Kevin Stallings understands he’s in a precarious position.

The first-year Pitt men’s basketball coach prides himself on honesty and being forthcoming, even if it reveals unflattering truths about his team, but any time questions are naturally raised about his modus operandi and how it compares to that of his predecessor, Jamie Dixon, a dangerous line is presented that Stallings frequently has to toe or completely evade. The way I do things isn’t better, he often has said; it’s just different.

The situation that faced Stallings’ employer at the time it hired him and what currently faces Stallings was and is much more perilous.

The decisions an athletic department encounters when it has to replace a longtime coach, particularly one as successful as Dixon, can have long-standing effects on a program’s well-being, shaping its continued success or plunging it in a more undesirable direction. It’s an all-important choice, one that Pitt, with Stallings, likely won’t see the full impact of for several years.

Advertise with us

In the short term, and with the Panthers sporting an 8-2 record, Stallings’ adjustment to his players, and vice versa, is an ongoing learning process.

“They deal with different kinds of expectations,” Stallings said, declining to specify what those differences in expectations were. “I try to be as tolerant as I can to what they’re used to and what they’re good at, but there are some levels where, because of how I need things to be in the future for my own comfort level, I sort of have to demand that those things are that way now.”

While not providing a complete answer, recent history offers some insight into how those succeeding long-tenured and decorated coaches fare.

Since 1985, the year the NCAA tournament expanded to 64 teams, there have been 31 instances in which a coach at a major-conference school — that is, in the ACC, Big Ten, Big East, Big 12, Pac-12 and SEC — was replaced after spending at least 10 years at the institution and posting a winning record in his final season there. Of those 31 occurrences:

• The average win percentage of the departing coach was 0.652. The win percentage of his successor was 0.593.

Advertise with us

• The average first-year win percentage of the new coach was 0.608. The average win percentage of the previous coach in his final season was 0.662.

• Ten of the successors had a better win percentage in their tenure than his predecessor.

• Twelve of the successors had a better win percentage in their first season than their predecessor had in his final season.

• Fifteen of the successors were fired or resigned while manning a struggling program. Six left to take a job with a different school or a pro team. Five are still coaching at the same school.

• The average tenure of the successor was 5.3 years.

Advertise with us

While there isn’t an ironclad conclusion — there isn’t a Tom Izzo for every Craig Esherick, but such success stories certainly exist — the sizable majority of coaches who replaced accomplished stalwarts didn’t fare as well as their predecessor. The data is somewhat self-selective, as a coach who stays at a school 10 years or more is most likely a pretty successful one, but it’s nonetheless the unenviable situation in which Pitt and Stallings find themselves.

Nearly nine months into his tenure, Stallings has, at the very least, established a strong connection with the group of players he inherited.

“There’s a lot more interaction with the team,” sophomore Cam Johnson said. “He’s very positive. You can’t pick a practice where he said more negative things than positive things. He’s good at motivating us and getting us ready to play. He’s a great guy just to interact with. If you have anything wrong, you can just call him and feel comfortable talking to him and go up and feel comfortable talking to him. That’s something I really appreciate and I’m sure most of my teammates really appreciate.”

The differences with Stallings have been noticeable so far, from the team’s overall pace to its defensive strategy. Even the things that have been relatively similar — like the way the Panthers play gap defense — have been taught differently.

Though history indicates it likely won’t, time will tell whether those practices help Pitt achieve the kind of success it did under its previous coach.

Advertise with us

“For me, the adjustment was to open my mind more,” senior Mike Young said. “Coach Dixon, he had a great system and how he wanted us to play. I just tried my best to go out there and execute whatever he wanted us to execute. With Coach Stallings, he opens my mind more in the sense of making more reads and letting me play and letting me think the game. That was the biggest adjustment.

“For the last two years, I’ve been kind of playing where it’s like you listen to the coach and whatever he wants, you go out there and execute it. Now, it’s like he’s telling me to go out there and play, use your high IQ, use your talent, use your skills and I’m going to put you in positions to do those things.”

Craig Meyer: cmeyer@post-gazette.com and Twitter @CraigMeyerPG.