Pitt's NCAA tournament hopes may be on life support, but the Pitt mailbag continues going strong (kind of).

This week, we tackle the important topics of the day, from Pitt's postseason aspirations to the Panthers' second-half collapses this season. Oh, and being late February, the Oscars.

We do these every Friday, so if you've ever got a question you'd like to be answered, you can email me at cmeyer@post-gazette.com or hit me up on Twitter @CraigMeyerPG.

The question that just won't die. For the past few weeks, Pitt's been stuck in a position similar to Lloyd Christmas at the end of Dumb and Dumber. The likelihood of a happy ending is so obviously bleak, but he's still holding out hope Mary Samsonite will say yes to a date. Yes, I'm saying there's a chance ... but not much of one.

Advertise with us

Pitt's had two games in the past 10 days in which a loss seemed to kill most any kind of a realistic chance at making the NCAA tournament. The Panthers, however, responded from a demoralizing loss to a fellow bubble dweller in Virginia Tech, by turning around and beating a top-20 Florida State team by double digits a few days later. Just when you thought it couldn't possibly get any more dire, they went out and did that ... and totally redeemed themselves (sorry, I'll stop). After the loss to Wake Forest earlier this week, they have a chance to regain some traction against North Carolina on Saturday, which, given what this Pitt team has done this season against any and all logic, will probably be a win.

The dreams of a spot in the field of 68 aren't officially dashed until a team loses in the conference tournament, but this team's got little, if any, margin for error. Of late, I've held firm to the idea that 19 wins gets the Panthers some solid footing in legitimate bubble conversations, though it obviously depends upon how and against whom those wins come. I'm going to work off the assumption this team, given its lack of depth, can't make any kind of a deep run in the ACC tournament. I'd be shocked if they win more than two games and even two might be a stretch. Basically, the two most workable scenarios are winning the final three games and adding a win in Brooklyn or going 2-1 the rest of the regular season and winning two in the tournament.

The odds aren't in their favor, but it's still a discussion worth having, at least for now.

I've long thought we — that is, most of us without an incredibly nuanced and deep knowledge of the game's tactics — use coaching as a way to try to explain what we can't rationalize in more conventional ways. Basically, if something seems like a mystery, we attribute it to coaching. It's a cliche to say coaches get too much of the credit when everything's rolling and too much of the blame with the situation worsens, but there's a lot of truth to it.

Of course, that isn't to absolve Kevin Stallings or this team. The trends are obvious, almost regardless of who their opponent is. The inconsistencies have been most notable in the extended stretches in which an otherwise good offense can't seem to buy a basket. In fact, after Tuesday's loss at Wake Forest, three of the five and five of the 13 worst shooting performances in a half in program history have come THIS SEASON. A look at that list.

Advertise with us

12.5 percent — Rutgers (2012)

15.6 — Seton Hall (1992)

16 — Louisville (2017)

16.7 — Wake Forest (2017)

17.9 — Clemson (2017)

Advertise with us

19.2 — Maryland (1998)

19.2 — Fordham (1961)

20 — Louisville (2006)

20 — West Virginia (2010)

20.7 — Syracuse (2017)

Advertise with us

20.7 — Notre Dame (2002)

20.7 — St. John's (2005)

21.2 — Duquesne (2016)

The Wake Forest loss was particularly egregious in that the four made field goals in the second half were the fewest in a half in program history, and the 19-point blown lead in the first half was the third biggest ever.

It's worth noting only three of those five historically bad shooting performances this season came in the second half. It's not exclusively a late-game phenomenon. But you're absolutely right that the team's struggles in the final 20 minutes have been palpable. Part of it may be coaching, but, at the risk of sounding like a broken record, Stallings is limited in the adjustments he can make given the personnel he has, which is what leads Pitt into these situations to begin with. It plays its five starters so many minutes, particularly with Ryan Luther out, that it's quite likely their legs get tired as the game goes on. When your legs start to give out, nothing falls off as noticeably as your shot.

Advertise with us

Lombardi has built up an impressive head coaching resume in his time at IUP, where he has gone 250-97 in 11 seasons, including a 25-2 mark this season. That Dixon guy, though, was probably significantly more important to Pitt's rise to being a national power, perhaps even more than Howland was in his quick and thoroughly effective rebuild, than Lombardi was in three seasons as an assistant.

As a side note, Jamie Dixon's early Pitt staffs has some nice coaching talent. There was the aforementioned Lombardi, along with Barry Rohrssen, who helped provide a valuable recruiting link to the New York area that allowed the program to thrive, and Orlando Antigua, who had a disastrous tenure on and off the court as a head coach at South Florida, but who did excellent work as an assistant at Memphis and Kentucky once his time at Pitt was over.

And on to the Corey Cohen Memorial (Even Though He's Not Dead) Non-Sequitur

A question whose excellent is matched only by its timeliness. I didn't get out to the movies as much as I would have liked given how crazy basketball season has gotten at times and didn't see a few of the Best Picture nominees (Lion, Hacksaw Ridge, Hidden Figures, Arrival and Manchester By The Sea, the last of which I'm really bummed about since Casey Affleck evidently spends half the movie wearing a Dugout Cafe t-shirt).

Anyhow, here's how I'd rank the films I saw this year:

Advertise with us

1. O.J.: Made in America — It's nominated for best documentary, not best picture, but it's an easy choice for me at No. 1. In about eight hours, it successfully encapsulated the story of race and fame in the United States while seamlessly intertwining the two topics through the symbol of O.J. Simpson. Also, O.J.'s childhood buddy with the super raspy voice needs to narrate audio books.

2. Hell or High Water — You can sell me on most anything with Jeff Bridges and this certainly didn't disappoint.

3. Moonlight — A little slow at times, but a powerful and sometimes heartbreaking coming-of-age story of a marginalized young man. Mahershala Ali's the man.

4. La La Land — A really good movie that, because of the praise it has received and what seems like an inevitable best picture win, is taking some excessive and undeserved criticism of late. Ryan Gosling and Emma Stone are a magical on-screen duo...except in Gangster Squad. That movie stunk.

5. The Nice Guys — There are few, if any, things better in life than a good buddy cop movie and this was one of those. I'm holding out for a sequel.

Advertise with us

6. Weiner — Man, Anthony Weiner is a terrible human being. Was really surprised this didn't get a best documentary nomination.

7. Deadpool — Any movie that has "X Gon' Give It To Ya" in its trailer is destined to be a masterpiece.

Craig Meyer: cmeyer@post-gazette.com and Twitter @CraigMeyerPG.