For years, there was a certain symbolism to Petersen Events Center and what it represented for the program that called it home.

After the building opened in 2002, the fortunes of Pitt men’s basketball drastically changed. A program that floundered for much of the 1990s rapidly became one of college basketball’s most consistently excellent brands, emerging as a regular presence in the top 10 of the national polls while playing its home games in front of one of the more raucous crowds in the sport.

One-third of the way through the 2016-17 season, it has served as an ever-present reminder of where the program currently sits. Pitt’s five home games this season have accounted for five of the 11 lowest-attended regular-season games in the venue’s 14-year history, with the pockets of empty seats and relatively stale atmosphere standing in stark contrast to how it was even five or six years ago.

With a first-year coach and several renovations made to Petersen Events Center, the glaring dip is puzzling and seems to hint at a deeper, more fundamental problem that faces the program. To those in the athletic department, it’s not a stand-alone issue; rather, it’s the continuation of a trend years in the making.

Advertise with us

“We’ve been on a three-year slide,” Pitt athletic director Scott Barnes said earlier this month. “This isn’t about one year; this is about a gradual decrease of our season-ticket base for three-plus years. It’s obviously something we’re dealing with, but I’ll tell you, it’s not unlike what a lot of my colleagues and even when I was a member of the men’s basketball committee talk a lot about — how do you, in today’s day and age of overexposure, television and digital platforms, get them here?”

The reasons and explanations for the decline are wide-ranging.

The relatively weak home non-conference schedule that has so far featured contests against Eastern Michigan, Gardner-Webb, Yale, Morehead State and Buffalo has been a common culprit. While the attendance for those games likely will pale in comparison to what the Panthers will draw for ACC games, the small crowds for the early slate of games are still abnormally low. In the previous 14 seasons at Petersen Events Center, the average attendance for the first five games against opponents from outside the six major conferences was never lower than 7,287. This season, it is at 6,355.

There are also the obstacles Pitt faces being a college in a professional market, competing against the Steelers, Pirates, Penguins and even its own football team for entertainment dollars. That challenge only has grown in the past several years as the Panthers slipped from their perch among college basketball’s top programs, with the .640 win percentage in Jamie Dixon’s final five seasons representing a sizable downturn from his .783 mark the previous eight seasons.

“I think Pitt is at a stage right now where they have to build that back up, that rabid fan base for basketball, where you take advantage of every chance to go to a game because you may not get tickets to go to another game,” said John Clark, a sport management professor at Robert Morris who specializes in sales, sport marketing and sport consumers.

Advertise with us

Attendance has been down across college basketball as a whole, making it far from a Pitt-specific trend. With greater accessibility to games broadcast online and on TV, along with the increased prevalence of high-definition television, 1,010,000 fewer people attended Division I games last season than they did in the 2007-08 season, amounting to an average of 581 fewer people per game, according to NCAA attendance reports.

The Panthers, however, also are impacted by a series of recent and troubling factors.

Multiple longtime season-ticket holders contacted for this story expressed doubt about keeping their seats beyond this season, citing reasons that included pessimism about next season, concerns about recent recruiting shortcomings, a perceived lack of heart and star power from the current team and trepidation over the hiring of Kevin Stallings as coach in March.

The move from Dixon to Stallings was met with, at best, a lukewarm reception, something that likely mitigated the excitement that generally carries over with coaching hires. The presence of a new coach, however, doesn’t guarantee an attendance boost.

In the past three seasons, major-conference teams with a first-year coach experienced an average 2.14 percent attendance uptick in their first five games compared to the first five games in the previous coach’s final year. Still, 10 of those 22 schools witnessed an attendance decrease in that time, with four programs posting attendance losses even greater than Pitt’s 9.69 percent downturn (interestingly enough, Stallings’ former employer, Vanderbilt, has the lowest at minus-15.59 percent).

Advertise with us

“One of the first things I heard was how everybody had the desire to get the Pete back to the way it was several years ago,” Stallings said. “I didn’t know exactly what that meant. I didn’t know what it had gotten to and where it had come from.”

Barnes and the Pitt athletic department have made it a priority to re-engage the school’s fan base, in men’s basketball and in other sports. He staged a town hall meeting in January, with nearly 500 people in attendance, and launched a fan experience committee. In an attempt to broaden the Panthers’ customer base, he emphasized mini-plans that offered tickets to a handful of games instead of the entire season, an area in which he said there was growth in sales.

Alarming as the numbers may seem and whatever challenges Pitt might be facing, there’s solace in knowing these difficulties are not unique to the Panthers.

“It’s not a problem that we’re the only ones dealing with,” Barnes said. “It’s a problem. Even in football, it’s almost like you have to recreate the man cave at the venue. You almost have to give them everything they have at home to get some of them to step up. We’re all dealing with that. It’s something we’re challenged by, but we also think there’s an opportunity to reverse that trend.”

Craig Meyer: cmeyer@post-gazette.com and Twitter @CraigMeyerPG.

Advertise with us