Surely, the Pitt men’s basketball team couldn’t have actually given up 106 points in 1906, right? Surely, Western University of Pennsylvania, as it was then known, couldn’t have been WUP’d by 93 points against Westminster that long ago, could it?
There was no 3-point line. No shot clock. Heck, the baskets didn’t even have the bottoms cut out of them yet.
But it really did happen. Westminster scored 106 points in 1906, in a game it allowed just 13. It’s such a mind-boggling result that even the very process of verifying it has become confusing throughout the past century-plus.
Let’s explain:
As the final seconds ticked down — or perhaps long before that — of Tuesday night’s blowout loss to Louisville at Petersen Events Center, the glaring question became obvious: Where does this rank among Pitt’s worst losses ever? An initial review of the Pitt men’s basketball media guide turned up two possibilities: A 51-point loss to Wichita State in 1964, or that 93-point Westminster thumping in 1906.
Eventually, it was decided via Pitt’s sports information department that the 1906 score was correct. And yet, skepticism lingered. No other result in Pitt’s inaugural season even saw a team reach 50 points, let alone 106. And just a little more than a month prior, Pitt met Westminster and only lost by 20, 35-15.
Read More
It seems the confusion begins with the 1907 edition of Pitt’s yearbook, “The Owl.” In it, Westminster’s score is listed as 1(?)6. Yeah, that typist couldn’t believe it either. At some point, this misplaced question mark got lost in translation. Some previous Pitt basketball media guides list the score as “Westminster 16, Pitt 13.” After all, that does seem more likely.
But that score has since been updated to 106, which is why Pitt’s loss to Louisville has uniformly been referred to as only the second-worst loss in program history. And it is, so the next glaring question is: How?
Here’s an excerpt from author Dick Minteer’s 2004 book, “The Glory Years – When the Towering Titans of Tiny Westminster Slew the Giants of College Basketball” courtesy of Westminster sports information director Nathan LaRiccia:
Eleven days after the loss at Youngstown, the Western University of Pennsylvania, [now the University of Pittsburgh], came to Westminster. They shouldn’t have. The game would go into the Westminster record book as the largest margin of victory of all time. Twenty seconds after the game started, Westminster’s. D.R. Calhoun hit a field goal and the rout was on. By halftime, Westminster led 65-7. Games were played in two 20-minute halves, but this game was far out of reach that the second half was cut to 15 minutes. Capwell scored all of Pitt’s 13 points. For Westminster, it was Elliott banging in 14 field goals to lead all scorers with 28 points. Five Westminster players scored in double figures. Lee Roy Deevers poured in 26, Hugh Lambie added 18, W.L. Marks had 16, and Calhoun had 10. The final score was 106-13. Westminster posted its highest scoring mark to date and its largest margin of victory.
Then, Minteer delivered this parting shot:
Here’s something to think about. Since the bottom of the net wasn’t removed until 1911, who was the poor guy that had to keep climbing and getting the ball out?
WUP coach Benjamin F. Printz’s postgame comments remain unknown.
Brian Batko: bbatko@post-gazette.com and Twitter @BrianBatko.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.