so clearly the hoops reputation of those two is not limited to their teammates.
• Narduzzi: “You gotta take Jordan Whitehead” — record scratch — Now wait a minute, here. This one’s out of left field, certainly off the grid compared to the other answers. Whitehead didn’t even play basketball at Central Valley High School beyond his sophomore year, so this selection is suspect, but maybe Narduzzi is just putting the utmost faith in Whitehead’s absurd athleticism here. And to be fair, Whitehead’s dad, Greg, did play Division III hoops at the College of Staten Island.
• “I don’t know if Jester can shoot or not, but as an athlete, I’d take him too.” — Oh, sure, now he’s worried about shooting. But it doesn’t matter, coach, that mixtape is fire.
• At this point, after those four, Narduzzi started scanning through the roster in his head to make sure he didn’t miss anyone. “There’s some other guys that are gonna get mad. Let me look at the front four, linebackers — no. That’s a tough question. Offensively, um, maybe Jaryd Jones-Smith. Another big guy, get some power game going.”
• Maybe Narduzzi’s just really impressed by Jones-Smith’s YouTube dunk. But of course the defensive-minded football coach picks two monstrous O-linemen and wants a “power game” in the low post. Just don’t try to run the ball behind those two; that’s a travel.
Now, after all of this discussion and analysis, here are the five guys from Pitt’s football team that I, Brian Batko, think would make the best basketball team:
C - Brian O’Neill
PF - Bryce Hargrove
SF - Jester Weah
SG - Ruben Flowers
PG - Dane Jackson
• The high school resumes and anecdotal evidence in support of O’Neill and Hargrove were too much for me to pass up as my inside duo.
• Weah and Flowers are going to be dunking on people left and right. If there’s any position on the football field that translates closest to basketball and vice versa, it’s wide receiver (or tight end, hence the Tony Gonzalez, Antonio Gates, Jimmy Grahams of the world).
• Jackson’s going to be a score-first point guard, but he also needs to distribute and work the ball into the post when possible. Shooting and ball-handling might be a real concern for this squad — Flowers was a forward in high school — but our athleticism and size will be strong across the board.
• Guys who just missed, I also considered (call them my bench) Tipton, DiNucci, the point guards Maddox and Henderson, and walk-on tight end DeAndre Schifino, who got a lot of buckets at Penn Hills but just didn’t quite fit into this lineup.
I’m putting this conversation to rest — for now. But don’t sleep on Pitt’s incoming class of 2017 signees. Steubenville tight end Charles Reeves was a 1,000-point scorer, Paris Ford was a baller his first two years in high school, and Grant Carrigan, Gabe Houy, Kyle Nunn, Tyler Sear and Carson Van Lynn all played, as well.
Enjoy the Final Four.
Brian Batko: bbatko@post-gazette.com and Twitter @BrianBatko.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.